Advertisement

U.S. history teachers bemoan Republican gaffes on campaign trail

WASHINGTON – It’s enough to make a grown American history teacher cry.

Texas Gov. Rick Perry is the latest high-profile Republican candidate to display a flimsy grasp of U.S. history in remarks he made in a presidential debate this week when he suggested Americans fought the Revolutionary War against the British in the 1500s.

His remarks have not only prompted a gleeful meme on Twitter as so-called tweeps use the hashtag #perryhistory to ridicule the governor’s take on history, but they’ve also renewed accusations that the conservative movement is peppered with …. well …. nitwits.

“Putting it bluntly: Rick Perry is not stupid,” the Austin Chronicle wrote in a damning defence of the governor following the debate.

“But he does seem to lack the kind of intellectual curiousity and agility that running outside of the convivial atmosphere of Texas politics requires.”

Story continues below advertisement

America’s political stage has long been populated by some apparent knuckleheads, from former vice president Dan Quayle — the Sarah Palin of his day, perhaps best remembered for misspelling the word ‘potato’ — to the late Democratic congressman, Sidney Yates, who once asked Hispanic high school students: “Do you own sombreros? Do you know the Mexican hat dance?”

But the current field of Republicans eyeing the party’s presidential nomination have caused some consternation among historians and pundits, who fear America’s famous strain of populism and anti-intellectualism could be shifting into overdrive.

“I feel the blood being drawn out of my body when I hear our precious history being so badly butchered by candidates who want to be the leader of our great nation,” Allan Lichtman, a history professor of the University of Maryland, said in an interview Thursday.

“If you don’t know your history, how in the world can you expect to guide the country into the future?” he asked. “These are the very people that tout their Americanism, and their fidelity to our heritage, and yet they don’t know anything about our heritage.”

Get breaking Canada news delivered to your inbox as it happens so you won't miss a trending story.

Get breaking National news

Get breaking Canada news delivered to your inbox as it happens so you won't miss a trending story.
By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy.

Lichtman aims particular scorn at Michele Bachmann, who landed herself in hot water earlier this year when she suggested the country’s Founding Fathers toiled tirelessly to abolish slavery.

In fact, slavery wasn’t outlawed until almost a century after the Declaration of Independence was signed — an event that took place amid the Revolutionary War, fought not in the 1500s, but from 1775 to 1783.

Story continues below advertisement

“How can someone not know that?” Lichtman asked.

Sarah Palin, meantime, got her Paul Revere history wrong, suggesting in infamous remarks earlier this year that the Revolutionary War hero made his legendary midnight ride to warn the British, not the Americans, that the enemy was approaching.

Lou Roper, a history professor at the State University of New York in New Paltz, N.Y., says he finds it all very suspicious.

“Playing dumb isn’t unheard of in this country. It’s annoying in the sense that a lot of people know that they’ve got things wrong, I suspect — I mean Bachmann is an educated person and should know better, so obviously someone is playing games here,” he said in an interview.

It grates, Roper adds, because “people should have a better grasp of the nation’s history and if they do and don’t want anyone to know about it, they should stop perpetuating that kind of ‘we’re dumb’ myth. I don’t think, when push comes to shove, that most Americans revel in being dumb or regard being dumb as a virtue.”

But rather than finding himself slumping into a depression about their history gaffes, Roper adds, he’s delighted at the outrage and ridicule that usually greet their remarks.

“Anything that sparks a discussion and debate about American history, for me, is a good thing. And we start talking about American history in great detail every time one of these remarks is made.”

Story continues below advertisement

And how.

The Twitterverse has been lit up all week with those poking merciless fun of Perry’s gaffe.

“Washington chopped down the cherry tree to clear the area for experimental oil drilling to save the nation from the terrorists,” one wag tweeted.

But Timothy Stanley, a research fellow in American history at Oxford University who’s working on a biography of Pat Buchanan, says it’s foolish for liberals to assume that the patriotic Tea Party, in particular, is populated by drooling buffoons.

“The Tea Party is engaged in more than just an emotional exercise; there’s a genuine intellectual dimension to what the Tea Party is all about and it isn’t just about limiting government,” Stanley said from the Ronald Reagan Presidential Library in Simi Valley, Calif., where he was researching his book.

“Within the Tea Party, there’s a real understanding about what the Founding Fathers were all about. If you look at their literature, they include the writings of Benjamin Franklin, Thomas Jefferson. They see American as a country with a historical story and a special place in the world that has to be earned through good and godly behaviour.”

The man considered the grandfather of the Tea Party movement, Ron Paul, is far from dumb, Stanley adds.

“This is a guy who will quote the Austrian school of economics … he has serious brain power.”

Story continues below advertisement

So what does Stanley make of the gaffes by the likes of Perry, Bachmann and Palin, politicians the Tea Party has embraced with open arms?

Perry and Bachmann were both Democrats in their early political careers, he points out, working for Al Gore and Jimmy Carter respectively.

“All these people, they’ve really hijacked the Tea Party movement, so I don’t expect them to display the same degrees of intellectual rigour as those who have been in the game for a very long time,” he said.

“These people are embracing the Tea Party now, but they are not emotionally or intellectually loyal to it.”

Sponsored content

AdChoices