TORONTO – As "radical elements" broke free of a G20 protest and began causing the unprecedented destruction of downtown Toronto, officers were simply unprepared to deal with the magnitude of the disorder, an internal police report concludes.
An audit by the Toronto Police Service of the force’s much-maligned actions during the G20 summit over June 26 and 27, 2010 was released Thursday with 10 recommendations.
The report paints a picture of police resources being overwhelmed by the sudden vandalism and so-called Black Bloc protest techniques. Not enough riot police could respond, and some officers not properly trained in riot policing were forced to step in, the report says.
While the chaos was unfolding police were hamstrung by poor communications and co-ordination. Plans were not communicated properly down the chain of command. Incident commanders were not relieved from their regular duties, so they did not have time to participate in the planning process and had to execute plans they didn’t develop. Some operational plans were put in place the day before the summit.
The communications system itself also became overwhelmed and radio transmissions became ineffective as too many officers tried to use it at the same time, the report says.
In a foreword to the report Toronto Police Chief Bill Blair says the challenges facing police that weekend were "immense" and some aspects were handled well, while others were not.
"Last June we saw levels of violence we had never seen before in Toronto," Blair writes. "People came to the G20 summit, not to engage in debate or discussion or demonstrations, but to infiltrate lawful, peaceful protests and use them as cover to commit vandalism and violence."
The Toronto police have also been criticized for poorly managing the detention centre where 1,118 people were sent. Detainees complained of cramped conditions, little to no food or their medical needs being ignored.
The detention centre was designed to hold 500 people and was capable of holding up to 750, if required, and the report says 885 were processed there during the G20.
But when hundreds of people were arrested on the night of June 26 into the morning of June 27, "the massive influx of prisoners, all within a matter of hours, overwhelmed the single court services pre-booking officer," the report stated.
This led to some prisoners facing delays of up to 24 hours, while some people arrested on the morning of June 27 were delayed "up to 36 hours before being taken before a justice of the peace.
Police acknowledge in the report that a "breakdown in communication" meant officers were unable to handle the huge influx of prisoners and left them with no central tracking system, which could have determined how long a person had been detained and if they had been fed.
The recommendations include reviewing how to better manage Black Bloc tactics and developing a way to identify people in a crowd who threaten public safety.
"There were times when crowd dynamics, coupled with the scope and scale of the mass disorder overwhelmed police capacity," police conclude in the report.
The police came under fire for employing a "kettling" technique, encircling a peaceful crowd of protesters and refusing to let those caught inside to leave for several hours.
"Better methods must be developed for extracting individuals posing a threat to public safety from within large crowds," the report concludes. "It is clear that current tactics and processes cannot be executed without considerable time, resources and unwanted impact on affected individuals."
The report also mentions the so-called G20 secret law that has come under fire from many, including Ontario ombudsman Andre Marin, who called it "the most massive compromise of civil liberties in Canadian history."
Toronto police asked the provincial government for the legal authority to demand information and accreditation for those entering the fenced summit area.
The provincial government updated the Public Works Protection Act but the report notes the regulation was was not communicated to the public.
And, the report says, police were not informed until June 25 that they did not have the power to search anyone within five metres outside of the security fence.
"There were two people arrested under the authority of the PWPA," the report said.
Premier Dalton McGuinty has said the Ontario government acted with "good intentions" but too much haste when it passed the law and has refused to offer an apology.
While the report acknowledges and even highlights policing errors and tactics that beg for improvement, police also congratulate themselves for succeeding in their core mandate, which was to protect the summit sites and delegations.
More than 280 complaints were made regarding policing during the G20 summit of which 90 were sent for investigation.
The report said 108 officers have been disciplined for removing their identification and one officer is charged with assault with a weapon.
In addition, 18 civil actions or human rights complaints have been launched over arrests, detentions, injuries or property damage.
Comments
Want to discuss? Please read our Commenting Policy first.