Advertisement

Appeals court rules Manitoba had the right to impose wage freeze on public sector

Click to play video: 'Appeals court rules Manitoba had the right to impose wage freeze on public sector'
Appeals court rules Manitoba had the right to impose wage freeze on public sector
A court ruling that struck down the Manitoba government’s public-sector wage freeze as a violation of collective bargaining rights was overturned by a higher court Wednesday – Oct 13, 2021

A court ruling that struck down the Manitoba government’s public-sector wage freeze as a violation of collective bargaining rights was overturned by a higher court Wednesday.

The provincial Court of Appeal ruled the government was within its rights to legislate the wage freeze. It said the original Court of Queen’s Bench judge erred in deciding the legislation violated bargaining rights under the Charter of Rights and Freedoms.

Read more: Manitoba’s public sector wage freeze bill violates Charter, court rules

Read next: Mendicino, RCMP will face committee over contracts to firm now tied to China

“While there can be no doubt that the imposition of wage restraint legislation … impacts or interferes with the collective bargaining process, the case law establishes that the type of legislative interference does not amount to ‘substantial interference’ when it is broad-based and for a limited period of time,” Chief Justice Richard Chartier wrote on behalf of the three-member appeals panel.

Story continues below advertisement

Moreover, the government removed only wages from the bargaining table, not any other issue, Chartier added.

Click to play video: 'Province to introduce bills that may freeze public-sector wages'
Province to introduce bills that may freeze public-sector wages

Public sector labour groups said they are considering an appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada.

“Unions believe in free and fair collective bargaining. It works, and we don’t think governments should be tipping the scales (and) dictating outcomes,” Kevin Rebeck, president of the Manitoba Federation of Labour, said on behalf of the unions representing some 120,000 civil servants, health-care workers, teachers and others.

The Progressive Conservative government introduced the wage-freeze bill in 2017 and said it was necessary to address growing annual deficits.

The bill called for any new public-sector collective agreement to start with a two-year wage freeze, followed by pay increases of 0.75 per cent in the third year and one per cent in the fourth.

Story continues below advertisement

The bill was passed by the legislature but never proclaimed into law, and the government held out the possibility of amending it. The unions said, however, that government negotiators acted as if the wage freeze was firmly in place.

A Court of Queen’s Bench judge last year called the bill “draconian”, ruled it invalid, and said the government should have tried to negotiate before resorting to legislation.

Click to play video: 'Manitoba government proposes five unpaid days off for civil servants'
Manitoba government proposes five unpaid days off for civil servants

The appeals court panel said that was an error.

“There is no legal prerequisite on governments to consult or negotiate prior to passing legislation,” Chartier wrote.

Finance Minister Scott Fielding welcomed the ruling. When asked whether the government might try to legislate more wage freezes in the future, he said the Tories prefer negotiations.

Story continues below advertisement

“We want to have groups at the bargaining table making decisions, that’s the most preferable approach.”

The government’s court victory was not complete.

The appeals court upheld a lower-court ruling that found the government violated collective bargaining rights during contract talks at the University of Manitoba in 2016.

Click to play video: 'Coronavirus outbreak: Pallister defends work-reduction proposal'
Coronavirus outbreak: Pallister defends work-reduction proposal

In that case, the university had already offered a seven per cent wage increase over four years when the government interrupted the process and ordered the university to seek a one-year wage freeze.

The trial judge did not commit any errors in finding those actions an infringement on the collective bargaining process, the appeals court ruled.

Read more: Manitoba government plans to appeal ruling that quashed wage freeze

Read next: Cost of living, inflation poised to take centre stage as Parliament returns

Story continues below advertisement

Despite the wage-freeze bill, some groups have managed to secure higher salaries.

A recent tentative agreement with the Manitoba Nurses Union, retroactive to 2017, includes wage hikes totalling 9.6 per cent over seven years.

Click to play video: 'University of Manitoba faculty union authorizes strike vote'
University of Manitoba faculty union authorizes strike vote

Sponsored content