Advertisement

Canadian teacher Neil Bantleman sex abuse acquittal overturned in Indonesia

WATCH: A Canadian man is back behind bars in Indonesia for sex crimes against minors. But experts question what - if any - evidence exists against Neil Bantleman, and the Canadian government is now condemning the court's decision. Mike Drolet reports.

Canadian school teacher Neil Bantleman has had his acquittal overturned by Indonesia’s supreme court, Global News has learned.

Bantleman and an Indonesian teacher had been acquitted of sexually abusing students at an international school in Jakarta after having been convicted in a case that has had many twists and turns.

READ MORE: Prosecutors file appeal in case of Canadian teacher in Indonesia

Speaking by phone from Burlington, Ontario, Bantleman’s brother Guy confirmed the court overturned the acquittal and that the news came as a blow when he heard it Tuesday night.

“It was [a] shock – we were fairly confident that we were going to see the decision upheld and Neil returned to Canada.”
WATCH: Guy Bantleman calls on government to help bring his brother home
Brother of Canadian teacher Neil Bantleman calls on gov’t to begin talks with Indonesia
Brother of Canadian teacher Neil Bantleman calls on gov’t to begin talks with Indonesia

“We’re not sure how in-depth or what sort of review went through with the file,” Guy said. “Today we’ve been spending trying to figure out next steps in terms of Neil turning himself over to authorities again and where we go from here.”

Story continues below advertisement
Canadian teacher Neil Bantleman, left, stands inside a holding cell while his wife Tracy talks to journalists after his trial at South Jakarta District Court in Jakarta, Indonesia, Thursday, April 2, 2015. An Indonesian court has sentenced Bantleman to 10 years in jail for sexually abusing three young children at a prestigious international school.
Canadian teacher Neil Bantleman, left, stands inside a holding cell while his wife Tracy talks to journalists after his trial at South Jakarta District Court in Jakarta, Indonesia, Thursday, April 2, 2015. An Indonesian court has sentenced Bantleman to 10 years in jail for sexually abusing three young children at a prestigious international school. AP Photo/Tatan Syuflana
Canadian teacher Neil Bantleman, right, receives a mobile phone from his wife Tracy as Indonesia teaching assistant Ferdinant Tjiong, left, looks on prior to the start of their trial hearing to listen to the prosecutor's demand at South Jakarta District Court in Jakarta, Indonesia, Thursday, March 12, 2015. Bantleman and Tjiong were on trial on accusation of sexually abusing a kindergartner on the campus of a prestigious international school in the capital.
Canadian teacher Neil Bantleman, right, receives a mobile phone from his wife Tracy as Indonesia teaching assistant Ferdinant Tjiong, left, looks on prior to the start of their trial hearing to listen to the prosecutor's demand at South Jakarta District Court in Jakarta, Indonesia, Thursday, March 12, 2015. Bantleman and Tjiong were on trial on accusation of sexually abusing a kindergartner on the campus of a prestigious international school in the capital. AP Photo/Dita Alangkara
Canadian teacher Neil Bantleman, center, hugged by his wife Tracy, after his trial at South Jakarta District Court in Jakarta, Indonesia, Thursday, April 2, 2015. An Indonesian court has sentenced Bantleman to 10 years in jail for sexually abusing three young children at a prestigious international school.
Canadian teacher Neil Bantleman, center, hugged by his wife Tracy, after his trial at South Jakarta District Court in Jakarta, Indonesia, Thursday, April 2, 2015. An Indonesian court has sentenced Bantleman to 10 years in jail for sexually abusing three young children at a prestigious international school. AP Photo/Tatan Syuflana
Canadian teacher Neil Bantleman, right, kisses his wife Tracy prior to the start of his trial at South Jakarta District Court in Jakarta, Indonesia, Thursday, April 2, 2015. An Indonesian court has sentenced Bantleman to 10 years in jail for sexually abusing three young children at a prestigious international school.
Canadian teacher Neil Bantleman, right, kisses his wife Tracy prior to the start of his trial at South Jakarta District Court in Jakarta, Indonesia, Thursday, April 2, 2015. An Indonesian court has sentenced Bantleman to 10 years in jail for sexually abusing three young children at a prestigious international school. AP Photo/Tatan Syuflana
Canadian teacher Neil Bantleman reacts during his verdict trial at South Jakarta District Court in Jakarta, Indonesia, Thursday, April 2, 2015. Bantleman, serving time in an Indonesian prison on child-abuse convictions, says the federal government has done little to protect him from what he calls an abuse of his human rights.
Canadian teacher Neil Bantleman reacts during his verdict trial at South Jakarta District Court in Jakarta, Indonesia, Thursday, April 2, 2015. Bantleman, serving time in an Indonesian prison on child-abuse convictions, says the federal government has done little to protect him from what he calls an abuse of his human rights. THE CANADIAN PRESS/AP/Tatan Syuflana
Canadian teacher Neil Bantleman sits on the defendant's chair prior to the start of his trial hearing at South Jakarta District Court in Jakarta, Indonesia, Monday, Dec. 2, 2014. Bantleman's family says the country's prosecutor's office has filed an appeal to the August ruling the resulted in his release.
Canadian teacher Neil Bantleman sits on the defendant's chair prior to the start of his trial hearing at South Jakarta District Court in Jakarta, Indonesia, Monday, Dec. 2, 2014. Bantleman's family says the country's prosecutor's office has filed an appeal to the August ruling the resulted in his release. THE CANADIAN PRESS/AP, Tatan Syuflana
FILE - In this Friday, Aug. 14, 2015 file photo, Canadian teacher Neil Bantleman, right, hugs his wife Tracy, left, after he was released from Cipinang prison in Jakarta, Indonesia. Indonesia top court has overruled the acquittal of Bantleman and his Indonesian colleague Ferdinant Tjiong and heightened their sentence to 11 years in jail for sexually abusing three young children at a prestigious international school in Jakarta.
FILE - In this Friday, Aug. 14, 2015 file photo, Canadian teacher Neil Bantleman, right, hugs his wife Tracy, left, after he was released from Cipinang prison in Jakarta, Indonesia. Indonesia top court has overruled the acquittal of Bantleman and his Indonesian colleague Ferdinant Tjiong and heightened their sentence to 11 years in jail for sexually abusing three young children at a prestigious international school in Jakarta. AP Photo/Achmad Ibrahim, File
Canadian teacher Neil Bantleman, right, hugs his wife Tracy, left, after he was released from Cipinang prison in Jakarta, Indonesia, Friday,Aug.14, 2015. A Canadian teacher and an Indonesian teaching assistant serving 10 years in an Indonesian prison for child sexual offenses were released Friday after a court overturned their convictions.
Canadian teacher Neil Bantleman, right, hugs his wife Tracy, left, after he was released from Cipinang prison in Jakarta, Indonesia, Friday,Aug.14, 2015. A Canadian teacher and an Indonesian teaching assistant serving 10 years in an Indonesian prison for child sexual offenses were released Friday after a court overturned their convictions. AP Photo/Achmad Ibrahim
Canadian teacher Neil Bantleman, right, hugs his wife Tracy, left, after he was released from Cipinang prison in Jakarta, Indonesia, Friday,Aug.14.
Canadian teacher Neil Bantleman, right, hugs his wife Tracy, left, after he was released from Cipinang prison in Jakarta, Indonesia, Friday,Aug.14. Achmad Ibrahim/AP Photo
Canadian teacher Neil Bantleman, right, kisses his wife Tracy, left, after he was released from Cipinang prison in Jakarta, Indonesia, Friday, Aug. 14, 2015. A Canadian teacher and an Indonesian teaching assistant serving 10 years in an Indonesian prison for child sexual offenses were released Friday after a court overturned their convictions.
Canadian teacher Neil Bantleman, right, kisses his wife Tracy, left, after he was released from Cipinang prison in Jakarta, Indonesia, Friday, Aug. 14, 2015. A Canadian teacher and an Indonesian teaching assistant serving 10 years in an Indonesian prison for child sexual offenses were released Friday after a court overturned their convictions. AP Photo/Achmad Ibrahim
Canadian teacher Neil Bantleman (2nd R) and Indonesian teaching assistant Ferdinand Tjiong (2nd L) arrive at the South Jakarta court in Jakarta on December 2, 2014. Bantleman, who worked at the prestigious Jakarta International School (JIS), was arrested in July along with a teaching assistant during a police investigation into the alleged sexual assault of three kindergarten students. Bantleman and co-accused Ferdinand Tjiong, could face up to 15 years in prison if convicted.
Canadian teacher Neil Bantleman (2nd R) and Indonesian teaching assistant Ferdinand Tjiong (2nd L) arrive at the South Jakarta court in Jakarta on December 2, 2014. Bantleman, who worked at the prestigious Jakarta International School (JIS), was arrested in July along with a teaching assistant during a police investigation into the alleged sexual assault of three kindergarten students. Bantleman and co-accused Ferdinand Tjiong, could face up to 15 years in prison if convicted. ADEK BERRY/AFP/Getty Images
Neil Bantleman.
Neil Bantleman. (Screengrab)

Bantleman and Ferdi Tjiong had been sentenced to 10 years last April by the South Jakarta District Court. But they maintained innocence and filed appeals to the High Court, which acquitted them in August.

Supreme Court spokesman Suhadi said Thursday a three-member judge panel handed down a verdict Wednesday based on the prosecutors’ appeal and increased their sentence to 11 years.

The two teachers also were ordered to pay a $7,440 fine each or to serve six more months in jail.

Canadian Foreign Affairs Minister Stéphane Dion released a statement early Thursday morning calling the ruling appalling.

WATCH: Foreign Affairs Minister Stéphane Dion says Neil Bantleman’s story isn’t over
Foreign Affairs Minister Stéphane Dion says Neil Bantleman’s story isn’t over
Foreign Affairs Minister Stéphane Dion says Neil Bantleman’s story isn’t over

“The Government of Canada is deeply dismayed and shocked that the Supreme Court of Indonesia has overturned the Jakarta High Court’s acquittal of Neil Bantleman and his Indonesian co-accused, Ferdi Tjiong, based on lack of evidence,” Dion said.

“This decision is unjust, given the many grave irregularities throughout the various proceedings in this case and the fact that all evidence presented by the defence has systematically been rejected.”

Tweet This

Dion also said the decision could hurt future relations between the two countries.

“Despite Canada’s repeated calls for due process, this case was not handled in a fair and transparent manner,” said Dion.

Story continues below advertisement

“The outcome of this case has serious implications for Indonesia’s reputation as a safe place for Canadians to work, travel and invest as well as for Canada’s long history of cooperation with Indonesia.”

The foreign affairs minister said Bantleman will continue to receive consular assistance as the case proceeds.

READ MORE: Neil Bantleman released after Indonesian court overturns sex abuse conviction

WATCH: Former colleagues of Neil Bantleman at Calgary’s Webber Academy are reacting to the news of his rearrest in Indonesia. Gary Bobrovitz reports.
Neil Bantleman’s former colleagues at Webber Academy are shocked
Neil Bantleman’s former colleagues at Webber Academy are shocked

Bantleman has lived in Ontario and Alberta, and spent time teaching at Calgary’s Webber Academy where staff and students say he was a beloved teacher.

Bantleman and teaching assistant Tjiong were convicted of abusing kindergarten students at the Jakarta Intercultural School.

-With files from The Associated Press