Magnotta trial: What is Not Criminally Responsible?
Videos
-
Magnotta trial: What is Not Criminally Responsible?
-
Global News at 5:30 Montreal: April 13
12:49 | April 13, 2025
-
Global News Montreal at 5:30: May 7
15:09 | May 8, 2024
-
RDP residents and government officials team up to tackle source of smell
02:19 | August 8, 2019
-
No free pass for bathroom access at Montreal train station
01:37 | August 2, 2019
-
Man shot in suspected bar robbery gone wrong: police
00:40 | May 27, 2019
-
Île-Bizard blue collar workers praised for tireless flood relief efforts
02:18 | May 7, 2019
-
Kirkland man accused of attempted murder of his 2 children found not criminally responsible
02:03 | March 20, 2019
-
Armed cop ‘intimidated’ by Global News reporter at G7 protests, asks her to move
01:31 | June 8, 2018
-
Global News Morning weather forecast: Friday, March 10
01:13 | March 10, 2017
-
TransLink gets high marks in review of Canada’s transit systems
04:16 | July 19, 2016
-
Magnotta trial: What is Not Criminally Responsible?
| September 29, 2014
-
Global News at 5:30 Montreal: April 13
12:49 | April 13, 2025
-
Global News Montreal at 5:30: May 7
15:09 | May 8, 2024
-
RDP residents and government officials team up to tackle source of smell
02:19 | August 8, 2019
-
No free pass for bathroom access at Montreal train station
01:37 | August 2, 2019
-
Man shot in suspected bar robbery gone wrong: police
00:40 | May 27, 2019
-
Île-Bizard blue collar workers praised for tireless flood relief efforts
02:18 | May 7, 2019
-
Kirkland man accused of attempted murder of his 2 children found not criminally responsible
02:03 | March 20, 2019
-
Armed cop ‘intimidated’ by Global News reporter at G7 protests, asks her to move
01:31 | June 8, 2018
-
Global News Morning weather forecast: Friday, March 10
01:13 | March 10, 2017
-
TransLink gets high marks in review of Canada’s transit systems
04:16 | July 19, 2016
Magnotta trial: What is Not Criminally Responsible?
Description
September 29, 2014
If Luka Magnotta is found “not criminally responsible” for the murder of Jun Lin, he could still be locked away for life.
Just not in a prison.
[tp_video id=1588862]
<b>WATCH: </b><strong>Magnotta admits to killing Jun Lin, jury must decide if he was of sound mind. Domenic Fazioli reports</strong>
Canada’s new “not criminally responsible” (NCR) regime passed last summer. It applies to those who are found to have committed an act that constitutes an offence, but cannot appreciate or understand what they did was wrong due to a mental disorder at the time.
Magnotta’s lawyer <a href="http://globalnews.ca/news/1587134/magnotta-trial-proceedings-begin-monday-in-montreal/" target="_blank">argued in court Monday</a> that his client is schizophrenic and was not criminally responsible when he killed Lin, a Chinese student, in 2012.
<b>READ MORE: </b><a href="http://globalnews.ca/news/451660/magnotta-diagnosed-with-paranoid-schizophrenia-2005-doctors-letter-reveals/" target="_blank"><strong>Magnotta diagnosed with paranoid schizophrenia, 2005 doctor’s letter reveals</strong></a>
If a person is found NCR, they are referred to a provincial review board.
The board can make one of three determinations: an absolute discharge, if the person is not deemed a public safety threat; a conditional discharge; or a detention in secure psychiatric facility or hospital run by the province.
The law now makes public safety paramount to the decision-making process.
It also creates a new “high-risk” designation – if a person has committed a “serious personal injury,” is likely to commit further violence, or the acts were of such “brutal nature” as to indicate a grave risk to the public.
High-risk NCR people would not get conditional or absolute discharges. They would not be allowed to go out into the community unescorted and escorted passes would only be allowed for medical reasons.
Most significant, they could not be released until the high-risk designation was revoked by a court.
Furthermore, their cases could be up for review only every three years – not annually.
And if the NCR person were ever released, victims would be notified upon request.
Magnotta could end up serving more time in a provincial facility if he is found high-risk NCR.
If Magnotta were convicted of first-degree murder, for instance, he would likely not be up for parole until he served 25 years of his sentence. If convicted of second-degree murder – which would mean he didn’t plan the killing - he would not be eligible until serving between 10 and 25 years.
Critics of the new NCR regime have argued that those who suffer from mental illness will have fewer incentives to plead NCR and may wind up in regular prisons – thus crowding the system with mentally ill inmates.
-
Magnotta trial: What is Not Criminally Responsible? -
Global News at 5:30 Montreal: April 1312:49 | April 13, 2025 -
Global News Montreal at 5:30: May 715:09 | May 8, 2024 -
RDP residents and government officials team up to tackle source of smell02:19 | August 8, 2019 -
No free pass for bathroom access at Montreal train station01:37 | August 2, 2019 -
Man shot in suspected bar robbery gone wrong: police00:40 | May 27, 2019 -
Île-Bizard blue collar workers praised for tireless flood relief efforts02:18 | May 7, 2019 -
Kirkland man accused of attempted murder of his 2 children found not criminally responsible02:03 | March 20, 2019 -
Armed cop ‘intimidated’ by Global News reporter at G7 protests, asks her to move01:31 | June 8, 2018 -
Global News Morning weather forecast: Friday, March 1001:13 | March 10, 2017 -
TransLink gets high marks in review of Canada’s transit systems04:16 | July 19, 2016
-
Magnotta trial: What is Not Criminally Responsible?| September 29, 2014
-
Global News at 5:30 Montreal: April 1312:49 | April 13, 2025
-
Global News Montreal at 5:30: May 715:09 | May 8, 2024
-
RDP residents and government officials team up to tackle source of smell02:19 | August 8, 2019
-
No free pass for bathroom access at Montreal train station01:37 | August 2, 2019
-
Man shot in suspected bar robbery gone wrong: police00:40 | May 27, 2019
-
Île-Bizard blue collar workers praised for tireless flood relief efforts02:18 | May 7, 2019
-
Kirkland man accused of attempted murder of his 2 children found not criminally responsible02:03 | March 20, 2019
-
Armed cop ‘intimidated’ by Global News reporter at G7 protests, asks her to move01:31 | June 8, 2018
-
Global News Morning weather forecast: Friday, March 1001:13 | March 10, 2017
-
TransLink gets high marks in review of Canada’s transit systems04:16 | July 19, 2016
Magnotta trial: What is Not Criminally Responsible?
Description
September 29, 2014
If Luka Magnotta is found “not criminally responsible” for the murder of Jun Lin, he could still be locked away for life.
Just not in a prison.
[tp_video id=1588862]
<b>WATCH: </b><strong>Magnotta admits to killing Jun Lin, jury must decide if he was of sound mind. Domenic Fazioli reports</strong>
Canada’s new “not criminally responsible” (NCR) regime passed last summer. It applies to those who are found to have committed an act that constitutes an offence, but cannot appreciate or understand what they did was wrong due to a mental disorder at the time.
Magnotta’s lawyer <a href="http://globalnews.ca/news/1587134/magnotta-trial-proceedings-begin-monday-in-montreal/" target="_blank">argued in court Monday</a> that his client is schizophrenic and was not criminally responsible when he killed Lin, a Chinese student, in 2012.
<b>READ MORE: </b><a href="http://globalnews.ca/news/451660/magnotta-diagnosed-with-paranoid-schizophrenia-2005-doctors-letter-reveals/" target="_blank"><strong>Magnotta diagnosed with paranoid schizophrenia, 2005 doctor’s letter reveals</strong></a>
If a person is found NCR, they are referred to a provincial review board.
The board can make one of three determinations: an absolute discharge, if the person is not deemed a public safety threat; a conditional discharge; or a detention in secure psychiatric facility or hospital run by the province.
The law now makes public safety paramount to the decision-making process.
It also creates a new “high-risk” designation – if a person has committed a “serious personal injury,” is likely to commit further violence, or the acts were of such “brutal nature” as to indicate a grave risk to the public.
High-risk NCR people would not get conditional or absolute discharges. They would not be allowed to go out into the community unescorted and escorted passes would only be allowed for medical reasons.
Most significant, they could not be released until the high-risk designation was revoked by a court.
Furthermore, their cases could be up for review only every three years – not annually.
And if the NCR person were ever released, victims would be notified upon request.
Magnotta could end up serving more time in a provincial facility if he is found high-risk NCR.
If Magnotta were convicted of first-degree murder, for instance, he would likely not be up for parole until he served 25 years of his sentence. If convicted of second-degree murder – which would mean he didn’t plan the killing - he would not be eligible until serving between 10 and 25 years.
Critics of the new NCR regime have argued that those who suffer from mental illness will have fewer incentives to plead NCR and may wind up in regular prisons – thus crowding the system with mentally ill inmates.
National News
-
Trump’s feud with Pope Leo widens as Vance, Johnson chime in1:544 hours ago -
‘We need serious leadership’: Floor-crosser MP Gladu praises Carney’s fuel excise tax suspension0:417 hours ago -
‘I feel like I’m in the presence of students’: Carney chides Poilievre on the economy3:087 hours ago -
‘He’s made a career out of it’: Poilievre slams Carney for causing inflation2:488 hours ago -
OpenAI limits access to new model as firms warn of AI-driven cyberattacks2:158 hours ago -
Unauthorized peptide marketing a pressing concern for CMA2:309 hours ago -
Vance reacts to Pope’s critique of U.S.-Iran war, advises he ‘be careful’ when talking theology2:589 hours ago -
Canada pistachio-linked salmonella outbreak still ongoing more than a year later1:029 hours ago -
Ontario solicitor general answers questions on accidental release of inmates2:089 hours ago -
Outside the box prom accessories to help you steal the show!5:0611 hours ago
Advertisement
Top News
-
9 dead, 13 injured in Turkey after 2nd school shooting in 2 days1:5010 hours ago -
Israel and Lebanon hold talks in Washington4:1110 hours ago -
An absolutely stacked Rock and Roll Hall of Fame class of 2026 announced0:2910 hours ago -
Health Matters: 7-Eleven brand sandwiches recalled due to listeria concerns2:0413 hours ago -
Sudan crisis: Millions facing starvation as war enters 4th year6:2414 hours ago -
China calls U.S. blockade of Iran ‘dangerous and irresponsible’2:041 day ago -
Carney says he will temporarily suspend Canada’s fuel excise tax amid Iran war1:112 days ago -
1,000+ in Hollywood sign letter opposing Paramount-Warner Bros. deal1:522 days ago -
Trump insults Pope Leo, deleting AI image of himself as Christ-like figure1:572 days ago -
The 1st social media war between the US and a foreign adversary11:364 days ago
Sponsored Content
Global National
-
Global National: April 1521:404 hours ago -
Global National: April 1421:531 day ago -
Global National: April 1321:482 days ago -
Global National: April 1221:563 days ago -
Global National: April 1121:524 days ago -
Global National April 1022:065 days ago -
Global National: April 922:106 days ago -
Global National: April 821:291 week ago -
Global National: April 721:191 week ago -
Global National: April 621:461 week ago
Trending
-
Scrapping taxes to lower gas prices4:1912 hours ago -
Adopt A Pet: Meet Scrappy5:0712 hours ago -
Fun Science: Kitchen chemistry5:1312 hours ago -
Rising cost of insuring homes due to wildfires4:4912 hours ago -
Health Matters: 7-Eleven brand sandwiches recalled due to listeria concerns2:0413 hours ago
Canada
-
Canada pistachio-linked salmonella outbreak still ongoing more than a year later1:029 hours ago -
Carney government to table spring economic update at end of April0:3710 hours ago -
Liberals back social media ban for kids under 16 amid growing debate8:3813 hours ago -
Alberta RCMP seeks public help identifying 2 suspects after laser units stolen from esthetician offices2:0013 hours ago -
Manitoba toddler rescued after falling through ice0:4713 hours ago -
Canadians welcome ‘necessary’ gas tax relief1:5113 hours ago -
Carney’s gas tax holiday to cost $2.4B, last until Labour Day1:5613 hours ago -
Alberta to introduce 120-day approval timeline for major projects2:0813 hours ago -
Carney promises ‘humility, determination, clear understanding’ after clinching majority3:582 days ago -
Alberta independence support increases in new Leger poll1:592 days ago
U.S. News
-
Vance reacts to Pope’s critique of U.S.-Iran war, advises he ‘be careful’ when talking theology2:589 hours ago -
Katy Perry calls Ruby Rose’s allegations of sexual assault ‘reckless lies’2:4710 hours ago -
‘It’s a big mistake’: Lebanese citizens pessimistic amid U.S.-hosted peace talks2:561 day ago -
Vance accuses Iran of ‘economic terrorism,’ Iranians say U.S. closure of Strait of Hormuz real threat1:271 day ago -
Husband of missing woman in Bahamas released without charges1:462 days ago -
‘Stop arming Israel’: People protest outside Schumer, Gillibrand’s office to block U.S. weapons sale3:352 days ago -
OpenAI CEO Sam Altman’s home targeted in 2nd attack in 2 days0:283 days ago -
U.S. blockades Iranian ports after peace talks fail5:072 days ago -
Trump orders Strait of Hormuz blockade as face-to-face talks with Iran fail4:574 days ago -
Energy drink contributed to 17-year-old cheerleader’s death, says U.S. lawsuit0:444 days ago
Advertisement
World
-
Iran threatens to expand Hormuz blockade to Red Sea1:574 hours ago -
Canada’s top junior tennis players compete in international event2:248 hours ago -
Vance reacts to Pope’s critique of U.S.-Iran war, advises he ‘be careful’ when talking theology2:589 hours ago -
9 dead, 13 injured in Turkey after 2nd school shooting in 2 days1:5010 hours ago -
Israel and Lebanon hold talks in Washington4:1110 hours ago -
Sudan crisis: Millions facing starvation as war enters 4th year6:2414 hours ago -
Carney suspends federal gas tax2:451 day ago -
Trump says Iran peace talks could resume in next 2 days1:5913 hours ago -
Vance accuses Iran of ‘economic terrorism,’ Iranians say U.S. closure of Strait of Hormuz real threat1:271 day ago -
Trump insults Pope Leo, deleting AI image of himself as Christ-like figure1:572 days ago
Politics
-
Iran threatens to expand Hormuz blockade to Red Sea1:574 hours ago -
Carney, Liberals hold 1st caucus meeting since gaining majority2:104 hours ago -
Kitsela treaty tabled in Victoria as B.C. gov’t struggles with DRIPA controversy2:024 hours ago -
Metro Vancouver board votes to roll back increases in development cost charges1:555 hours ago -
Gibbons faces $15.3 million debt, may lose town status1:525 hours ago -
Sim supports Surrey’s call for public inquiry1:525 hours ago -
Sakatchewan municipal leaders gather for annual SUMA bear pit1:316 hours ago -
‘We need serious leadership’: Floor-crosser MP Gladu praises Carney’s fuel excise tax suspension0:417 hours ago -
Global News at 6 Toronto: April 15 202623:047 hours ago -
‘I feel like I’m in the presence of students’: Carney chides Poilievre on the economy3:087 hours ago
Health and Wellness
-
BC denies funding for drug to help treat rare blood disorder3:171 day ago -
Alberta’s plan to curb MAID access worries ALS, Parkinson’s advocates2:0313 hours ago -
St. Albert kids create handmade gifts to support cancer patients1:301 day ago -
Healthy Living: Keeping on top of your overall gut health4:081 day ago -
Closing arguments in ‘MAID’ lawsuit in BC Supreme Court2:122 days ago -
Doctor’s referral not needed for certain medical tests under proposed Alberta law1:472 days ago -
Health Matters: Long-term care workers in Nova Scotia begin protest2:172 days ago -
Get Fit: Stretching Tips3:012 days ago -
Ask an Expert: Five steps to building self-esteem4:424 days ago -
Ask an Expert: Boosting your smoothie6:064 days ago
Advertisement
Investigative News
-
Report: Lytton wildfire rebuild lacked framework2:154 weeks ago -
Deportation hearing begins for alleged Iranian regime official1:384 weeks ago -
Questions about how Tumbler Ridge shooter had access to guns2:302 months ago -
Deportation hearing for suspected high-ranking Iranian official living in Canada held behind closed doors0:452 months ago -
Battling extortion violence in Surrey7:132 months ago -
Fighting the addictions crisis in northern Manitoba’s Nisichawayasihk Cree Nation5:024 months ago -
‘They can shoot me’: Fear-stricken Ontario family speaks after Bishnoi gang violence in Canada2:514 months ago -
Government responds to allegations of widespread fraud at Social Development and Poverty Reduction ministry3:304 months ago -
Ontario’s landfill crisis: The cost of inaction2:535 months ago -
Russian snipers using Canadian rifles in Ukraine despite sanctions2:386 months ago
News Bloopers
-
‘Amoosing’ cow leaves Global News Morning crew in stitches1:594 months ago -
‘Can’t use that on TV’: Watch a Global News reporter jump from the highest bungee jump in Canada0:3712 months ago -
Black bear in tree has rough landing after being tranquilized at Halifax-area park0:4919 months ago -
Edmonton, B.C. morning show hosts settle NHL playoff bet3:0523 months ago -
‘You can’t make this stuff up:’ Loud clap of thunder interrupts live TV segment at pivotal moment0:2530 months ago -
Fun times? Global News personalities help clear snow in search of ‘fun’ story2:0041 months ago -
‘Buzzworthy moment’: Colin D’Mello recaps Doug Ford accidentally swallowing a bee1:5744 months ago -
‘Did you just call me daddy?’: Morning show hosts can’t hold back laughter after on-air mixup1:1545 months ago -
B.C. dad hoping to see his cloud photo on TV get his wish following viral TikTok campaign2:1248 months ago -
Bloopers: Phil Darlington slips, slides and falls in these Our Winter City outtakes1:3842 months ago