December 4, 2018 6:00 am
Updated: December 4, 2018 9:25 pm

Albertans waited 6.5 months for medically necessary treatment in 2018: report

WATCH: AHS is downplaying a new report on wait times that says most Albertans are waiting far longer than most Canadians for access to some health-care services. Heather Yourex-West reports.

A A

From receiving a referral from a general practitioner to getting in to see a specialist and then to actual medical treatment, Albertans in need of various procedures and tests spent about 26.1 weeks waiting for them, according to an analysis by the Fraser Institute.

That accounts for just over 6.5 months of time.

The number is down slightly from what Bacchus Barua, the institute’s director of health policy studies, called a record high reported last year, which saw wait times average about 26.5 weeks.

Story continues below

In comparison, patients in Saskatchewan waited an average of 15.4 weeks for treatments, according to the report. On the other side of the spectrum, patients in New Brunswick waited the longest — coming in at 45.1 weeks, or just over 11 months.

READ MORE: How do emergency room wait times differ in Alberta’s 3 major cities?

The average Canadian wait time in 2018 was 19.8 weeks.

The Fraser Institute’s study, led by Barua, looked at wait times for 12 different medical specialties, including orthopaedic surgery, diagnostic tests and medical oncology.

It also broke down the timelines for when patients get a referral from a family doctor to when they see a specialist, and then again from the specialist visit to receiving the medical treatment they need.

Watch below: ‘It just feels like they’re not listening’: Saskatchewan the only province without dedicated seizure unit

Albertans needing orthopaedic treatment waited the longest, with an average of 55.3 weeks — more than a year — on the list. For Alberta medical oncology patients, the wait was about 4.8 weeks.

From the referral from a family doctor to a visit with a specialist, patients across the country waited about 8.7 weeks, which is down from 10.2 in 2017.

From the specialist visit to the point where the patient receives their treatment, Canadians wait an average of another 11 weeks, which is an increase from 2017, when the average wait was 10.9 weeks.

“I think most policymakers — [and] physicians themselves — are reporting that their patients are still waiting longer than is clinically reasonable and I’m pretty sure that Albertan patients themselves would prefer more timely access to care if possible,” Barua said.

READ MORE: Alberta government continues to fall short of providing continuing care in timely manner

The wait times for diagnostic treatments are also lengthy, the report said, suggesting that Canadian patients could wait up to 4.3 weeks for a CT scan, 3.9 weeks for an ultrasound and as long as 10.6 weeks for an MRI.

“It is estimated that, across the 10 provinces, the total number of procedures for which people are waiting in 2018 is 1,082,541,” the report’s executive summary reads.

The report also said that according to doctors’ reports, patient requests for postponement or delay only account for about 12.2 per cent of those on the waiting lists.

The Fraser Institute has been measuring wait times for medical treatments since 1993, when Alberta’s average wait time was 10.5 weeks.

Watch below: Calgary medical staff looking for public’s ideas of 3D printing possibilities

“While there is a little bit of improvement given the record high that we saw last year, the trend is that wait times are actually increasing over the last two-and-a-half decades,” Barua said.

He added that Canadians wait significantly longer than those in other countries with universal health care, like Sweden, the Netherlands and Australia.

LISTEN: Bacchus Barua joins Danielle Smith to discuss his report on health care wait times

View link »

“This is a Canadian problem and unfortunately, the governments have generally followed a policy of putting more money into the system and no government has really tackled reform the way that other countries [have] through universal health care,” Barua said.

In an emailed statement from Alberta Health Services on Tuesday, a spokesperson said the report was based on a survey that “in many cases, less than five physicians responded to.”

“It’s based on anecdotal information rather than hard data,” AHS said.

The statement goes on to say the government views wait times as a serious issue, adding that wait times for seeing a gastrointestinal specialist in Calgary were reduced by 98 per cent in the past two years. AHS also said wait times for breast cancer surgery were reduced by more than 60 per cent in Calgary and 30 per cent in Edmonton in the same time period.

It went on to say the 2018 provincial budget allotted $40 million for surgery wait time reductions.

Barua said Tuesday that 228 doctors participated in the study, meaning the survey represents one in four doctors across the province.

“I think most Albertans would want to hear the voices of these physicians—and the data they provide—detailing the long wait times their patients have to endure,” he said.

The report pointed out that in the Atlantic Canadian provinces, survey responses were lower than in other provinces, which could result in the average wait times being higher or lower than what’s been reported.

Methodology: The data for this issue of “Waiting Your Turn” were collected between Jan. 11 and May 15, 2018. Survey questionnaires were sent to practitioners in 12 medical specialties: plastic surgery, gynaecology, ophthalmology, otolaryngology, general surgery, neurosurgery, orthopaedic surgery, cardiovascular surgery, urology, internal medicine, radiation oncology and medical oncology. Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu Limited provided mailing lists, drawn from the Canadian Medical Association’s membership rolls. This year, the overall response rate was 17 per cent.

© 2018 Global News, a division of Corus Entertainment Inc.

Report an error

Comments

Want to discuss? Please read our Commenting Policy first.