Advertisement

Canada weak on foreign bribe probes, prosecutions. Numbers? Grim: report

  • A new law was implemented in 1999 to combat foreign bribery by Canadians and their companies.
  • Only nine investigations have led to criminal charges being laid.
  • Because a majority of cases end with a plea deal and limited information is published, it is unclear how fines are even calculated.
Click to play video: 'SNC-Lavalin pleads guilty to fraud, to pay $280M fine'
SNC-Lavalin pleads guilty to fraud, to pay $280M fine
Canadian engineering giant SNC-Lavalin has pleaded guilty to one count of fraud, and will pay a $280-million fine for bribes the company made to secure projects in Libya years ago. Abigail Bimman has reaction to the deal, and what it means for the company – Dec 18, 2019

Twenty-five years after Parliament banned Canadian companies and executives from bribing foreign officials to win deals, the number of anti-corruption enforcement probes launched here “remains exceedingly low,” a new report says.

The report, by the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development, says that since Canada’s Corruption of Foreign Public Officials Act was adopted and implemented in 1999, only nine probes have led to criminal charges being laid in foreign bribery and corruption cases.

Only four people have been convicted, and only four companies in all have ever faced sanctions, the OECD report adds.

Because there are no sentencing guidelines and most of the handful of cases that have been launched were concluded through a plea deal with limited information published, it is publicly unclear how fines are calculated in foreign bribery cases in Canada, the report stated.

“Unfortunately, the news is not good,” said John Boscariol, a Toronto lawyer and partner at McCarthy Tetreault who leads the law firm’s international trade and sanctions practice.

Story continues below advertisement

Boscariol dissected the OECD report briefly on his LinkedIn professional networking account and highlighted some key findings.

“The report highlights a significant concern many of us have been raising for years now — the lack of publicly available information on important elements of resolved foreign bribery cases and the lack of clarity around self-reporting,” he added.

Boscariol was responding to findings by members of an OECD working group assessing Canadian efforts to combat bribery of foreign officials under its International Anti-Bribery Convention.

Click to play video: 'China jails former top secret police official for life'
China jails former top secret police official for life

The report and its recommendations reflect the findings of an anti-corruption working group made up of experts from Austria and New Zealand. The report was adopted on Oct. 12. The OECD group did its own research and made visits to Toronto and Ottawa in May and June.

Get the day's top news, political, economic, and current affairs headlines, delivered to your inbox once a day.

Get daily National news

Get the day's top news, political, economic, and current affairs headlines, delivered to your inbox once a day.
By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy.

“Due to the limited case information publicly available, the root causes of the deficiencies (by Canadian officials) in detecting, investigating and prosecuting foreign bribery, are difficult to pinpoint,” the OECD report stated.

Story continues below advertisement

“The recent pattern of restrictive court interpretation (in Canada) of the Corruption of Foreign Public Officials Act is also a source of concern calling for action.”

The OECD is calling on Canadian authorities — the RCMP and federal public prosecutors — to review and analyze themselves to understand why enforcement results are so exceedingly low.

FILE – The logo at the entrance of the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) headquarters in Paris. (AP Photo/Francois Mori, file)

The RCMP did not initially comment on the report.

Five days later, Sgt. Kim Chamberland, a spokesperson for the national police at its headquarters in Ottawa, said the Mounties are heartened that the OECD working group recognized the “RCMP’s prompt response in initiating bribery investigations, and our foreign bribery awareness-raising initiatives in Canada and abroad.” Those efforts demonstrate the RCMP’s “continued commitment to disrupting, deterring and preventing corruption domestically and internationally.”

More recently, Sgt Chamberland added, the RCMP has “increased its resources and specialization in foreign bribery matters. Furthermore, the RCMP international anti-corruption team progressively increased its engagement with the private sector, as well as public government agencies, on foreign bribery.”

Story continues below advertisement

Inside the OECD report, however, the RCMP reportedly shared that from 2018 until the end of 2022, the Mounties special foreign bribery and corruption unit opened 31 new foreign bribery investigations (six per year on average).  During the same period, investigators closed “at least 33 investigations,” including cases opened before 2018.

The OECD working group said the sharp increase in the number of foreign bribery investigations the RCMP reportedly opened since its last review was “encouraging,” but said that sentiment was “offset by the high proportion of discontinued investigations.”

Given the size of the Canadian economy and the many sectors in which its many major companies operate, the number of investigations that led to prosecutions would be expected to be higher, the report suggested.

Both the United States and the United Kingdom have more foreign bribery prosecutions.

The OECD is recommending that Canadian police and justice officials conduct an analysis into all foreign bribery cases undertaken in Canada since the new law to “identify the challenges that may impede effective investigation and prosecution of the foreign bribery and related offences and develop an action plan to address these.”

Click to play video: 'International anti-corruption court'
International anti-corruption court

The Supreme Court’s Jordan ruling that proscribes time limits on any accused’s trial appears to be a factor that is limiting and hurting successful prosecutions, the OECD noted, especially because foreign bribery probes are far more complex and take far more time to complete.

Story continues below advertisement

In one example in 2019, some criminal charges laid against one SNC-Lavalin executive, Sami Bebawi, were stayed by a Quebec Superior Court judge who ruled it took Crown prosecutors too long to bring the case to trial and delays were unreasonable.

The OECD report also recommended that the RCMP work with FINTRAC, the Financial Transactions and Reports Analysis Centre of Canada, to detect foreign bribery through money laundering tracking and delivering intelligence on suspicious transactions.

Former SNC-Lavalin vice-president Sami Bebawi is shown at the courthouse in Montreal in  2019. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Graham Hughes. Graham Hughes/The Canadian Press

Sponsored content

AdChoices