Opponents of TransCanada Corporation’s proposed Keystone XL oil pipeline argued on Tuesday that regulators in Nebraska had no authority to approve the line’s “alternative” path through the state and that the project should be considered dead.
The Nebraska Public Service Commission issued an approval for the line to pass through the state in late November, removing what appeared to be the last big regulatory obstacle for the long-delayed project, which has been backed by U.S. President Donald Trump.
But the commission’s approval was not for the route TransCanada had singled out in its application, but for an alternative that shifts it closer to an existing pipeline right-of-way down the eastern side of the state.
David Domina, an attorney for landowners along the Keystone XL route, argued at a commission hearing on Tuesday that Nebraska law specifies the regulatory body can only rule on TransCanada’s preferred route.
“It uses the singular word ‘route.’ It doesn’t use the… plural term ‘routes,'” Domina said. “It’s not a smorgasbord statute.”
He said many landowners along the alternative path had not been notified a pipeline might be crossing their property, and that the specific social and environmental impacts of the alternative path had not been properly studied.
READ MORE: TransCanada says it’s speaking with landowners along new Keystone XL route
Get weekly money news
Watch below: In November, an alternate route was approved for the Keystone XL pipeline project through Nebraska. It’s taken more than nine years and three tries to get here. Here’s a timeline.
Tuesday’s hearing was set after TransCanada filed a motion with the commission asking if it could amend its initial application, in a move to head off legal challenges.
By filing an amended application, “we are working to reduce the possibility of the PSC decision being overturned which would compromise our ability to build this project on time and on schedule,” a spokesman for the company told Reuters.
Pipeline opponents say that request should be denied because the Nebraska regulatory body’s statutes do not allow for retroactive amendments to such applications. The commission is considering TransCanada’s new application request.
While it is unclear how the commission will rule, the pipeline has strong political support stretching from the White House to the Nebraska governor’s mansion.
The proposed line, which would run about 1,899 kilometres from Hardisty, Alta., to Steele City, Neb., has been a lightning rod of controversy. Since it was proposed a decade ago, environmentalists have made it a symbol of their broader fight against fossil fuels and global warming. Business groups and Trump say it could lower fuel prices and create employment.
Trump handed TransCanada a federal permit for the pipeline in March as part of a broader agenda to boost the energy sector. That reversed a decision by former U.S. President Barack Obama in 2015 to block the project on grounds it would not bring significant enough economic benefits to outweigh its environmental impact.
-With files from Richard Valdmanis
Watch below: Some videos from Global News’ ongoing coverage of the Keystone XL pipeline.
-
![]()
Edmonton’s chief economist on Keystone XL pipeline approval through Nebraska -
![]()
Keystone XL pipeline: A timeline of events -
![]()
Is the approval of the Keystone XL Pipeline a good thing? -
![]()
Premier Rachel Notley calls Keystone XL expansion into Nebraska good news -
![]()
Alberta premier weighs in on Keystone XL approval through Nebraska -
![]()
Keystone XL decision leads to cautious optimism for potential construction contracts -
![]()
Nebraska approves alternate route for Keystone XL pipeline -
![]()
Keystone XL gets approval in Nebraska -
![]()
Retired TransCanada executive reacts to Nebraska Keystone XL approval -
![]()
South Dakota residents haven’t heard from TransCanada after Keystone XL pipeline leak -
![]()
Nebraska to rule on Keystone XL pipeline expansion -
![]()
Nebraska to rule on Keystone XL pipeline -
![]()
Drone footage puts the spotlight on Keystone oil pipeline spill -
![]()
Video shows scope of Keystone oil spill -
![]()
800,000 litres of oil spill from Keystone pipeline in U.S. -
![]()
Trump said he insisted on U.S. steel for Keystone – to a point -
![]()
Keystone XL symbol of Trump’s elimination of environmental regulations -
![]()
Roadblocks remain after Trump gives green light to Keystone XL pipeline -
![]()
Trump approves Keystone XL pipeline -
![]()
Keystone, Kinder Morgan, Energy East pipelines will reduce costs: Notley
Comments