Hey voters, do not fear the Saskatchewan MRI

Click to play video: 'Liberal Party and Saskatchewan government spar over private MRI clinics' Liberal Party and Saskatchewan government spar over private MRI clinics
WATCH: The federal Liberals are again threatening to claw back federal health funding if Saskatchewan continues with its private MRI program – Aug 24, 2021

Saskatchewan was thrust into the national spotlight this week as Liberal Party Leader Justin Trudeau threatened to reduce funding to the Prairie province over its private MRI policy.

What’s the problem? Why should Canadians care? Why does our nation desperately need a serious debate on health reform? Here are a few facts that voters might find of interest.

Read more: Liberal Party, Scott Moe spar over private MRI clinics

To begin, private MRI clinics have operated in Canada since the first one opened in Alberta in 1994. Despite critics claiming the sky would fall once these clinics opened, their dire predictions have yet to come true.

Many of these clinics operate no differently than private labs in Canada. Just as your doctor may send you to a private lab for bloodwork, patients are sent to private MRI clinics for a scan. In both cases, the government still picks up the tab for the service.

Story continues below advertisement

Other times, patients may decide to pay for a private MRI scan at one of these clinics instead of waiting several months (in some cases more than a year) for the system to provide the scan. Each time this happens, one more patient is removed from a government waiting list, shortening the waiting period for everyone else.

Read more: Closing arguments begin in B.C. case launched in 2009 over private health care

Presently, six provinces have private MRI clinics that sell scans to the public, including Trudeau’s home province of Quebec. Why he only threatened Saskatchewan with a funding cut is not clear.

If anything, progressive politicians such as Justin Trudeau should like a unique feature of the Saskatchewan government’s MRI policy: private clinics are required to provide a free scan to someone waiting in the public system every time the clinic sells a scan to patients.

Since 2016, more than 10,000 patients there waiting have received free scans from these private MRI clinics. Another 10,000 patients received paid scans. Ultimately, this means the public system did not have to pay for these scans or add those patients to its already long waiting lists.

Click to play video: 'Manitoba willing to try MRI system that allows patients to pay for scans' Manitoba willing to try MRI system that allows patients to pay for scans
Manitoba willing to try MRI system that allows patients to pay for scans – Dec 1, 2016

Are we to assume Trudeau would have preferred those 20,000 patients be added to government waiting lists? Would you want thousands of additional patients in front of your spot in line?

Story continues below advertisement

The Prime Minister’s criticism of Saskatchewan’s policy can likely be chalked up to politics. Progressives have a long history of threatening that their opponents would eliminate public health care altogether. In reality, in each of the six provinces that have private MRI clinics, government spending on public health care has never been higher.

Read more: NDP push to reform Saskatchewan health care by ending private MRIs

The problem is throwing money at the system doesn’t work. Our system has been in trouble for years despite massive increases in spending.

Prior to COVID-19, health-care waiting lists had never been longer. During the pandemic, governments postponed thousands of surgeries, diagnostic scans and other medical appointments. Those waiting lists are now even longer.

To make matters worse, pressure on our system will increase substantially in the years ahead as our aging population takes its toll — the oldest of the enormous baby boomer generation starts to hit the magic age of 75 this year. Government data shows the average 75-year-old patient costs the health-care system more than three times as much as the average 50-year-old.

Story continues below advertisement

Compared with other countries, our system is underperforming.

A new study by the progressive Commonwealth Fund evaluated the performance of health-care systems in 11 developed nations. Canada ranked 10th. Commonwealth Fund research has also shown that of those 11 countries, Canada has the longest waiting periods to see a specialist and receive elective surgery.

Read more: Premiers urge Ottawa again to increase health care funding

Their research also found Canada actually spent more than most of the countries that outperformed our nation.

One thing countries with better performing universal health-care systems do differently is they allow patients to choose between using the public health-care system and non-government providers (non-profit or for-profit clinics). This not only provides patients with more choices, but non-government providers also take pressure off of the public system.

To be sure, we have a lot of good, talented people who are stuck in a system that is both underperforming and unsustainable. Allowing more clinics to open up and provide more services to the public won’t solve all our problems, but it is a step in the right direction — just as we have seen in Saskatchewan.

Colin Craig is the president of, a new Canadian think-tank based in Calgary.


Sponsored content