Advertisement

Parts of B.C.’s new drunk driving laws declared unconstitutional

B.C. Supreme Court Justice Jon Sigurdson has declared part of the province’s tough new impaired driving law unconstitutional because police act as roadside judge, jury and executioner.

In a lengthy decision released on the same day the holiday CounterAttack program began, the veteran jurist said the Liberal Government had gone too far with a section of its year-old, anti-drunk-driving program and trampled individual rights:

“Although I am fully satisfied of the importance of the objective of reducing the harms caused by impaired driving, I have found that the challenge succeeds in part, because in one respect the impugned legislation infringes the rights of individuals to be free from unreasonable search and seizure.”

After deliberating for six months, Justice Sigurdson said Wednesday the government should have more deference for the rights of drivers who blow over .08 on a roadside screening device.

Story continues below advertisement

Given the harsh punishment for a “fail,” he thought there needed to be a better appeal process – “under the ARP regime the driver’s ability to challenge the result of the search or the basis for the search is very limited, notwithstanding the possible non-trivial consequences resulting from the search.”

He concluded: “The ARP legislation infringes section 8 of the Charter [of Rights and Freedoms] insofar as it concerns the prohibition, penalty and costs arising from the screening device registering a ‘fail’ reading over 0.08. This infringement is not a reasonable limit which is demonstrably justified in a free and democratic society.”

Justice Sigurdson said the legislation had another constitutional flaw but was saved by the section of the charter that allows individual rights to be minimally impaired in pursuit of an important public objective.

The justice did not make an order at the conclusion of his findings but asked the lawyers involved in the case to return to court “as soon as is practicable” to make submissions on the appropriate declaration.

Get daily Canada news delivered to your inbox so you'll never miss the day's top stories.

Get daily National news

Get daily Canada news delivered to your inbox so you'll never miss the day's top stories.
By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy.

“It was a victory for sure,” said a happy Joel Whysall, one of the lawyers in the case.

Story continues below advertisement

“My reading of it is that he doesn’t want to give police officers carte blanche. He wants some oversight of police officers. And that was one of our points – that there wasn’t sufficient checks and balances.”

Robert Holmes, of the B.C. Civil Liberties Association, was also celebratory: “Thank goodness we have an independent judiciary that isn’t afraid to stand up to government when it goes too far.”

Established via amendments to the Motor Vehicle Act, the most draconian impaired driving regime in the country allows police to issue immediate roadside suspensions, impound cars and levy fines on drivers who refuse a breath test or blow a blood-alcohol level of .05 or higher.

It costs drivers hit with a three-month suspension for a “fail” nearly $5,000 in penalties, towing and stowage fees and other costs – they must take a pricey safe driving program and install an interlock ignition device on any motorized vehicle they operate.

Defence lawyers savaged the law for infringing rights while the hospitality industry complained it was scaring away customers.

The Alliance of Beverage Licensees of British Columbia said Justice Sigurdson should have denounced the legislation.

“We have believed from day one that this law is unfair and conceptually flawed, and our businesses have suffered as a result,” says president Matt MacNeil.

Story continues below advertisement

“We’re pleased that the Supreme Court has agreed that provisions of this law are unconstitutional, and we look forward to working with the B.C. Government to come up with better solutions to stop impaired driving.”

Justice Sigurdson thought the dangers of drunk driving were so significant that the legislation by and large passed muster except for its most stringent sections.

Extensive material was filed in the case documenting the continuing problem of impaired drivers – the devastation and personal costs resulting from alcohol-related injuries and deaths.

“The evidence filed in the case at bar,” Justice Sigurdson explained, “shows that there is a legitimate, substantial and pressing reason for the province to regulate highway safety and the licensing of drivers to remove impaired drivers from the roads, and that the federal government is justified in legislating criminal sanctions in relation to impaired driving.”

He said the infringement on the right to counsel, while real, was “minimal” and could be justified – but not the search and seizure.

“In my view, because of the significant prohibition, penalty and cost implications of a ‘fail’ reading, the province could easily have provided in the legislation a reasonable and meaningful review process where a driver subject to a lengthy automatic roadside prohibition could challenge the results of the screening device,” he said. “This is particularly so considering the province has legislated to base the consequences of a ‘fail’ reading entirely on the results of the screening device.”

Story continues below advertisement

While not binding, the decision will prod other provinces such as Alberta, which last week introduced similar legislation, to review plans to emulate B.C.’s approach.

The constitutional challenge grew out of a petition filed by Aman Preet Sivia, who was stopped about 10 days after the new law came into effect in Sept. 2010.

Sivia was found to be in excess of the .05 blood alcohol restriction and was issued a driving prohibition. She applied to the Superintendent of Motor Vehicles for a review of the officer’s decision, but was denied.

Solicitor General Shirley Bond, who needed time to review the ruling, said regardless of the decision the cops will be out in force enforcing the impaired driving laws.

The decision does not affect the federal criminal code prohibitions.

The government claims its program was a huge success reducing alcohol-related fatalities during the last year to 68 – a 40 per cent decline from five-year annual average of 113 deaths.

Also during that year, police issued 23,366 suspensions. Of those, 15,401 were drivers who blew a “fail” (which indicates they were over .08) or refused to provide a breath sample; and 7,965 blew a “warn,” which indicates a blood alcohol level of between .05 and .08.

Police also impounded 20,020 cars – roughly 14,900 for 30 days. The rest were three-day impoundments.

Story continues below advertisement

[The decision is available on the court website http://www.courts.gov.bc.ca/jdb-txt/SC/11/16/2011BCSC1639.htm#_Toc310333396
 

Sponsored content

AdChoices