Advertisement

Vancouver hotel owner found guilty of safety violations

WINNIPEG – The owner of a Winnipeg hotel that was recently busted for major fire and safety violations racked up more than $43,000 in fines last year for his Vancouver hotel that was so rundown one judge called it a "black hole."

The Howard Johnson hotel on Ellice Avenue shut down on Friday after management failed to bring 19 serious safety violations – including a broken fire alarm and sprinkler systems – up to code. City officials said inspectors have been at the hotel "on a regular basis" over the last year, in an attempt to prevent the situation from deteriorating further.

The hotel’s Vancouver-based owner, David Grewal, hasn’t commented publicly about why deficiencies were allowed to slide until the city decided it reached the point where it was no longer safe for people to be inside.

Documents from B.C. Provincial Court reveal that Grewal’s company, Picadilly Investments, has a long track record of flouting city fire and safety standards that extends back to 2004. The company was found guilty of 32 counts of violating basic building and fire codes at the Picadilly, a downtown hotel frequented by marginalized people. The city declared the hotel unsafe for human habitation and ordered closed in March, 2007.

In his 2008 decision, judicial justice Zahid Makhdoom said the nightmarish conditions were akin to the slum conditions of industrializing London. One hotel manager who gave up trying to get rid of rats "adopted resident rats as her pets," the decision noted.

"Picadilly remained a veritable Dickensian black hole even after comprehensive and repeated inspections, work orders, verbal and written warning and advises," Makhdoom wrote in his decision.

The B.C. judge slapped the company with a hefty fine in the hopes of deterring negligent conditions in future.

"The corporation had demonstrated very little, if at all any, commitment to bringing Picadilly up to the basic, minimum standards . . . as such its negligence must be denounced so that both the accused and those engaged in similar business are deterred from offending."

Grewal did not return calls from the Winnipeg Free Press on Monday.

There is no provincial regulatory body in Manitoba that approves or licenses hotels, so city inspectors rely on bylaws to enforce minimum building and fire safety codes.

Howard Johnson’s national franchise office declined to comment on whether they investigated Grewal’s corporate history before they agreed to let him operate under the Howard Johnson banner. It’s not known whether the Ellice Avenue hotel could be stripped of the franchise name when it reopens.

Nazir Kassam, the Howard Johnson’s restaurant’s current manager, said he’s aware of the problems Grewal’s company had in Vancouver and admits that "there’s definitely similarities in both places."

But Kassam said Grewal’s "hands-off" management style means he isn’t on site to inspect the property and relies on third-parties to keep the hotels running.

"It’s not so much that’s he’s a negligent person or careless," Kassam said, during a phone interview over the weekend. "As an owner he doesn’t come in and check every room here."

Manitoba Hotel Association CEO Jim Baker said Howard Johnson on Ellice Avenue wasn’t a member of the association, and that he’s heard several complaints about the hotel’s problems before. He said it wouldn’t be appropriate for a regulatory body to oversee hotel operations.

"It’s sort of buyer beware to a certain extent," Baker said. "There’s good (hotel) operators and bad operators."

Advertisement

Sponsored content

AdChoices