Finance Minister Ted Morton said Wednesday a provincial sales tax isn’t on the horizon – although he didn’t rule out the possibility this revenue tool will one day hit Albertans’ pocketbooks.
Fielding questions on the Alberta government’s fiscal update and record $4.8-billion projected deficit, Morton declined to reveal where he stands on a sales tax.
However, he noted the Premier’s Council for Economic Strategy – led by economist and former federal cabinet minister David Emerson – is examining tax options as it drafts a blueprint for securing the province’s long-term prosperity amid erratic oil and gas revenues.
"In the medium to long term, looking at all the options is a good idea," Morton said. "Looking at all the options we have for smoothing out revenue volatility."
In Vegreville on Wednesday evening, Premier Ed Stelmach pledged there will never be an Alberta sales tax as long as he’s premier.
And Stelmach’s finance minister acknowledged a provincial sales tax would be a tough sell in the only province in Canada without one.
"Albertans are rather happy with the fact, and even proud of the fact, that there isn’t a sales tax in this province," Morton said, "and for the time being this government doesn’t have any intention of changing that."
However, talk of a new tax down the line drew staunch criticism from all opposition political parties.
The Liberals and Wildrose Alliance suggested the Stelmach government collects enough dollars.
"We don’t have a revenue problem. We have a spending problem," said Liberal MLA Hugh MacDonald, the party’s finance critic.
Wildrose Alliance Leader Danielle Smith noted the province’s low taxes are an advantage and chastised Morton for not ruling out a sales tax.
"It’s irresponsible. It sends the wrong message," Smith said. "They’ve got to get their spending under control. This is not going to be resolved by just loading up new taxes on Albertans."
However, several prominent economists have advocated for a provincial levy on consumption, arguing it would provide Alberta with a reliable revenue source.
In a study last year, world-renowned tax policy specialist Jack Mintz suggested an eight per cent tax similar to the federal GST would allow Alberta to cut personal and corporate taxes to roughly five per cent.
"Alberta has long resisted a general sales tax, but global economic integration and much more mobile capital and labour could force the province to reconsider strongly held positions with respect to tax policy," said the report by Mintz, who heads the University of Calgary’s school of policy studies.
Alberta had a three per cent sales tax briefly in 1936, but the Social Credit measure proved unpopular and was rescinded.
Today, such a tax is prohibited under legislation unless approved in a referendum.
According to a 2008 C.D. Howe Institute analysis, a provincial tax of two or three per cent patterned on the GST would deliver about $1.5 billion to government coffers.
Morton said the Tories are reviewing ideas pitched by Mintz and others. The finance minister added the government’s long-awaited savings strategy will be outlined in the next provincial budget.
Also next year, the Premier’s
Council for Economic Strategy will release its financial blueprint for Alberta, offering suggestions to guide the next three decades.
Former cabinet minister Emerson, chairman of the 12-member group, said the council recognizes that the province has a fiscal gap, but he said he’s uncertain whether final recommendations will touch on a sales tax.
"Generally speaking, it doesn’t support the fiscal stability of the province to rely so heavily on resource revenues to fund government operations," Emerson said. "There’s a tremendous and important role to be played in non-resource revenues in terms of initiatives that could broaden and diversify the economic base."
NDP Leader Brian Mason, whose party also opposes a consumption tax, wants the Conservatives to instead overhaul the province’s flat income tax, adopted in 2001.
rdaliesio@theherald.canwest.com
Comments
Want to discuss? Please read our Commenting Policy first.