Behind Russia’s attacks on Ukraine’s nuclear power plants

Click to play video: 'Russian seizure of Ukrainian nuclear power plant raises global alarm'
Russian seizure of Ukrainian nuclear power plant raises global alarm
Russian forces have captured Europe’s largest nuclear power plant after attacking it overnight Friday, which started at least one fire, officials said as the invasion of Ukraine entered its second week. Experts say if a meltdown happened, consequences could be much worse than Chernobyl. Mike Armstrong reports from Poland – Mar 4, 2022

Russia’s attack on Europe’s largest nuclear power plant in Ukraine early Friday has raised fears of a disaster that could impact all of central Europe for decades.

The shelling on Zaporizhzhia — located near the town of Energodar — has resulted in at least one fire which was extinguished by local firefighters, according to Ukrainian and UN officials.

Just over a week earlier, Russian forces captured the Chornobyl nuclear power plant, a site responsible for a botched security test that sent clouds of nuclear smoke across much of Europe in 1986, now known as the worst nuclear disaster in history.

So why are Russian forces attacking Ukraine’s nuclear power plants?

These attacks are about the seizure of national infrastructure, according to Allen Sens, a professor in the department of political science at the University of British Columbia.

Story continues below advertisement

“It’s really difficult at this time to say why the plant came under fire but it’s pretty easy to say why the Russians were advancing on the plant and trying to seize it,” he said.

“Remember, a stated Russian objective is to conquer Ukraine and bring Ukraine back into the Russian orbit so there’s also some interest in maintaining some critical infrastructure.”

A graphic outlining where Ukraine’s nuclear power plants are located across the country. Global News

Although, “one of the stupidest things anybody could do is bring fire onto a nuclear power plant,” he said. If Russia were to control Ukraine’s nuclear reactors, they would also be controlling much of the country’s power, Sens added.

Last year, Ukraine got over 50 per cent of its electricity from nuclear reactors, according to M.V. Ramana, a professor at the University of British Columbia’s school of public policy and global affairs.

Story continues below advertisement

“Ukraine depends a lot on nuclear power,” he said.

Click to play video: 'Russia-Ukraine conflict: Partial ceasefire collapses as countries trade blame'
Russia-Ukraine conflict: Partial ceasefire collapses as countries trade blame

It would not be in the interest of Russia for a major accident to happen at a Ukrainian nuclear power plant as a substantial amount of radioactive fallout could go fall back into their country, according to Ramana.

“These assets have value themselves, rather than being something you’d want to destroy,” Sens said.

When it came to Chornobyl attack, Russians targeted this closed plant because of its relation to the capital of Ukraine, he added.

“They went through there because that was an important land corridor towards Kyiv,” Sens said.

Click to play video: 'No radiation detected after Russian troops take Europe’s largest nuclear power plant in Ukraine'
No radiation detected after Russian troops take Europe’s largest nuclear power plant in Ukraine

The dangers

Outside of the reactor at the Zaporizhzhia plant, and most other reactors worldwide, are spent fuel rods stored outside of the containment vessel, Sens explained.

Story continues below advertisement

These highly radioactive rods, consisting of enriched uranium, are used to power the reactor, he said.
After being used in the nuclear power process, these rods are not stored in a protective way — creating the potential for a “very dangerous” situation, he said.

“If ammunition was to fall intentionally or by accident and breach whatever building they happen to be stored in, and that radioactivity is released, it could lead — depending on the wind conditions that day — to a widespread contamination over a wide area,” he said, also noting the importance of a secure energy supply to the Zaporizhzhia plant to ensure safe operations.

There’s a lot that goes into making sure things run smoothly, Marina Freire-Gormaly, a professor in mechanical engineering at York University’s Lassonde School of Engineering, explained to Global News.

“You need all of the pumps working well, you need the heat exchangers to be operating as designed, you need all of the backup diesel generators in case the power isn’t working and then, you need all of this active cooling outside the reactor’s containment system to be operational,” she said.

A burnt car stands next to the remains of the local house of culture following a night air raid in the village of Byshiv, 40 kilometres west of Kyiv, Ukraine on March 4. Russia’s war on Ukraine is now in its ninth day and Russian forces have shelled Europe’s largest nuclear power plant, sparking a fire there that was extinguished overnight. Efrem Lukatsky/AP

It’s also important for the staff who are trained to operate the nuclear power plant to remain able to do so, Freire-Gormaly added.

Story continues below advertisement

“These staff have been trained for many years. They’ve gone through a series of very systematic training,” she said, noting in Canada, nuclear power plant staff who work in the operating room will have gone through four to six years of training.

Experts including Freire-Gormaly say it’s possible for other nuclear plants in Ukraine to be attacked by Russian forces.

“In a wartime situation, the aggressor usually wants to control the power and be able to create a lot of chaos by having blackouts to the community,” she said.

How to keep a nuclear power plant safe

Rafael Mariano Grossi, director general of the International Atomic Energy Agency, also known as the UN’s nuclear watchdog, has laid out a number of elements that must “never be compromised if one is to ensure safety and security at any nuclear facility.

Story continues below advertisement

The points include physical integrity, the maintenance of all safety and security systems, the ability for staff to fulfill duties, off-site power, availability to the supply chain, radiation monitoring systems and communication.

Rafael Grossi, Director General of the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA), points on a map of the Ukrainian Zaporizhzhia nuclear power plant as he informs the press about the situation of nuclear powerplants in Ukraine during a special press conference at the IAEA headquarters in Vienna, Austria on March 4, 2022. JOE KLAMAR/AFP via Getty Images

“No country disagrees that these principles must be maintained. However, the first of this, the physical integrity of the plant, has been compromised with what happened last night,” Grossi said during a press conference Friday while speaking on the attack of the Zaporizhzhia plant.

Grossi also offered to travel to Chornobyl in order to negotiate with Ukraine and Russia to try to ensure the security of Ukraine’s nuclear sites.

This has happened before

In 1981, Israeli forces attacked Iraq’s Osirak nuclear reactor. Ten Iraqi soldiers and one French engineer were killed during the airstrike, according to the George Washington University National Security Archive.

Story continues below advertisement

“It’s been done in the past and the fact that Israel was never censored for that is a bad precedent for this,” Ramana said.

History could also repeat itself if the Zaporizhzhia plant in Ukraine is forced to use their less reliable backup diesel generators should their off-site energy supply be cut. This is how a disaster at Japan’s Fukushima plant in 2011 took place, Ramana explained.

A massive earthquake and tsunami destroyed cooling systems, triggering meltdowns in three reactors during the incident.

What is Canada doing?

Canada’s nuclear regulator, the Canadian Nuclear Safety Commission, says they’ve been monitoring the events at Ukraine’s nuclear facilities.

Story continues below advertisement

“We are currently in a state of enhanced monitoring in keeping with our emergency plan,” the commission said in a statement on Friday. “It is important to note there is no immediate radiological threat to regions surrounding these facilities or to Canadians.”

A recent round of Canadian sanctions against Russia also targeted the countries energy sector.

On Wednesday, Global Affairs Canada said the federal government would be imposing restrictions on 10 key individuals from two important companies in Russia’s energy sector, Rosneft and Gazprom.

“These measures are intended to put further pressure on Russia’s leadership to cease its violations of Ukraine’s sovereignty and territorial integrity,” they said.

Sponsored content