April 24, 2018 3:45 pm
Updated: May 3, 2018 1:49 pm

5 things you need to do to win (or survive) a CRA tax audit

WATCH: If you did avoid an audit, here's what you should and shouldn't do with your tax refund.

A A

So you’ve filed your taxes and received your notice of assessment, but now there’s another letter from the Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) in your mailbox with a request to see more of your paperwork. What do you do?

READ MORE: Here are the Canadians most likely to get a tax audit 

Story continues below

Most likely, what you’re looking at is an inquiry notice, said David Rotfleisch, owner of Toronto tax law firm Rotfleisch and Samulovitch.

If you’ve claimed, say, a medical expense deduction and filed your return electronically, the taxman may ask you to produce copies of the receipts that prove that you’re actually eligible for the tax break in question.

All you have to do is have your papers in order and respond by deadline, usually 30 days from the date of the letter. The CRA will disallow your tax break if you can’t back up your claim and may decide to audit you.

You should keep your tax records for six years, in case you’re ever the subject of a review.

READ MORE: Canada’s 2018 tax season: 6 things you need to know

An audit is an examination of your books and records to see if you’ve actually paid all the taxes you owe.

READ MORE: 3 of the tax mistakes you’re most likely to make, according to the CRA

The CRA may do a so-called desk audit if it wants to dig deeper into a particular aspect of your return. These examinations are particularly common if you have business income and declared losses or if your return shows real estate transactions, Rotfleisch said.

Then there are field audits, in which the taxman will physically show up at your home or place of work.

Now, let’s assume you’ve received the dreaded notice that you’re actually being audited. What do you do?

SIGN UP: Global News has a new Money newsletter

Cooperate and be respectful

The worst thing you can do when the CRA comes calling is pretend you didn’t hear.

“You’re going to get audited — there’s nothing you can do to stop it,” said Dale Barrett, author of Tax Survival for Canadians: Stand up to the CRA and the principal of Barrett Tax Law.

Instead, the best thing you can do is get organized and be cooperative in the process, he added.

WATCH: These are three tax deductions Canadians often forget to claim

Get professional help

Rotfleisch advises getting professional help as soon as you receive your audit letter.

“The sooner you get professional advice, the better case you are preparing from the get-go,” he said.

Still, that doesn’t necessarily mean lawyering up. A tax accountant with the proper qualifications, such as someone with the Chartered Professional Accountant (CPA) designation, should be perfectly able to help you through a simple audit where you claimed what you were entitled to and have the paperwork to show it.

READ MORE: Self-employed? Here are 6 steps to get your taxes right

However, if there are gray areas in your case, if you haven’t kept your books in order, or if you suspect your accountant messed up, you can turn to a tax lawyer, Rotfleisch added.

You might also want to seek legal help if you have a feeling that things are getting off track.

One such instance may be when the CRA decides to do a net-worth audit.

The agency normally conducts audits by combing through your records and receipts, Barrett said. However, when you can’t back up every detail of your tax return and income situation, the agency might resort to a rough calculation of your net worth.

Typically, the CRA will look at a three-year period, Barrett said. They’ll look at your assets and liabilities on Jan. 1 of Year One, and then compare that to your financial situation on Dec. 31 of Year Three.

“They’ll [also] come to an idea of what your living expenses should have been for those three years,” Barrett said.

If the CRA believes you need $100,000 a year to sustain your lifestyle and finds that you’ve accumulated $200,000 worth of assets on top of that when you’ve been declaring an income of $75,000 a year, you’re in trouble.

READ MORE: Here’s what taxes can do to your savings if you’re not careful

The problem is, though, that net-worth audit calculations can be “way off,” Barrett said.

And there’s a risk that auditors will use a net-worth audit as a shortcut, instead of painstakingly combing through the available documents, he added.

WATCH: What you need to know for the 2018 tax season

Understand whether you’re in it to win – or to settle

At the very beginning of the process, ask your representative what you’re chances are, Rotfleisch said. This may sound obvious, but if it’s clear that the CRA is right and you are not, the aim should be to simply rip off the band-aid as quickly and painlessly as possible. Respond to the taxman, admit your error, and pay quickly to minimize interest and penalties.

“Beware of an accountant who has made a bad expense claim telling you that the fight has merit so as not to admit a mistake,” Rotfleisch writes on his website, TaxPage.

You can usually get a second opinion about your case from a tax lawyer in a one-hour consultation that will cost you between $200 and $1,000, Rotfleisch said.

READ MORE: 4 important things you probably aren’t noticing on your T4 tax slip

Check in with your tax representative

Even if you’ve hired someone to help you through the audit, you can’t wash your hands of it, Rotfleisch said.

Especially in the period between May and June, accountants are often swamped, and it’s easy for some things to fall through the cracks, he added. If you aren’t receiving regular communication about the process, follow up in order to make sure things are moving along.

Appeal the case if it makes sense and it’s worth it

At the end of an audit, the CRA will usually tell you in a letter whether it found any mistakes and you owe more tax. You have 30 days to question those findings. The CRA will then take a second look and get back to you. If you still don’t agree with your assessment, you can challenge it in tax court, Barrett said.

Before you go to court, however, make sure that the amount of tax in dispute (plus interest and penalties) is worth your lawyer’s fees, Rotfleisch said.

SIGN UP: Global News has a new money newsletter

© 2018 Global News, a division of Corus Entertainment Inc.

Report an error

Comments

Want to discuss? Please read our Commenting Policy first.