A Dr. Seuss classic is under fire by the school district in Prince Rupert for being too political.
‘Yertle the Turtle,’ a popular children’s picture book released in 1958, apparently doesn’t fit with the school board’s mandate banning political content from the classroom.
The controversy erupted after an elementary school teacher in the district was disciplined for keeping a placard from a teachers’ rally in her car. The sign from a recent demonstration read: ‘Kids Deserve More: Bill 22 Gives Less.’
Other teachers began storing items in their car in a show of solidarity.
One of the teachers wanted to get a baseline on what was appropriate as she planned on abiding by the school district’s wishes.
She sent a list of about 20 quotations to the district for approval including a quote from former Canadian Prime Minister John A. Diefenbaker.
All of the submitted quotes were OK with the district, except for two, including one from Yertle the Turtle.
Get daily National news
“I know up on top you are seeing great sights, but down here on the bottom, we too should have rights,” one turtle says to Yertle.
The school district said the quote was “definitely political messaging,” and pointed out that the teacher’s vehicle was parked on private property.
Joanna Larson, President of the Prince Rupert District Teachers Union, thinks the whole situation is absurd.
“”It’s ridiculous. I don’t know if there’s better word than that,” she says.
“Teachers are definitely feeling oppressed here, it’s a right to freedom of expression. We’re talking about Dr. Seuss here.”
Larson says it’s difficult to insulate children in the classroom from current events in the news, like the current labour dispute between teachers and the provincial government.
“We certainly don’t want to indoctrinate them one way or another, but current events are part of what public education is about. I am sure most people remember doing current events in their classroom and watching the news.”
Dave Stigant, acting director for the Prince Rupert School District, says the dispute isn’t really about a Dr. Seuss book, but instead about political messaging in schools.
“The attempt here is to minimize the issue by making it absurd. I think there’s been success in that. But it escapes the real issue which is, should children be exposed to political messaging when they are sent to class?”
Stigant says the district has no objection to the use of the book or the use of the quote, as long as it isn’t used for political purpose on school property.
He says the Dr. Seuss quote has been singled out because of the labour dispute with the provincial government.
A letter of direction was sent was sent to teachers asking them to refrain from political messaging on school board property and in the classroom. If they were on public street, that’s not our jurisdiction, he says.
In 2011, an arbitrator decided that political materials should stay out of B.C. classrooms.
He says during the legal strike phase from September to March, there were several incidents of teachers coming to work wearing t-shirts and buttons with union and political messages.
Teachers were asked to cover those up while in the classroom and on school board property.
Comments
Want to discuss? Please read our Commenting Policy first.