September 11, 2017 4:01 pm
Updated: September 11, 2017 4:18 pm

Hearing begins into Hamilton city councillor’s carding allegation

A hearing involving Councillor Matthew Green's "carding" complaint against a Hamilton police officer started on Monday.

City of Hamilton

A hearing is underway that will decide if Hamilton’s only black city councillor was subjected to an arbitrary, unjustified and racially motivated street check by a local police officer.

READ MORE: Police Services Act hearing related to Hamilton carding complaint delayed until September

Ward 3 Councillor Matthew Green provided his testimony against Const. Andrew Pfeiffer on Monday, the first day of a Police Services Act hearing that is scheduled to continue over four days.

Story continues below

Green said he was waiting for a bus in the area of Victoria Avenue and Stinson Street in April of 2016 when he felt “targeted” by the officer who rolled down the window of his cruiser and asked him what he was doing there.

Green told the hearing that he was made to feel “like a suspect in my own neighbourhood.”

READ MORE: Hamilton cop who stopped city councillor faces discreditable conduct hearing

Defence lawyer Bernard Cummins, in his cross-examination of the councillor, indicated that Const. Pfeiffer will have a different story to tell.

Cummins said his client asked Green “how are you doing?” after spotting him under-dressed for the weather and standing in mud, only to have the question returned to him in a “heightened, aggressive tone” by the councillor who started “thumping” his chest.

READ MORE: Hamilton city councillor files complaint to police after ‘carding’ incident

Green denied that version of events, calling it “preposterous.”

He also testified that Pfeiffer asked about his well-being, only as a “rehearsed” afterthought, after learning who he was talking to and before driving away.

The officer has plead not guilty to one count of discreditable conduct.

© 2017 Global News, a division of Corus Entertainment Inc.

Report an error


Want to discuss? Please read our Commenting Policy first.