THE WEST BLOCK
Episode 33, Season 2
Sunday, April 21, 2013
Host: Tom Clark
Guests: Luiza Savage, David Graham, Mark Carney, Larry Rousseau
Location: Ottawa
Tom Clark:
Welcome to The West Block on this Sunday, April the 21st, from the nation’s capital, I’m Tom Clark.
Coming up on today’s show, after a devastating week in the United States, we tap into the pulse of the nation.
And then, Bank of Canada Governor Mark Carney is getting ready to fly across the pond and take on a new job at the Bank of England. We have an exclusive interview.
And finally, think you’ve seen an attack ad? Well just wait until you see the attack by government employees against the Harper government.
But first, this morning throughout the city of Boston and across America, prayers are being said for the dead and the wounded. A new week brings new hope but it can’t erase the memory of a horrendous few days.
Boston, under attack by terrorists.
Letters laced with a deadly poison sent to the president and a senator.
The president suffers a political and emotional defeat on a key gun control bill.
And finally, with the capture of a suspected terrorist in Boston, a national asks why.
President Obama: “All in all this has been a tough week.”
(on camera)
Tom Clark:
Well that’s perhaps the understatement of the week. What has this done to the American psyche and what will it do to American politics? Well joining me now from Washington DC, Luiza Savage, the Washington correspondent for Maclean’s magazine and David Graham, an associate editor for the magazine, The Atlantic. Welcome to you both and Luiza let me start with you. You know there was understandable relief and celebration with the capture of the second suspect on Friday in Boston but where does it all go from here because inevitably this is going to be put through the political prism? What happens next?
Luiza Savage:
Well already we’re seeing a political debate emerging over what to do with the suspect. Now the Obama administration has said they’re going to put him through the civilian criminal justice system but they’ve also said they’ll be interrogating him without reading him his Miranda rights at first. Now some of the civil libertarian groups are very concerned about this. On the other hand, you have republican law makers who’ve come out and said he should be taken out of the civilian court system and held in the military system as an enemy combatant. So there’s already this debate about just what to do with this one suspect, not to mention all the other political debates swirling around this, such as, for example, what the implications will be for the big immigration overhaul that’s been gathering momentum here in Washington and now some of the critics saying wait, wait, we need to slow this down and see whether there’s some security issues that need to be addressed first and others say that’s just a tactic to delay a long overdue reform that was finally gaining steam.
Tom Clark:
David is there any way that you can sort of characterize what the state of the soul of American is after all of this? As I said, a horrendous few weeks but is there a line that can describe America’s psyche today?
David Graham:
I think sort of shattered and confused and you know, there are so many things to happen in one week. And I think that it is people, are at a loss really.
Tom Clark:
Well you know, I want to go to one other thing, we’re talking about Boston but in the midst of all of this of course, the president was rebuffed by the Senate when they tried to bring forward a sort of a gun control bill as a result of the Newtown massacre. What occurred to me out of that was America said back at the time of the Newtown massacre, things are going to change, there’s a new mood in America. And yet here we see the end of it, there was nothing going on at all. Why did nothing change as a result of that? Luiza, do you want to take it?
Luiza Savage:
Well I think things are changing but I think it takes time. So what you had was a vote in the Senate whereby Senate rules, you need 60 votes to pass this amendment and they had a majority but they didn’t have enough votes, and several things happened. One was there were four Democratic senators who were against the amendment. They come from Conservative rural states like Alaska, North Dakota, Montana, Arkansas, so they weren’t able to win over those senators who are worried about their re-election and worried about the influence of the NRA. But you see also at the same…
Tom Clark:
Just let me jump in here because I want to ask David about this very point. I mean is there a sense David of paralysis that violence in America is becoming such a commonplace thing as horrendous as it may be, but here you have political paralysis in terms of dealing with a little corner of it.
David Graham:
That’s right. I mean it’s striking to me how little the politics changed at the top level. We saw in repeated polls showing that 90 per cent of Americans roughly would like to see some sort of tightening of gun laws, often expanded background checks not a sweeping package. And yet, within the context of the Senate, things change very little; still closely divided, still a slight majority that voted for but they couldn’t get the 60 votes to end the filibuster. So what we’re seeing is that while the rest of the country seems to be moving, Washington is still more or less stuck where it was before.
Tom Clark:
David can you put this in context for me as well because I mean we can’t compare Boston of course to 9/11. And yet there are those moments in American history where people say well the country changed as a result of this. Is the country going to change because of Boston?
David Graham:
I think it’s probably a little early to tell. It is impressive to see how affected people have been by Boston which was a scary event with three fatalities of course plus the police officer who was shot, so four. But in comparison to an event like Newtown which was said to be changing the political debate and hasn’t with so many more fatalities and the weekly and daily gun violence incidents. I’m impressed by how much people seem to be shaken by Boston in comparison.
Tom Clark:
Luiza let me ask you this, you’ve been down in Washington a long time now with Canadian eyes, is this a country that at least the way it appears to be so deeply divided on the issues of violence and security, and I guess the question is if Newtown can’t overcome that what can?
Luiza Savage:
Well I would quibble a little bit. First of all, I don’t think America is getting more violent. I think violent crime is down; murder rate lowest in 40 years so let’s keep that context in mind. I think we’re less divided here than we were right after 9/11 or than Americans were. Think about the big debates about transforming the government, creating the Department of Homeland Security, the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan, how to treat detainees, a lot of those questions have been worked through and you even see the Obama administration sort of normalizing some of the things that Bush did, and some of those debates are largely over. The big debate now on gun control is one that is heating up because you see people like Mayor Michael Bloomberg of New York City and his huge fortune starting to go in and spend that money on individual congressional races to support candidates who support gun control. And you see someone like Gabby Giffords, the congresswoman who was shot doing her effort to raise a movement in favour of gun control and that’s just going to take time. You see the Obama administration taking its campaign infrastructure, turning it into a grassroots mobilization effort called Organizing for Action and trying to see if they can use their technology and their know how to mobilize not just voters to the polls as they have in the past but now voters to influence their congress people. But this is all just starting so we don’t know the impact yet.
Tom Clark:
Get daily National news
David I’ve literally got 15 seconds left but if you had to project, do you think things are going to get better? Do you think that that gun control bill will finally get passed or not?
David Graham:
I think it’ll be interesting to see how Boston affects that but it’s too soon to tell. I think reform may be in the future but maybe not in the short term.
Tom Clark:
David Graham, Atlantic magazine and Luiza Savage of Maclean’s magazine, thank you both very much for being here this morning. I appreciate your insights.
Luiza Savage:
Thanks very much Tom.
David Graham:
Thank you.
Tom Clark:
Well coming up next on The West Block: the good, the bad and the ugly of the Canadian economy. Mark Carney joins us for an exclusive interview.
Tom Clark:
Welcome back. In just nine weeks, Mark Carney will change banks from Governor of the Bank of Canada to Governor of the Bank of England. With the British economy in pretty bad shape, it’s going to be a tough job but what’s the state of the Canadian economy as Carney leaves? Well here it is, your weekly West Block Primer:
So what do you want first, the good news or the bad news, or perhaps the ugly news? Well let’s start with the good news. The Bank of Canada says consumers are now the good guys here. They’re getting smarter about how to spend their money after reaching record levels of personal debt, it’s more under control. And Canadian consumers, pat yourself on the back for another reason, because Canadians are also borrowing smarter. A majority are now taking on safer fixed-rate mortgages instead the unpredictable variable rates. Now the bad and the ugly news: the International Monetary Fund and the Bank of Canada have slashed the prediction for Canada’s economic growth for the next six months, from a relatively healthy 2 per cent to a worrisome 1.5 per cent. Why? Well a lot of culprits. But Canadian businesses are still sitting on mountains of cash rather than investing it. And our exports, well they ain’t what they used to be. But back to the good news: the Bank of Canada says happy days aren’t too far away. Next year, it says — if its prediction doesn’t change, again.
Mark Carney Interview
Tom Clark:
And joining me now, the Governor of the Bank of Canada, Mark Carney. Governor good to have you here again.
Mark Carney:
Great to be here Tom.
Tom Clark:
Your report this week and that of the IMF on growth basically says that Canada has gone from the front of the class to the opportunity class in terms of growth. What went wrong in the last year that the forecasts were off?
Mark Carney:
Well two things: first I think we should recognize that if you’ve grown a lot faster than everyone else, sooner or later your growth is going to moderate a bit relative to those who still have a lot of catching up to do, so that’s first thing. The second thing is, relative to where we thought we’d be this time last year; the biggest difference has been the performance of Canadian exports. They actually have swung quite bit. They’ve been much less strong across the board, whether it’s oil and gas, non-energy commodities or importantly, goods and services – manufacturing, effectively — the much weaker than we would have expected.
Tom Clark:
You know a lot of people in an interview with the Governor of the Bank of Canada want one question and that is that you have consistently said in the past, careful about your debt levels because interest rates are going to be going up. But with the projection that we’re going actually into a bit of a downturn at least for the next couple of quarters, are you saying…is it inherent in what you’re saying that interest rates are going to stay down for 2013 before they start going up?
Mark Carney:
Two things: first, the next couple of quarters – growth was weak in the fourth quarter of last year and it picks up from there, so 1.5 per cent, we think first quarter, then 1.8 per cent, then above 2 per cent and averaging 2.5 per cent for the latter half of the 2013. So it is kind of picking up, slowly, surely from here right now. Secondly, in terms of the period over which we expect interest rates to remain at this level, we haven’t spelled that out explicitly. What we have spelled out are the factors that are going to influence how long that period is. First, the economy needs to growth above its so-called potential rate of growth. So it needs to grow more than 2 percentage points. Secondly, you need to see a continuation of what is becoming a positive evolution of household debt and aspects of the housing market. They’re both moving; moving in the right direction towards more sustainable levels. So we need to see those aspects and also inflation picking up a little bit before we would move.
Tom Clark:
Can you take all this and bring it down to main street what this means for the average Canadian what they can expect in terms of availability of jobs, in terms of as you said the housing market and so on?
Mark Carney:
Well, what we would expect is that, I mean, the Canadian labour market has performed pretty well – very well compared to other major economies — but it performed pretty well. We’re in a bit of a soft patch right now; we would see that picking up in the latter half of this year. There are a lot more Canadians who want to work and those Canadians who are working want to work more hours.
Mark Carney:
In terms of prices, inflation: low, stable, predictable. So they don’t have to worry about inflation. And in terms of access to credit, if a Canadian watching is thinking of expanding their business, setting up a business, getting access to credit, times are about as good as they can be and the only thing we’re saying with the glass half empty is if you’re taking out a longer term consumer loan or a mortgage, just remember that we’re in exceptional circumstances and rates over time will rise. And in fact, the next move will likely be a move up in Canada after we start to establish those conditions for sustainable growth.
Tom Clark:
I want to talk about you walking off the Canadian stage and onto the next assignment but before I do that, as you leave this country, is there one thing or can you point to one thing that this country should keep its eye on for the next generation that is going to be vital to the future of this country?
Mark Carney:
One thing…I think in the end it comes down to skills. We are obviously tremendously blessed with natural resources, other advantages, but seven with natural resources, the global race, if you will, global competition, global opportunity for the country, it’s all about skills and it’s skills across the board for all Canadians and all Canadian residents.
Tom Clark:
So that’s not only increasing skills here but being open to bringing in skilled workers from around the world?
Mark Carney:
Everyone starts very much with the first. And with the second, is the recent debate has been, is that very much in the spirit of what the government has said is that’s a transition; those are transitory measures. You’re bringing in high-skilled workers to transition to high-skilled Canadian residents to fill those jobs.
Tom Clark:
One of the hallmarks of your time as Governor of the Bank of Canada has been your accessibility. I can’t remember any other bank governor who has been so open in terms of communicating with the public about the issues of the day than you have been. Two questions on that: should your successor, whoever that may be, follow in those footsteps about open communication? And secondly, are you going to bring that style to England?
Mark Carney:
Well, I think to some extent the extra accessibility was a product of the times in that we had a financial crisis almost immediately when I showed up. I didn’t cause it. I want to make that clear, but we had one. And you know, you over communicate in those situations. People need to know, know what you know, what you don’t know, and that’s important. That said, yes transparency, we need to be more transparent in central banks. We have a lot of responsibility. We need to try to explain ourselves, what we’re doing so that the man and the woman on the street understand it and they can get on with their lives. So my successor, whoever he or she is, will, I would suspect would follow in that tradition in their own style. Different people have different styles but the intent would be the same.
Tom Clark:
Just got a final question for you, you’ve steered this country through some of its darkest financial times. You’re about to go over the England to try and rescue the European economy and turn that around. What do you do for an encore after that?
Mark Carney:
Try and take your seat.
Tom Clark:
There are days when I’d give it to you.
Mark Carney:
Exactly.
Tom Clark:
I think it’s safe to say, because this is the last time you’ll be appearing on this show as the Governor of the Bank of Canada, I think it’s safe to say governor that on behalf of all Canadians, we thank you for the extraordinary public service that you’ve rendered this country for the past number of years. Thank you very much.
Mark Carney:
Very kind, thank you Tom.
Mark Carney:
Good seeing you again.
Tom Clark:
Well coming up next on The West Block, political attack ads. You ain’t seen nothin’ yet.
Break
Tom Clark:
Welcome back. Attack ads, love them or hate them, they are part of our politics. Now usually they involve fairly juvenile jousting between political parties but now, Canada’s civil servants are joining the game taking direct aim at the Harper government. Here to talk about the attack ads is Larry Rousseau, vice president of the Public Service Alliance of Canada. Welcome, thanks very much for being here.
Larry Rousseau:
Thank you very much.
Tom Clark:
Before we start chatting, let’s show everybody just a bit highlight reel of this new video that you put out. Take a look.
Video is played
Tom Clark:
Wow, I mean I know that’s about the environment but that’s a really violent ad with almost sort of an inherent violence against women in that ad. Why would you do that?
Larry Rousseau:
It’s more of a wakeup call. There’s a shock effect to it but you know when you sound the alarm, when you hear an alarm go off in a building, it’s aggressive isn’t it? And you want it to go off but we’re sounding the alarm. We’re sounding the alarm because when you think about what has happened in the last year, especially since last year’s budget, C-38, C-45; we got the budget this year. Environmental deregulation, when you’ve taken 99.5 and 99.7 per cent of our lakes and rivers no longer subject to environmental regulation at the federal level, this is serious.
Tom Clark:
Okay, fair enough.
Larry Rousseau:
Very serious stuff.
Tom Clark:
And I understand that that’s the environmental message that you’re trying to get through here but when you have an ad where people are going in with jack boots and masks and dressed in black and inherently threatening a woman, aren’t you ceding a little bit of the high ground here? I mean sort of…I don’t know how you could claim in that to have the high ground when you show stuff like that.
Larry Rousseau:
You know, this is perhaps the artistic value of having analogy, alright? The analogy here is innocence. What can be more innocent than the environment that we wish to leave to our children and future generations and we’re saying that in order to allow corporations to make even more profits than they made in the past several years that we want to take out of the equation regulations that would make them think and actually make sure that the health and safety of Canadians has the primary interest. We’re looking out for the public interest not the corporate interest.
Tom Clark:
Aren’t you worried…I just want to stick with this ad for a minute because we deconstruct attack ads of course, but there does seem to be almost this inherent violence against this woman in the ad. I mean how is that acceptable?
Larry Rousseau:
Well no one was harmed in making these ads, let’s make that clear.
Tom Clark:
No but it was clearly intimidating you know when you look at it, the woman looks very intimidated by these people with jack boots knocking down her door.
Larry Rousseau:
How do you think that Canada’s Aboriginal communities feel right now when their cancer rates and their disease rates are going through the roof because of environmental pollution? This is why we’re talking about a wakeup call. We are on the front lines. Our inspectors, environmental inspectors on the front lines are seeing what’s happening. We’re being removed from the equation so we are out there saying if this continues, we will no longer be able to fill our mandate to protect the health and the safety of Canadians. We’ve had three videos so far: food inspection, we’ve had aviation inspection, our Transport Canada inspectors and now we’re talking about environmental regulation. This is serious.
Tom Clark:
This may be unfair of me but we’ve literally only got 30 seconds left. When you are that far over to the side with these videos that you’re producing, how on earth do you ever get it back to centre? How does this end? How does this confrontation end?
Larry Rousseau:
By provoking the debate; the unions are excellent, excellent about getting debate going. In a union conference people disagree but we make sure that we can get all of the information out so that we can make decisions. And Canadians are going to have to make decisions in the coming months and years regarding where our country is going. That’s what we want. We want debate.
Tom Clark:
Larry Rousseau, Public Service Alliance of Canada, I appreciate your time this morning. Thanks for coming in.
Larry Rousseau:
Thank you very much Mr. Clark.
Tom Clark:
Well that is our show for this week. Here’s what we’ve got our eyes on in the week ahead. On Tuesday night there’s an all-candidates’ debate for the Labrador byelection that you can hear on VOCN.com. And on Friday, leaders of the four main parties and British Columbia will have their first debate. You can listen to that at CKNW.com.
Global National will have all the latest news on these stories and on the attacks on Boston. Be sure to tune in throughout the week.
We leave you now with some of the sights and sounds from Boston as that city and that country pick themselves back up.
Until next Sunday, I’m Tom Clark. Thanks for being here and have a great week ahead.
Comments
Want to discuss? Please read our Commenting Policy first.