With the collapse of Trumpcare, Republicans are taking their time on tax reform

Trump turns to tax reform after healthcare bill debacle
After Donald Trump was unable to get his health care bill through the U.S. House of Representatives, lawmakers are now calling for bipartisanship. The president, meanwhile, wants to turn his focus to tax reform—but that may not prove so simple. Ines de La Cuetara reports.

Raw feelings and mistrust could pose an obstacle to President Donald Trump and hard-line conservative lawmakers in his Republican Party as they seek to rebound from defeat on health care legislation by launching into an overhaul of the U.S. tax code.

Trump has accused the Freedom Caucus lawmakers of snatching a “defeat from the jaws of victory” with their rejection of the White House-backed health care bill to replace President Barack Obama’s 2010 health care reform bill.

In interviews with 10 of the roughly three dozen House Freedom Caucus members, the lawmakers said they were eager to put aside tensions over the health care debacle and seek common ground on tax reform.

But there is no consensus, even within the conservative faction, on details of a tax-reform bill, with some members open to discussing ideas such as the border tax plan supported by House leaders and others opposed to it.

Story continues below advertisement

Representative Warren Davidson, a Freedom Caucus member from Ohio, said Republicans should leave aside the blame game and work through their policy differences before launching tax reform legislation.

“Some people are still in that hurt-feelings and frustration” stage, Davidson said. “I do think it’s smart to take the time to get it right.”

READ MORE: Donald Trump’s ‘big, big’ corporate tax cut could ‘erase Canada’s advantage’

Republican Representative David Schweikert of Arizona, a Freedom Caucus lawmaker who sits on the tax-writing House of Representative Ways and Means Committee, could emerge as a bridge between the conservative faction and House leaders. The panel will work closely with House leadership on the tax bill.

Schweikert said he planned to consult with rank-and-file members to discuss plans and listen to their priorities.

He said giving companies incentives to invest in plants and equipment was one of the items on his own wish list.

“My personal fixation is very simple: What maximizes economic growth?” Schweikert said.

Cuts, cuts and more cuts

Representative Mark Meadows, chairman of the Freedom Caucus, said the group has “no formal position” on the structure of tax reform legislation.

Story continues below advertisement

But Meadows listed the top priorities on his own wish list: “Lower taxes, lower taxes and lower taxes.”

A 35-page blueprint developed by House Republican leaders, known as a “Better Way,” will serve as a starting point for the tax-reform discussions.

READ MORE: Trump’s tax bill: Here’s how much he’d pay in Canada

The plan calls for streamlining the income tax system and cutting the corporate income tax rate to 20 per cent from 35 per cent. It would exclude export revenue from taxable income and impose a 20 per cent tax on imports.

The border tax proposal has divided the business community and is a top flashpoint for lawmakers. Big exporters such as General Electric Co say the tax would boost manufacturing and jobs. But retailers like Target Corp have said the border tax would hike consumer prices and hurt the economy.

Trump, a businessman who had never been in public office until he took over at the White House on Jan. 20, has at times praised the border tax idea but at other times has been noncommittal.

President Donald Trump listens in the Cabinet Room of the White House in Washington, Wednesday, March 29, 2017.
President Donald Trump listens in the Cabinet Room of the White House in Washington, Wednesday, March 29, 2017. AP Photo/Evan Vucci

Virginia Congressman Dave Brat said he would insist that the tax bill not add to the deficit, while Meadows said he would not necessarily insist on that.

Story continues below advertisement

Other conservatives said they needed more information about the tax bill to form an opinion – and some space from the contentious health care debate.

“We just had a major battle on a Republican welfare plan and that has consumed to a large degree my time and mental effort,” said Alabama Representative Mo Brooks.

“When we have a tax reform bill I can evaluate, that’s when I’ll start voting on it,” Brooks said.

Tweet This

As a sign of tensions that have lingered after the collapse of the health care bill, Freedom Caucus lawmakers faced tough questioning from their colleagues during a closed-door meeting of House Republicans on Tuesday, said Representative Randy Weber of Texas.

But Weber said some of the friction eased by the end of the meeting, prompting House Speaker Paul Ryan to say that more give and take might have been useful in the health care effort.

“Ryan said: ‘This is what we should have been doing,'” Weber told Reuters.

READ MORE: Why Trump’s health care defeat could jeopardize his tax reform agenda

Republican Representative Ken Buck of Colorado, a member of the Freedom Caucus, said he thinks lawmakers learned lessons from the health care defeat that could apply to tax reform.

Story continues below advertisement

“I think people are going to work harder to get to ‘yes’ this next piece of legislation,” Buck said.

A Reuters/Ipsos opinion poll released on Wednesday showed Republicans mostly blame Congress, and not Trump or party leaders, for failing to pass the health care overhaul.