GRAND FALLS-WINDSOR, N.L. – American hunter Mary Beth Harshbarger walked silently and stoically out of a Newfoundland court on Friday, climbed into her lawyer’s white Mercedes, rolled down the window and let out a whoop of victory as she was driven away a free woman.
Accused of criminal negligence in the shooting death of her husband, Mark, on a hunting trip here in 2006, a judge found her not guilty Friday following a two-year extradition battle and a two-week trial.
The killing of Mark Harshbarger was "an accident and nothing more," ruled Newfoundland Supreme Court Justice Richard LeBlanc – the result of a "constellation of unfortunate facts which led Mrs. Harshbarger to conclude that she was shooting at a bear."
The experienced Pennsylvania hunter, 45, has maintained for years that she mistakenly thought her husband was a black bear when she shot him through the chest with a hunting rifle in the dim light of a late-summer evening in the central Newfoundland woods on Sept. 14, 2006.
Mark was walking alone out of the forest towards the pickup truck where Harshbarger was waiting with her two young children, and a loaded hunting rifle at her side. An expert markswoman, she aimed through her scope at what she said looked like the rough outlines of a bear, and fired.
Her in-laws have publicly insisted that Harshbarger deliberately killed Mark to collect a $550,000 US insurance policy on his life, and to take up a romantic relationship with his oldest brother, Barry, who like Harshbarger is estranged from the rest of the family.
"I’m very disappointed," said Dean Harshbarger, Mark’s other brother, in a telephone interview from Pennsylvania following the verdict. "We were hoping for some accountability here.
"Letting this woman go, now she’s going to be even more emboldened to come back here and wreak more havoc on everybody’s lives. I’m worried now for my safety."
Harshbarger did not testify during her trial and has said nothing to reporters since being extradited to Canada, and being held in custody since May.
On Friday, she sat alone in the court, listening without expression to the judge’s hour-long ruling. After hearing his not-guilty verdict, she stood up and wiped tears from her eyes.
LeBlanc, who decided the case without a jury, said he accepted Harshbarger’s statements to police that she did not intend to harm her husband.
"The death of Mark Harshbarger was clearly an unintended act of the shooting," LeBlanc said.
Because Harshbarger was not charged with murder, the case rested not on issues of malice or motive, but on whether she acted recklessly, and without regard for the safety of others.
Police re-enactments of the scene found that, because the sun had already set and the woods were becoming dark, Harshbarger could reasonably have believed a person walking towards her, in the long grass at the scene of the shooting, might have been an animal.
LeBlanc said Harshbarger believed there was a bear in the area, which her husband and a hunting guide had walked together into the woods to flush out of the forest.
Mark was expecting his wife to fire on a bear if one appeared.
The judge said Mark walked back to the truck alone, after his guide stopped in the trees to urinate. Mark was also not wearing hunter orange or other bright clothing, and he was hunched over – looking at the rough ground – when he came towards her.
"She had good reason to believe it was a bear," said LeBlanc, adding that Harshbarger’s decision to shoot, "does not meet the necessary level of blameworthy conduct" to constitute a crime.
Crown prosecutor Karen O’Reilly said she did not know if the decision would be appealed.
Dean Harshbarger and other family members have said they’re disappointed that details of Mary Beth Harshbarger’s past, collected by RCMP investigators in Pennsylvania, were not introduced at the trial.
O’Reilly said the criminal courts do not allow an accused’s prior convictions or past history to be used as evidence at trial.
"The relevant evidence was put before the justice," said O’Reilly. "If there’s other evidence about her past, if it wasn’t relevant to the charge before the court, then it would not have been appropriate to put it before the justice."
The trial has drawn attention across North America. U.S. television reporters attended the judge’s ruling on Friday, as well as a handful of curious Newfoundlanders.
"I was interested in the case," said Pierce Saunders, a local hunter. "I think it’s the right decision. She said she was sure she saw a bear."
In Pennsylvania, Dean Harshbarger had a different view.
"The judge is now saying that anybody in the woods is fair game for any hunter," he said. "If you see movement, you can shoot at it and then say, `whoops, I made a mistake, I shot at a black mass.’ It doesn’t matter any more."
Comments
Want to discuss? Please read our Commenting Policy first.