WASHINGTON – The executives of the five biggest oil companies operating in the United States on Tuesday faced accusations of crafting shoddy safety plans that have left them just as ill-equipped as BP to deal with a major deepwater spill in the Gulf of Mexico.
Even as they claimed the Deepwater Horizon disaster was a preventable aberration, the oil company bosses were confronted with charges they developed "cookie cutter" response scenarios almost identical to the now-discredited plan employed by BP.
"When you believe that there is zero chance of a disaster happening, you do zero disaster planning," said Massachusetts Democrat Edward Markey, chairman of the House energy and commerce’s subcommittee on energy and the environment.
"The oil industry has invested nearly zero time and money into developing safety and response efforts."
Markey led lawmakers in the inquisition of executives from BP, Shell, ExxonMobil, Chevron and ConocoPhillips on the first of several days of congressional hearings into the safety of offshore oil exploration and drilling.
"We are sorry for everything the Gulf coast is going through," said BP America president Lamar McKay, who faced a demand from one Republican lawmaker to resign.
The oil executives’ testimony came ahead of a nationally televised Oval Office speech on the BP spill by President Barack Obama.
Obama returned to Washington following a two-day visit to the Gulf states of Mississippi, Alabama and Florida, where he promised to name individual commanders for each state polluted by oil from the spill.
Speaking to military personnel in Pensacola, Fla., Obama said he wanted Gulf residents to know his administration will "make sure BP pays for the damage it has done" to the coastal economy and environment.
"This is an unprecedented environmental disaster. It’s the worst in our nation’s history. But we’re going to continue to meet it with an unprecedented federal response and recovery effort," Obama said.
"This is an assault on our shores, and we’re going to fight back with everything we’ve got."
According to U.S. government estimates, about 40,000 barrels of oil are spewing into the Gulf each day despite BP’s ongoing efforts to capture the oil.
From the start of Tuesday’s congressional hearing in Washington, Democrats on the committee cast the oil companies as the villains – seating the executives in a hearing room that featured a large-screen, live video feed of the oil still spewing from BP’s ruptured well on the floor of the Gulf.
That bit of political theatre aside, the hearing produced embarrassing revelations about the oil industry’s contingency planning for potential disasters in the Gulf of Mexico.
Lawmakers who reviewed oil safety response plans found the five companies used the same outside contractor to prepare near-identical emergency scenarios, which one member of Congress described as "boilerplate."
Four companies included wildlife protection plans to preserve walrus populations – although walruses do not live in the Gulf. Plans by BP and two other companies cite the same deceased oil spill expert. ExxonMobil’s plan includes a 40-page public relations strategy, while devoting five pages to resource protection and nine pages to oil removal.
"It could be said that BP is the one bad apple in the bunch, but unfortunately they appear to have plenty of company," said Representative Bart Stupak, a Michigan Democrat. "Exxon and the other major oil companies are just as unprepared to respond to major oil spill in the gulf as BP."
The oil company officials sat silent for more than an hour during opening statements by members of Congress.
But when they got their chance to speak, executives from Shell, ExxonMobil, ConocoPhillips and Chevron collectively cast BP as an industry exception and expressed confidence their own operations were safe.
"This incident represents a dramatic departure from the industry norm in deepwater drilling," said Rex Tillerson, chairman and chief executive officer of ExxonMobil.
"When you properly design wells for the range of risk anticipated, follow established procedures, build in layers of redundancy, properly inspect and maintain equipment, train operators, conduct tests and drills, and focus on safe operations and risk management, tragic incidents like the one we are witnessing in the Gulf of Mexico today should not occur."
Marvin Odum, president of Shell, described BP’s project was "not a well we would have drilled" and said his company was "confident in our drilling expertise and procedures."
Democrats, however, cited statistics they said showed the oil companies placed safety far down the list of priorities in their rush to explore and drill for new sources of oil.
"The oil companies before us today amassed nearly $289 billion in profits over the last three years. They spent $39 billion to explore for new oil and gas," Markey said. "Yet, the average investment in research and development for safety, accident prevention and spill response was a paltry $20 million per year, less than one-10th of one per cent of their profits."
Republicans on the committee joined Democrats in their criticism of BP for being unprepared for the prospect that safety mechanisms might not work when accidents occur.
"You can’t have a contingency plan that says cross your fingers and hope the (oil well’s) blowout preventer works," said Texas Republican Joe Barton, "and that was the contingency plan."
But Republicans also criticized the Obama administration’s response to the spill and argued the BP disaster should not be used as a reason to limit U.S. drilling in the Gulf and other offshore locations.
"The Gulf of Mexico accounts for almost a third of U.S. oil production. If we eliminate that supply, the dependency on foreign oil will indeed go up," said Michigan Republican Fred Upton. "Saudi Arabia will be happy. Hugo Chavez, Ahmadinejad, they’ll be popping champagne perhaps. But the American consumer will be remembering the good old days when gas was only $4 a gallon."
Obama has ordered a six-month moratorium on deepwater drilling as an independent commission investigates the reasons for the explosion and sinking of the Deepwater Horizon, the BP-leased rig that triggered the oil spill.
Comments
Want to discuss? Please read our Commenting Policy first.