Are Canada’s pot-impaired driving penalties too strict? New study suggests yes
A new study from the University of British Columbia (UBC) is suggesting that Canada’s cannabis-impaired driving penalties may be too strict.
That’s after researchers found no link between low levels of THC, the psychoactive chemical in pot, and car crashes.
WATCH: What are the penalties for driving high?
The study, recently published in the journal Addiction, also looked at the impact of other illegal drugs and alcohol on collisions.
Under Canada’s drug-impaired driving laws, drivers found to have blood THC levels of between two and five nanograms per millilitre are liable for a fine of up to $1,000, while drivers with over five nanograms face a minimum $1,000 fine and up to 10 years in prison for a first offence.
THC levels in the blood spike quickly after smoking cannabis but drop to two nanograms per millilitre within four hours of smoking. Edible products drop similarly about eight hours after ingesting THC, according to UBC researchers.
The UBC study analyzed blood samples from more than 3,000 drivers who were treated in B.C. trauma centres between 2010 and 2016. It looked at accident reports for more than 2,300 of those crashes and included 1,178 of those in which the driver was deemed responsible for the crash in its final analysis.
WATCH: New funding to fight drug-impaired driving in B.C.
In analyzing blood samples from those drivers, researchers found no increased risk of crashes when THC levels were below five nanograms per millilitre. It said there may be an increased risk of crashes above that level but that just 20 of 1,825 samples tested had THC greater than that amount.
“At blood levels of less than five nanograms/ml, THC does not appear to be associated with an increased risk of crashing,” said Dr. Jeffrey Brubacher, an associate professor at UBC’s emergency medicine department and lead investigator in a five-year study looking at cannabis and crashes.
“That’s significant because the new impaired driving laws do include penalties for drivers with THC levels between two and five nanograms/ml, suggesting that the laws may be too strict.”
In contrast to THC, researchers found recreational drugs such as cocaine, amphetamines and heroin increased the risk of a crash by 82 per cent.
WATCH: Young Canadians perceive alcohol as less dangerous than cannabis while driving — study
Sedating medications such as antihistamines, benzodiazepines, other hypnotics and antidepressants were also found to boost crash risk by 45 per cent.
Alcohol was found to have the highest association with crash risk, with drivers showing a blood-alcohol content over 0.08 six times more likely to crash compared to non-drinkers.
“The biggest problem remains alcohol,” said Brubacher. “Drug-impaired driving is probably a problem, but let’s not lose sight of alcohol.”
The federal government maintains that cannabis use increases the risk of car crashes and says the number of drivers killed in crashes in Canada who test positive for drugs now exceeds those who have alcohol in their system.
Abbotsford Police Chief and Chair of the Canadian Association of Chiefs of Police Drug Advisory Committee Mike Serr said he’s pleased to see more research being done on drug-impaired driving.
But he said with much still unknown, police still believe starting with more restrictive rules makes sense.
“We do know is cannabis is impairing. And I think a lot more research needs to be done before we’re willing to change perspective,” he said.
“We really want to know what the scientists say, and what we do is we also have highly trained officers who are standardized field sobriety test-capable as well as drug recognition experts and they’re able to test whether a person is impaired.”
Serr added that while the research is valuable, he has concerns people may read it and downplay the possible consequences of sparking up and getting behind the wheel.
A survey of Canadian police forces in April by the Canadian Press found no noticeable increase in the number of drug-impaired driving charges handed out since cannabis was legalized, except for in Alberta.
© 2019 Global News, a division of Corus Entertainment Inc.