Advertisement

NDP alleges anti-union group is holding the pen on a Tory MP’s bill

OTTAWA — New Democrats are suggesting an anti-organized labour group is the “true architect” of a Conservative MP’s private member’s bill aimed at forcing unions to open their books to the public.

The Opposition continued hurling questions Wednesday about the origin and purpose of Conservative MP Russ Hiebert’s bill, days after it was revealed the MP had been attending several closed-door meetings with senior government players and Merit Canada, a vocal anti-union organization and construction contractor.

Terrance Oakey, the president of the organization, met with 14 Conservative MPs and senior staff members last month, according to records on the federal Lobbying Commissioner’s website.

“He has had unprecedented access to the (Prime Minister’s Office),” NDP MP Wayne Marston said during a committee hearing into the proposed legislation.

“Would you say Merit has the benefit of making significant financial gains if this bill is passed?” he asked.

Story continues below advertisement

James Smith, vice president of the United Brotherhood of Carpenters and Joiners of America, took the question.

“Absolutely,” he said. “This is a dream come true for the Merit shop.”

NDP MP Pat Martin went so far to say the bill was created “with the express purpose of busting unions” in the construction industry.

“Why would we set up this bureaucracy to further the commercial interests of Merit, who are the true architects of this bill?” he asked.

Get breaking Canada news delivered to your inbox as it happens so you won't miss a trending story.

Get breaking National news

Get breaking Canada news delivered to your inbox as it happens so you won't miss a trending story.
By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy.

The prime minister’s chief of staff and director of planning have both been in several meetings with Hiebert and Oakey to discuss Bill C-377, lobbying records show. A spokesman for the Prime Minister’s Office says staff there has also met with the bill’s opponents.

At the heart of this proposed legislation, according to Hiebert and his supporters, is the fact that the public relinquishes hundreds of millions of dollars every year because of the tax exemptions union members receive.

Hiebert’s bill would compel unions to submit an annual “standard set of financials” to the Canadian Revenue Agency and publish those figures online – in much the same way charities have been operating for more than three decades.

“Bill C-377 is simply about transparency requirements that fall upon entities that enjoy the public trust,” Oakey told the committee, considering a portion of union dues are funnelled toward issues that have little to do with the collective bargaining process.

Story continues below advertisement

Unions supporting last summer’s Quebec student protest while others contribute to the sovereigntist Party Quebecois or campaign against oil pipelines were some examples he listed.

But the bill casts such a wide net, critics argue, it will end up invading workers’ privacy and could even be considered unconstitutional; as the bill is written, any payment exceeding $5,000 — including pensions, salaries and benefits — would have to be publicly disclosed in detailed, annual statements to the Canada Revenue Agency.

Hiebert and his supporters have said they are open to amendments to mitigate any privacy concerns, but none has been presented to the committee.

Still, having to disclose every payment exceeding $5,000 could also end up revealing trade secrets to Smith’s competition — Merit Canada, he said.

“This bill, with the reporting we will be required to do, would show various training programs,” Smith said. “That would be a competitive advantage that would be opened up to the Merit contractors, to see what we are doing and what our contractors are doing.”

Since the bill began making headlines in October 2011, New Democrats have been accusing the government of having its hands in crafting the legislation and using the private member’s bill as a “back door” to push through its agenda – accusations the Conservatives and Hiebert denied.

The MP has maintained throughout that the bill is a necessary step for transparency and accountability to the taxpayer and union members – a stance with which Oakey, a former Conservative staff member, agrees.

Story continues below advertisement

Working with the government to create a disclosure regime is one of the few ways to ensure transparency and continued public trust, he said during Wednesday’s finance committee meeting.

“Canadians have the right to know how their tax dollars are being used to influence public policy,” he said.

Oakey successfully lobbied the government last year to repeal the Fair Wages and Hours of Work Act, which governed federal contracts and the payment of fair wages.

Follow Amy on Twitter.

Sponsored content

AdChoices