Trump FBI probe: Judge appears open to special master, says, ‘What’s the harm?’

Click to play video: 'Trump requests ‘special master’ in FBI’s Mar-a-Lago investigation'
Trump requests ‘special master’ in FBI’s Mar-a-Lago investigation
WATCH ABOVE: Former U.S. president Donald Trump is requesting a "special master" look at the classified documents the FBI seized from his Mar-a-Lago home. Neetu Garcha explains what a special master is, and why some lawmakers say such a move could put lives at risk. – Sep 1, 2022

A federal judge Thursday appeared to give a boost to former President Donald Trump’s hopes for appointing an outside legal expert to review government records seized by the FBI, questioning the Justice Department’s arguments that Trump couldn’t make the request and that it would needlessly delay its investigation.

“Ultimately, what is the harm” in such an appointment, U.S. District Judge Aileen Cannon asked department lawyers. But she did not rule on the request, saying she would do so later.

Read more: Biden’s prime time speech: Trump, allies threats to democracy

Lawyers for Trump say the appointment of a special master is necessary to ensure an independent inspection of the documents seized by the FBI during the Aug. 8 search of Mar-a-Lago.

This kind of review, they say, would allow for “highly personal information” such as diaries or journals to be separated from the investigation and returned to Trump, along with any other documents that may be protected by claims of attorney-client privilege or executive privilege.

Story continues below advertisement

Chris Kise, a Trump lawyer and former Florida solicitor general, told Cannon that appointing a neutral party would restore public faith in the investigation.

“This is an unprecedented situation. We need to lower the temperature,” Kise said. “We need to take a deep breath.”

Click to play video: 'Trump FBI search: Judge to appoint ‘special master’ to review documents seized in raid'
Trump FBI search: Judge to appoint ‘special master’ to review documents seized in raid

The Justice Department has said an appointment is unwarranted because investigators have completed their review of potentially privileged records and identified “a limited set of materials that potentially contain attorney-client privileged information.” The government also says Trump lacks legal grounds to demand the return of presidential documents because they do not belong to him since he no longer occupies the White House.

“He is no longer president, said Jay Bratt, the head of the Justice Department’s counterintelligence section. He is unlawfully in possession of them.”

The department has also expressed concerns that the appointment could delay the investigation, in part because a special master probably would need to obtain a security clearance to review the records and special authorization from intelligence agencies.
Click to play video: 'U.S. Justice Dept. claims evidence of ‘concealed’ papers at Trump’s Mar-a-Lago home'
U.S. Justice Dept. claims evidence of ‘concealed’ papers at Trump’s Mar-a-Lago home

But Cannon, who said she would issue a written ruling at some point, pressed the government on that point, asking, “Ultimately what is the harm?”

Read more: U.S. Justice Department cite efforts to obstruct probe of documents at Trump estate

Story continues below advertisement

Cannon had said on Saturday, before the latest arguments in the matter, that her “preliminary intent” was to appoint a special master. It was not clear whether she might make a final determination Thursday or how her view might be affected by the fact that the Justice Department says it has already reviewed potentially privileged documents.

It was also not clear who might be serve as that outside expert. In some past high-profile cases, the role has been filled by a former federal judge.

Click to play video: 'Biden comments on affidavit released on Trump Mar-a-Lago search, reports of classified documents'
Biden comments on affidavit released on Trump Mar-a-Lago search, reports of classified documents

Cannon was nominated by Trump in 2020 and confirmed by the Senate 56-21 later that year. She is a former assistant U.S. attorney in Florida, handling mainly criminal appeals.

Tucker reported from Washington.

Sponsored content