Ontario PCs call for investigation into allegations Liberal staff destroyed documents

WATCH ABOVE: Ontario PC's say Liberal response to Trillium Power investigation "eerily similar" to handling of gas plant scandal

Ontario’s Progressive Conservatives are calling on the province’s information and privacy commissioner to investigate allegations from Trillium Power that documents relevant to a $500-million lawsuit against the government of Ontario were destroyed by officials from within former-Premier Dalton McGuinty’s office.

The call to investigate comes a day after Global News reported on new evidence that Trillium Power says shows that officials from within McGuinty’s office and the office of the minister of energy engaged in the deliberate destruction of documents after their court case had begun.

READ MORE: Trillium Power releases new evidence alleging Ontario Liberals destroyed documents during $500M lawsuit

The company says this was done to prevent it from being able to argue its claims in court and to erase information that may have been damaging to the government.

“In light of recent media reports, I am writing to you today asking that you investigate the actions of the Premier’s Office in relation to the alleged deletion of documents relating to the Trillium Power Wind Corporation’s $500 million lawsuit against the Ontario Government,” wrote Vic Fedeli, a PC MPP and leader the opposition, in a letter obtained exclusively by Global News.

Story continues below advertisement

WATCH: PC Party MPP Vic Fedeli demands investigation into allegations of deleted documents

Vic Fedeli demands answers on documents in Trillium Power lawsuit
Vic Fedeli demands answers on documents in Trillium Power lawsuit


“The evidence presented by [Trillium] is eerily reminiscent of the gas plants deleted documents scandal,” Fedeli wrote. “The people of Ontario have been through this song and dance before. It appears, as in the past, the Liberals’ general approach to issues management has been delete and delete again.”

Government denies allegations

Government lawyers and spokespeople deny Trillium’s allegations outright.

In its statement of defence — presented as part of the ongoing lawsuit between Trillium and the government — lawyers for the Ministry of the Attorney General state firmly that no documents related to Trillium’s case were “deliberately destroyed” by government officials.

WATCH: Community fed up with lack of action on wind turbine complaints

Community fed up with ministry’s response to wind turbine complaints
Community fed up with ministry’s response to wind turbine complaints

The lawyers also say Trillium’s allegations that the project was sidelined in favour of another project — that of Windstream Energy — are entirely untrue.

In response to allegations that officials from within the office of the ministry of energy engaged in the destruction of documents prior to March 2013, a spokesperson for Ontario’s current Minister of Energy, Glenn Thibeault, said the allegations have been investigated and proven to be untrue.

READ MORE: Ontario family says wind turbines have made life a ‘nightmare’

“In 2016, Trillium requested that the OPP investigate their allegations related to the moratorium on wind energy. Those allegations were thoroughly investigated and found to be unsubstantiated,” said Colin Nekolaichuk, the government spokesperson.

Story continues below advertisement

With respect to maintaining documents, Nekolaichuk said the government is committed to being open and transparent, and has taken action to strengthen the laws related to record keeping — working closely with provincial watchdogs to ensure the government follows best practices.

WATCH BELOW: Ex-McGuinty aide David Livingston sentenced to 4 months in jail for deleted gas plants emails

David Livingston to appeal sentencing in gas plants scandal: lawyer
David Livingston to appeal sentencing in gas plants scandal: lawyer

But John Kourtoff, CEO and owner of Trillium Power, alleges internal emails provided by the government in the lead up to the trial clearly show an intention to destroy evidence.

In legal documents, the Trillium references one such email, alleging it proves the government gave codenames to files related to offshore wind — making them more difficult to find when sifting through large volumes of records — and discussed plans to “purge emails, records, documents.”

The long-awaited Trillium trial is set to begin June 11 — four days after the provincial election — and is scheduled to last for three weeks.

Global News Redesign Global News Redesign
A fresh new look for Global News is here, tell us what you think
Take a Survey

Sponsored Stories