Advertisement

Police, RCMP to join forces in mortgage fraud investigation

CALGARY – Police will speak with Calgary Northeast MP Devinder Shory after announcing Thursday their review of a massive mortgage fraud involving dozens of city properties has become a criminal investigation.

The Tory MP, among hundreds of defendants named in a civil suit filed by the Bank of Montreal, is accused of negligently acting as a lawyer on behalf of clients who used fraudulent documents to obtain mortgages, according to a statement of claim filed by the bank.

RCMP spokesman Sgt. Patrick Webb said investigators, after reviewing a sample of the voluminous paperwork provided to police by the bank, determined criminal activity might be involved. The investigation would involve speaking with Shory, among others named in the civil suit, he said.

“What that will involve is members from both agencies working together to look at the materials presented by Bank of Montreal – literally tens of thousands of documents – as well as commencing the likely hundreds of interviews, which will be required,” said Webb.

The investigation, to be jointly conducted by RCMP and Calgary police, follows a civil suit filed by the bank that alleges the defendants fraudulently inflated the values of properties and then enticed so-called straw buyers to assume liability for the debt. Many of the mortgages went into default, leading to losses of more than $30 million for the bank, according to court documents.

Webb said it will likely take investigators weeks to comb through the bank documents and determine whether there is any evidence to warrant criminal charges.

The bank is suing 14 groups in what it believes is a sophisticated scheme that includes Calgary lawyers, mortgage specialists, real estate agents and bank employees for the allegedly fraudulent deals that occurred during the peak of the city’s housing boom in 2006 and 2007.

None of the allegations has been proven in court.

Prime Minister Stephen Harper said two weeks ago that Shory would not be pushed from the caucus or the party as the suit, at that time, was a civil matter.

Duane Bratt, an associate professor of political science with Mount Royal University, said it’s too soon to jump to conclusions.

“A criminal charge is separate from a criminal investigation,” he said.

Shory’s political future will likely lie with the disclosure forms he was required to file to the Conservative party before the 2008 election, he added.

“Now, we know that he was part of a civil suit prior to the elections. If there was that disclosure on the candidate forms, and the Conservatives said, “˜OK,’ then that raises questions about the Conservative party,” he said. “If it wasn’t disclosed, that’s grounds for removal from caucus.”

Shory has been named in connection with five of the hundreds of mortgages that were allegedly obtained through fraudulent means, according to court documents filed by the bank.

Shory has denied any wrongdoing and said in a statement that he would “vigorously” defend himself against all allegations.

Bank of Montreal has accused Shory of negligence and not fraud.

“We allege that he was negligent in the way he acted as counsel for both the bank and the straw buyer in four transactions in which the bank suffered a loss of approximately $300,000,” a spokesman for the bank said last week.

Webb said Shory’s name was among those provided by the bank.

Calgary police economic crimes Staff Sgt. Gordon Bull said this will be one of the department’s largest mortgage fraud investigations.

“These things often run into years. And that’s on a smaller scale investigation. We’re in the process now of assembling our team and formulating the model for the investigation and determining the resources we can put into it, but this will be long and drawn out,” said Bull.

Unlike the civil process, where the focus is on recovering lost money, a criminal investigation looks for evidence pointing to criminal activity such as forging documents.

Bull said investigators are starting out with hundreds of names, but will narrow that list.

Al Rosen, a Toronto-based forensic accountant who has investigated previous well-known fraud cases, said he was pleased the police are pursuing the bank’s allegations as a criminal matter.

“In my experience, it’s unusual for them to have acted so quickly,” Rosen said. “The track record of the RCMP on such actions has not been particularly successful.”

Last week, a rare and sweeping civil court order allowed the bank to search the homes of some individuals named in the lawsuit.

The search led to the seizure of cash, passports and chequebooks from U.S. and Canadian banks, according to Jim Bancroft, the supervising solicitor appointed by the court to oversee the searches.

A child’s backpack crammed with mortgage applications was also uncovered, as were jumbles of bank documents and receipts.

Calgary Herald with files from Jason van Rassel

Advertisement

Sponsored content

AdChoices