VICTORIA – The B.C. Liberal government says it cancelled a deal to rename BC Place in large part because Telus was planning to place two signs on the outside of the stadium that were almost 2.7 metres (nine feet) larger than agreed.
“The deal was changing so much. Then when we found out this piece, that the signs were much, much larger than what had originally been agreed to, then that was again another big change that we were confronted with,” Minister of Jobs, Tourism and Innovation Pat Bell said Monday.
“After a year of trying to work through this, and not get to a successful decision, I think the right thing to do is say, ‘Listen, let’s just not pursue this.’”
The explanation is significantly different than the one the government has provided so far – that the province wanted to retain the BC Place name, and that the final deal was not in the best interests of taxpayers.
On Monday, Bell said the issue came at the end of a protracted negotiation, adding the time had come to just make a decision.
“It got to the point where it felt like we were trying to nail Jell-O to the wall. The deal was changing so much,” added Bell, who said he and Finance Minister Kevin Falcon, not cabinet, made the final decision.
“I have been involved with this file for the better part of a year. There’s just been so many twists and turns in it, and eventually I think the responsible thing to do is to make a decision.”
Get daily National news
Bell said the government originally told companies it was looking to sell rights that included the ability to place two illuminated signs on the outside of BC Place that would fit within a ring that encircles the base of the roof. Such signs would have been about 3.3 to 3.9 metres (11 to 13 feet) high.
The now constructed “Telus Park” sign was 4.5 metres (15 feet) for much of the writing, a Telus spokesman said, though he agreed some letters stretched to almost 6.7 metres (22 feet).
During negotiations, Telus told the government that if it had to reduce the size of its planned sign, it would also significantly reduce the $1.75 million per year it was prepared to pay for naming rights.
The Telus spokesman, who did not want to be named due to sensitivity of negotiations, confirmed that was Telus’s position in its written terms, but added the company later took that off the table.
“In the later stages of negotiations we agreed that if the signs needed to be reduced in size, or were required to be reduced in size, that we would not reduce our funding and that we would hold the accountability on that front,” said the spokesman.
“Towards the later stages we said, look, we’re willing to drop that.”
The Telus spokesman also provided The Sun with a letter from Jacque Duguay, vice-president of operations at Pattison Sign Group, which constructed the signs.
“In the case of the re-branding of BC Place to Telus Park, we have consulted with our customer on various elements of the design, including the size of the signage,” read the undated and unaddressed letter.
“Because of the large dimensions of a stadium like BC Place, large signs are required to adequately show the brand.In our opinion, these signs are the right dimension to properly brand this size of building.”
For government, the concern was not just having a much larger sign on BC Place, but also the fact that Telus would be getting a much better deal than had been offered to other companies in the initial call for proposals.
Falcon said negotiations were also complicated by the months’ long delay caused by the Liberal leadership race.
“We accept our share of responsibility for the fact that it has been a long drawn-out process, particularly given the interregnum period where we’ve got a leadership race going on,” he said.
“But it has also been a process that has been frustrated by the negotiation process, and when new elements are introduced that have significant potential impact to impair the value you’re receiving, you have to take the time to do the homework,” he continued.
Falcon said he regrets the deal couldn’t be done with Telus, but he still believes walking away was the best move for taxpayers.
“We’re not proud of the fact that this deal took a long time, and it’s unfortunate in our view that it didn’t meet what we believe is the public interest test,” he said.
Peter Brown, the well-known Vancouver financier who recently resigned from PavCo’s board, said he believes all three parties share responsibility for the failure.
“Unfortunately, in my opinion, all three parties – PavCo, Telus and the B.C. government – could share some varying responsibility for a flawed process and poor communication,” Brown said Monday.
Comments
Want to discuss? Please read our Commenting Policy first.