Carbon capture talks being blocked by tensions between Ottawa, Alberta: oil group

Click to play video: 'Alberta premier pledges to fight feds’ ‘just transition’ bill for oil, gas workers'
Alberta premier pledges to fight feds’ ‘just transition’ bill for oil, gas workers
Alberta Premier Danielle Smith is pushing back against the federal government's plan for oil and gas workers to transition to clean energy jobs. Heather Yourex-West explains how these workers have the most to lose. – Jan 10, 2023

The chief executive of Cenovus Energy Inc on Monday said friction between the federal and Alberta governments was making it difficult to hold meaningful discussions on funding carbon capture and storage (CCS) technology needed to decarbonize the oil and gas sector.

Cenovus CEO Alex Pourbaix was speaking on behalf of the Pathways Alliance, a collaboration between Canada’s six largest oil sands producers targeting net-zero emissions by 2050. It is planning to develop a CCS hub in northern Alberta, expected to cost $16.5 billion by 2030.

Of that, the group wants public money to fund 66 per cent, or roughly $10.9 billion, and says government support would speed up decarbonisation and help establish a competitive clean-tech industry in Canada.

Story continues below advertisement

So far the federal government has unveiled an investment tax credit worth $2.6 billion over the next five years, but both Ottawa and Alberta say the other should contribute more.

Alberta’s conservative Premier Danielle Smith is a vocal critic of Liberal Prime Minister Justin Trudeau and has slammed many aspects of federal climate policy, accusing Ottawa of trying to cripple the western province’s energy sector.

Trudeau told Reuters in an interview earlier this month Alberta was “hesitating around investing in anything related to climate change” and urged Smith to use her province’s budget surplus to invest in carbon capture.

“It’s very hard to have meaningful discussions with another party when you’re lobbing rocks at each other,” Alex Pourbaix, chief executive of Pathways member Cenovus, told Reuters in an interview.

“I would like to see the temperature turned down a little bit.”

Click to play video: 'Canadians will see high oil and gas prices through 2023'
Canadians will see high oil and gas prices through 2023

Pourbaix said there still needs to be a “significant discussion” between the federal and provincial governments and industry, and Pathways has set a target for that to happen early this year.

Story continues below advertisement

“I’ve had both levels of government telling me that they’re supportive of doing that and engaging on that. I think it has not occurred yet to the level it needs to resolve the differences that the groups may have,” he added.

Officials in Trudeau’s offices had no immediate comment. Smith must win an election in May in order to remain Alberta’s premier.

Asked to comment on the industry’s call to tone down political rhetoric, Taylor Hides, a spokesperson in Smith’s office, repeated that Alberta’s government is willing to invest in CCS and is looking forward to “working with our industry partners” to create jobs.

Canada is the world’s fourth-largest producer of crude, most of which comes from Alberta’s oil sands. The oil and gas sector is the country’s highest-polluting industry and needs to drastically cut emissions if Canada is to achieve its international climate commitments.

‘No time to slip’

The Pathways Alliance has already said Ottawa’s goal of cutting oil and gas emissions 42% by 2030, equivalent to a 35-megatonne reduction, is impossible.

The group could achieve a 22-megatonne reduction in carbon emissions by 2030, said Pathways President Kendall Dilling, but that depends on key components like public funding being agreed and a smooth regulatory approval process for the CCS project.

Story continues below advertisement

“We don’t have time to slip,” Dilling said.

“Canada’s track record on major infrastructure development in the last decade has been abysmal,” he said. “If we run into those same kind of troubles, then 2030 will not be realized.”

Click to play video: 'Prime Minister Trudeau urges Alberta to contribute to carbon-capture incentives'
Prime Minister Trudeau urges Alberta to contribute to carbon-capture incentives

Another recent source of federal-provincial conflict has been Ottawa’s “Just Transition” bill, which Ottawa says is meant to help retrain oil and gas workers for jobs in Canada’s green energy economy, but which Smith says will instead destroy better-paying oil and gas jobs.

Pourbaix and Derek Evans, CEO of Pathways member MEG Energy Corp, said their biggest concern is that Alberta will not have enough workers for decarbonizing the oil patch.

“I’m terrified we don’t have enough people on our side of the business to get the work done today, let alone what we’re planning on doing if we’re going to spend $16.5 billion by 2030,” Evans said.

Story continues below advertisement

The six companies in the Pathways Alliance, representing 95 per cent of Canada’s oil sands production, are Cenovus, MEG, Suncor Energy Inc, Canadian Natural Resources Ltd, Imperial Oil Ltd and ConocoPhillips.

(Reporting by Nia Williams in British Columbia and Steve Scherer in Ottawa; Editing by Marguerita Choy, Jonathan Oatis and Deepa Babington)

Sponsored content