Advertisement

The ethics of vaccine rollout: Who should be in Alberta’s Phase 2?

Click to play video: 'The ethics of vaccine rollout: Who should be in Alberta’s Phase 2?'
The ethics of vaccine rollout: Who should be in Alberta’s Phase 2?
WATCH ABOVE: As Alberta moves through Phase 1 of COVID-19 vaccinations, Dr. Deena Hinshaw has said an “ethical framework” will be used to determine who qualifies for Phase 2 — which is expected to take place between April and September. Julia Wong has more on who experts say should be next in line to roll up their sleeves – Jan 15, 2021

As Alberta moves through Phase 1 of COVID-19 vaccinations, the chief medical officer of health has said an “ethical framework” will be used to determine who qualifies for Phase 2, which will include certain priority groups.

Vaccinations against the novel coronavirus started in December and have offered a glimmer of hope for Albertans during the pandemic. The priority, so far, has been to immunize the elderly in continuing care and staff working in intensive care units.

READ MORE: Vaccine advisory committee recommends new ranked roll-out, with long-term care at top

But that hasn’t stopped the speculation or the lobbying for certain groups to be included in Phase 2 of inoculations, which is expected to take place between April and September.

Experts say it will be important to look at a variety of factors, including equity, fairness and circumstances as decisions about who will get the shot are made in the largest mass vaccination program in modern history.

Story continues below advertisement
Click to play video: 'Alberta working with ethicists, advisory committee to determine who gets COVID-19 vaccine next'
Alberta working with ethicists, advisory committee to determine who gets COVID-19 vaccine next

On Dec. 28, Hinshaw said many Albertans can benefit from the vaccine but it is currently a scarce resource so different elements have to be taken into account to ensure the vaccine is being allocated in an ethical way.

The province is expected to release guidelines for Phase 2 in the coming weeks.

READ MORE: Online coronavirus vaccine tool estimates when Canadians will get their shots

Dr. Shannon MacDonald is an assistant professor in the Faculty of Nursing at the University of Alberta. She is also working with the National Advisory Committee on Immunization (NACI) doing public consultations over its vaccine guidelines.

Guidelines released by the NACI in November show that Phase 2 of vaccinations should include health-care workers not included in the initial rollout, residents and staff of other congregate settings, such as living quarters for migrant workers, correctional facilities and homeless shelters, as well as essential workers.

Story continues below advertisement
Click to play video: 'Inoculations begin for 600 elderly and vulnerable inmates'
Inoculations begin for 600 elderly and vulnerable inmates

MacDonald explained why people living in congregate settings should receive priority.

“Groups that don’t have the opportunity to protect themselves…[places] where you’ve introduced one case of COVID in there and it could explode,” she said. There have been outbreaks, in the past and currently, in homeless shelters and correctional facilities in Alberta.

READ MORE: Canada begins vaccinating inmates in federal prisons with no active coronavirus cases

Receive the latest medical news and health information delivered to you every Sunday.

Get weekly health news

Receive the latest medical news and health information delivered to you every Sunday.
By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy.

MacDonald said another important priority group may be people with chronic illnesses that put them at high risk of severe illness of death, particularly those who are essential workers and do not have the option to stay home.

She acknowledges that decisions around essential workers will be “tricky.”

“It’s driven both by science, when we have science availability, but it’s also driven by values,” she said.

Story continues below advertisement

“For instance, somebody might argue grocery store workers should be first because they’re the ones that are providing us our food. Other people would argue firefighters and police should really be first. Other people might argue teachers should be first so that we can keep our kids in school.

“It’s a balance between ‘use the science we have’ and we augment that with what we value as a society.”

MacDonald said when a decision is purely driven by scientific evidence, it is easier to defend than a decision being driven by values.

“It is more subjective and there needs to be some agreement on what are the values that a society like ours places on those decisions and on people,” she said.

Click to play video: 'What about teachers and front-line workers? Hinshaw addresses priority list for COVID-19 vaccination in Alberta'
What about teachers and front-line workers? Hinshaw addresses priority list for COVID-19 vaccination in Alberta

Colin Furness, an infection control epidemiologist at the University of Toronto, said the goal behind vaccinations can determine where vaccinations move to next.

Story continues below advertisement

“Do you want to get the economy going? If so, look at factory workers and other kinds of essential workers, and teachers actually to keep schools open.

“If you want to control transmission then maybe you need to actually do servers and other people who have a lot of contact with the public,” he said.

The definition of an essential worker, someone who cannot do their work from home, can be broad; Furness said they can range from personal support workers to transit drivers to factory workers.

“It’s going to be actually hard. You could probably line up dozens or hundreds of job descriptions and a bunch of experts and they wouldn’t necessarily agree about what pile to put people into,” he said.

Furness also said different workers can become essential in different season or different times of year.

“People who drive snow plows aren’t so important in the summer but come winter, obviously they become extremely important. We don’t need to worry as much about teachers in the summer but during the school year, obviously that changes. So you really also want to be thinking and be flexible and adaptable when the vaccine shows up – who is essential right now?”

Story continues below advertisement
Click to play video: 'Alberta continues to look at best way to allocate ‘scarce supply’ of COVID-19 vaccine'
Alberta continues to look at best way to allocate ‘scarce supply’ of COVID-19 vaccine

Blake Murdoch, a research associate with the Health Law Institute at the University of Alberta, said that when it comes to prioritizing essential workers, you have to look at minimizing societal disruption.

“You can make, I think, a strong argument some groups of traditionally underpaid, underappreciated people like grocery store workers might be deserving of getting the vaccine before some other groups,” he said.

Devidas Menon, a professor of health policy at the University of Alberta School of Public Health, said there will be ethical components in deciding who is considered a priority group.

“The other thing is equity. It’s not enough to look at just sickness, of ability to gain health, but the disadvantaged populations – the deaths and infections worldwide that happen in the lower socioeconomic class and people of colour in many places.”

Story continues below advertisement

Menon said fairness must also be considered, such as in the case of inmates.

“Some segments of society want to punish prisoners because they’ve done horrible things. On the other hand, they’re confined and they don’t have the luxury of being able – much like the homeless – to isolate themselves.

Priority setting exercises have been done before, Menon said, such as whether jurisdictions should pay for expensive drugs to treat a small number of patients.

Click to play video: 'Coronavirus: Manitoba’s top doctor explains why some at-risk groups won’t get first vaccines'
Coronavirus: Manitoba’s top doctor explains why some at-risk groups won’t get first vaccines

He said these types of decisions are very challenging to make and it is critical for the decision-making process to be transparent.

Story continues below advertisement

“They won’t be easy but at least if it’s clear what was done and if it’s defensible – because there’s some general agreement – there will never be unanimity,” Menon said.

“People don’t always agree with decisions that organizations and government make but if they had an idea of procedural justice along the way the decision was made and how it was reached, people are more willing to accept that.”

Sponsored content

AdChoices