Twitter, racism and the Boston Bruins
WATCH: Members of the Boston Bruins react harshly to the so-called Bruins fans who sent out racist tweets directed at PK Subban
NOTE: The following post contains language that readers may find offensive. Discretion is advised.
MONTREAL – When Boston Bruins fans took to social media to vent their frustration at the team’s first loss against the Montreal Canadiens, it got ugly.
First this happened:
P.K. Subban is a power play specialist. Exhibit A -> http://t.co/dpSkbaSvu0
— Canadiens Montréal (@CanadiensMTL) May 2, 2014
Boston’s hockey team is playing against a team with a Black player. The black player scored. The word “nigger” is now trending in Boston.
— Shirley’s Grandson (@imfromraleigh) May 2, 2014
It was really trending
The tweets were ugly, profane and if they didn’t directly reference the colour of Subban’s skin, they used the hashtag of the n-word as emphasis.
Influence Communication, a Montreal-based company that specializes in media monitoring and analysis, noted that there were over 17,000 tweets containing the word “Subban” and the n-word on Thursday night.
“It was really trending last night.”
While Ève Couture, a director for Influence Communication, acknowledged that there were numerous examples of shockingly racist comments featuring the Canadiens’ defenceman, she noted that when given closer analysis, the social media reaction was not as xenophobic as it would first seem.
Although many, like the one with Subban’s face photoshopped onto a piece of feces, shared by a Twitter account with a man in blackface as a profile photo with just 30 followers, were possibly meant for a limited audience, the nature of social media saw the trend amplified as more people shared and commented on tweets.
“Many of the tweets were denouncing the racism,” she said, suggesting that context was very important – like this tweet on the same subject over a month earlier.
cute. RT @_KING_SK: Once again, Subban stop being a nigger
— Daniel Dudley (@DD_TribLive) March 25, 2014
A word map created by the company showed that the words most often linked to the n-word on Thursday night were “Subban,” “Bruins,” “Boston,” “s**t” and “racist.”
Other words included “score,” “strong” and “ashamed.”
Super disappointed in any Boston fans last night making racist remarks about PK Subban. Hatred in the rivalry is great, but not racism — Billy (@bplavy) May 2, 2014
Couture noted that the word was shared in a positive way as well.
“Nigger” was trending in Boston because P.K. Subban scored… It’s a rare moment in my life to be ashamed to be a Bruins fan. — Josh Tarr (@TheJoshTarr) May 2, 2014
Social media and sentiment
Werner Kunz, an assistant professor of marketing at the University of Massachusetts Boston, also suggested that just counting the number of tweets containing a word does not provide a reliable perception of sentiment.
“This kind of case shows right away, that while there is political correctness, people don’t think twice before tweeting something,” he said.
“There’s so many ways how we express stuff on social media, especially on Twitter, as it’s very abbreviated. Just counting the ‘n-word’ is one way to get an idea, but not the full picture.”
“What it shows is that while there are some people in Boston that think like that, the majority are not so much in favour of this.”
“As someone living in Boston, I have never experienced anything like this,” he added.
“It’s a little bit surprising that this happened in the first game.”
The Boston Bruins have officially distanced themselves from the social media actions of the team’s fans with a statement:
“The racist, classless views expressed by an ignorant group of individuals following Thursday’s game via digital media are in no way a reflection of anyone associated with the Bruins organization.”
It’s not the first time that the Bruins have had to apologize for racist slurs from team fans. In April 2012, the team released a similar statement after fans tweeted racist comments about Joel Ward, who scored the winning goal for the Washington Capitals.
“The Bruins are very disappointed by the racist comments that were made following the game last night. These classless, ignorant views are in no way a reflection of anyone associated with the Bruins organization.”
“It doesn’t take much to resurface, it’s just people venting but it’s ignorance, racism and hatred,” said Michael P. Farkas, the president of of the board of directors for Black History Month.
“Funny that, just after seeing what happened with the Clippers. It shows we’re hypocritical, we’ve got a serious problem.”
Farkas, who also happens to be a serious hockey fan himself, said that the sport has a history of being a tough game to get into if you’re a black player.
“Don’t forget, it’s coming from a league that used to say ‘if only he was white, he’d be on my team,” he said.
“It was a racist league. Hockey was never a black sport. Black people weren’t [considered] strong enough to play hockey, that’s where we’re coming from.”
He also noted the irony of the fact that the first black player to be signed to the National Hockey League, Willie Eldon O’Ree, was a winger for the Boston Bruins from 1957 to 1979.
As for what he thinks the Habs will do after the social media uproar?
“They’ll pay it no mind and just play the game.”
The sentiment is echoed by the mayor of Montreal. Denis Coderre, who also happens to be an avid Habs fan, often live-tweeting games, had this to say on Friday: “They [Boston Bruins’ fans] can get our answer by the number of goals we’ll score.”
Watch: Montreal mayor places wager with Boston mayor
Many Bruins’ fans were sharing their distaste with the racism displayed on Twitter Thursday night by firing back with their own tweets on Friday.
— brian dailey (@realbriandailey) May 2, 2014
And fans in Montreal? They too had a strong message to share.
— 25stanley (@25stanley) May 2, 2014
© Shaw Media, 2014