Advertisement

Unauthorized Tragically Hip biography sparks heated debate among fans

Click to play video: 'Hip book backlash'
Hip book backlash
A new biography on Gord Downie and The Tragically Hip is striking some bad chords among Hip fans and one of the band members. Guitarist Rob Baker says, "Don't believe everything you read" – Apr 11, 2018

Music journalist Michael Barclay’s The Tragically Hip biography came out on April 3, but Hip fans have been buzzing about the unauthorized account of the band’s rise to Canadian rock and roll fame for the last few months.

One reason for the latest controversy among Hip fans is the reaction by one of the band’s members to the book The Never-Ending Present.

https://twitter.com/tthbaker/status/983843865508622336

Rob Baker, The Tragically Hip’s guitarist, took to Twitter the day the book was released to condemn parts of Barclay’s account. “Don’t believe everything you read. I saw a few paragraphs and almost blew my coffee out my nose,” he said in a Tweet.

According to Barclay, if there are any inaccuracies, it’s not for lack of trying to get the facts straight.

Story continues below advertisement

“Rob Baker said he read a couple of paragraphs. The book is 450 pages long. I’m sure I got a couple of dates wrong but the band itself refused the fact-checking document,” said Barclay.

For news impacting Canada and around the world, sign up for breaking news alerts delivered directly to you when they happen.

Get breaking National news

For news impacting Canada and around the world, sign up for breaking news alerts delivered directly to you when they happen.
By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy.

The author added that most biographies are unauthorized and that personal accounts are usually delivered through memoirs.

“I did dozens of interviews, almost 80 interviews with people who work closely with the band.”

Nevertheless, the tug of war between biographer and subject has fans turning against each other. CKWS has received access to a closed The Tragically Hip Facebook forum where thousands of Hip fans from all over the world gather to discuss the Canadian rock legends. In the forum, Barclay’s unauthorized book has caused people to take sides.

A screenshot taken from a private fan forum on Kingston that has over 15,000 dedicated The Tragically Hip fans from all over the world. Michael Barclay’s unofficial biography, and Rob Baker’s reaction to it has gotten fans heated. Facebook

The discussions have become so heated among fans that the moderator of the forum has started deleting all negative comments about the book.

Story continues below advertisement
A post from the moderator of the Tragically Hip forum on Facebook warns any negative comments concerning The Never Ending Present, will be deleted.
A post from the moderator of the Tragically Hip forum on Facebook warns any negative comments concerning The Never Ending Present, will be deleted. Facebook

As for Barclay, he hopes that fans will judge his work on its journalistic merits and the value of his reporting done on the Hip because he too is a fan.

“As a fan I wanted this story to be told for a long time.”

Click to play video: 'A side of the Tragically Hip that few know about'
A side of the Tragically Hip that few know about

Sponsored content

AdChoices