June 2, 2014 3:00 pm
Updated: June 2, 2014 7:59 pm

Debate stirs over US-Taliban captive swap


Watch above: The deal to free a soldier has created a rift in Washington over whether the U.S. military should negotiate with the Taliban. Robin Stickley reports.

WASHINGTON – The prisoner swap that won a release of a U.S. Army soldier from Taliban hands has stirred a debate in Washington about whether the exchange puts other Americans at risk of being snatched as bargaining chips.

Story continues below
Global News

Five terrorist suspects walked free to gain the release of Army Sgt. Bowe Bergdahl, who was handed off to U.S. special forces in eastern Afghanistan after five years in captivity. The swap has also raised questions about whether the released detainees – several senior Taliban figures among them – would find their way back to the fight.

READ MORE: Afghanistan criticizes swap for captive US soldier 

U.S. officials said Sunday that Bergdahl’s health and safety appeared in jeopardy, prompting rapid action to secure his release. “Had we waited and lost him,” said national security adviser Susan Rice, “I don’t think anybody would have forgiven the United States government.”

Republicans said the deal could set a troubling precedent – one called it “shocking.” Sen. John McCain, a former presidential candidate and former prisoner of war himself, said of the five Guantanamo detainees, “These are the hardest of the hard core.”

And in Kabul Monday, the Afghan Foreign Ministry called the swap “against the norms of international law” if it came against the five imprisoned Taliban detainees’ will. The ministry said: “No state can transfer another country’s citizen to a third country and put restriction on their freedom.”

Tireless campaigners for their son’s freedom, Bob and Jani Bergdahl thanked all who were behind the effort to retrieve him. “You were not left behind,” Bob Bergdahl told reporters, as if speaking to his son. “We are so proud of the way this was carried out.” He spoke in Boise, Idaho, wearing a long bushy beard he’d grown to honour his son, as residents in the sergeant’s hometown of Hailey prepared for a homecoming celebration.

WATCH: Upon hearing the news of Bowe Bergdahl’s release, residents in his hometown of Hailey, Idaho celebrated by holding a gathering at a local coffee shop. 

The five detainees left Guantanamo aboard a U.S. military aircraft flying to Qatar, which served as go-between in the negotiations. They are to be banned from leaving Qatar for at least a year. Among the five: a Taliban deputy intelligence minister, a former Taliban interior minister with ties to al-Qaida leader Osama bin Laden and a figure linked by human rights monitors to mass killings of Shiite Muslims in Afghanistan in 2000 and 2001.

Bergdahl, 28, was being treated at Landstuhl Regional Medical Center in Germany. Officials did not offer details about Bergdahl’s health to support their contention that his release had to be arranged without delay. Rice on one hand said he had lost considerable weight and faced an “acute” situation. Yet she said he appeared to be “in good physical condition” and “is said to be walking.”

One official said that U.S. officials, after seeing a proof of life video, were concerned about Bergdahl’s health and believed that with the uncertainty of not knowing exactly what condition he was in, there was a greater sense of urgency.

This official, who spoke on grounds of anonymity because the person wasn’t authorized to discuss the subject by name, said there also were concerns about Bergdahl’s mental and emotional health. The ‘good health’ statement was more an observation that he was able to move on his own, and wasn’t in such bad shape that he had to be helped or carried, the official said.

Questions persisted, too, about the circumstances of Bergdahl’s 2009 capture. Defence Secretary Chuck Hagel declined to comment on earlier reports that the sergeant had walked away from his unit, disillusioned with the war. Such matters “will be dealt with later,” Hagel said.

READ MORE: U.S. moved quickly on prisoner swap because soldier’s life was in danger, says Hagel

Hagel, visiting troops in Afghanistan, was met with silence when he told a group of them in a Bagram Air Field hangar: “This is a happy day. We got one of our own back.” It was unclear whether the absence of cheers and applause came from a reluctance to display emotion in front of the Pentagon chief or from any doubts among the troops about Bergdahl.

In weighing the swap, U.S. officials decided that it could help the effort to reach reconciliation with the Taliban, which the U.S. sees as key to more security in Afghanistan. But they acknowledged the risk that the deal would embolden insurgents.

Republicans pressed that point. “Have we just put a price on other U.S. soldiers?” asked Senator Ted Cruz of Texas. “What does this tell terrorists, that if you capture a U.S. soldier, you can trade that soldier for five terrorists?”

Republican Representative Adam Kinzinger of Illinois said, “I’m going to celebrate him coming home,” but added that the release of “five mid- to high-level Taliban is shocking to me, especially without coming to Congress.”

Baldor reported from Bagram Air Field, Afghanistan. Associated Press writers Deb Riechmann and Darlene Superville in Washington, Rahim Faiez in Kabul, Afghanistan, and Zarar Khan in Islamabad contributed to this report.

© 2014 The Canadian Press

Report an error


Global News