Two high-school buddies jailed in the U.S. for life for killing the parents and sister of one of them exactly 17 years ago will get their chance today to try to win a new trial.
Sebastian Burns and Atif Rafay, now both 35, were 18 years old in 1994 when they travelled to the Rafays’ Bellevue, Wash., home and bludgeoned to death Rafay’s parents, Tariq and Sultana, and his 20-year-old autistic sister, Basma, leaving behind a bloodied, gruesome scene.
The following year, they were arrested in Canada and, after a lengthy extradition process, were sent to the U.S., to stand trial.
After a six-month trial in 2004, they were found guilty of three counts of aggravated first-degree murder and were each sentenced to three consecutive life terms without chance of parole.
They both remain behind bars. Rafay is at Washington State Reformatory near Everett, where he teaches high school to inmates and writes scholarly papers.
Burns is jailed with violent long-term offenders at Washington State Penitentiary in Walla Walla. Prison records document a life in constant crisis, including assault by inmates and the force-feeding of food and anti-psychotic medications because of mental-health problems.
The pair have always said they didn’t murder the Rafays, maintaining they were forced to confess under threat of harm or death in a controversial “Mr. Big” sting operation led by the RCMP.
Burns’ family, who live in West Vancouver, have been fighting their case ever since. His sister, Tiffany Burns, a former model and CBC TV anchor in Edmonton, produced a critically acclaimed documentary about the Mr. Big tactic.
Now, seven years after their conviction, the pair, who met in high school in West Vancouver before Rafay’s family moved to Bellevue, will get a chance Friday to ask the Washington State Court of Appeals to order another trial.
Their lawyers are expected to argue the pair didn’t receive a fair trial because the defence wasn’t allowed to offer evidence pointing to other killers, they were forced to falsely confess in the Mr. Big tactic that’s illegal in the U.S., there was no DNA evidence linking them to the crime, and their alibis didn’t allow time for them to commit the murders, said Greg Hampikian, a forensic biology professor at Boise State University and the director of the Idaho Innocence Project, which advocates for the wrongly convicted.
Hampikian said the Innocence Network, of which his group is part, prepared a brief filed with the court to assist the defence, which argues the trial judge disallowed expert testimony that would have helped the jury understand why people sometimes make false confessions.
“This shouldn’t have been built up into a case because of the gut feeling of the police officers,” said Hampikian.
“There is certainly reasonable doubt.”
Rubin “Hurricane” Carter, an advocate for the wrongly convicted through a group called Innocence International and himself wrongly convicted of a triple murder years ago, has posted a long argument calling for Burns and Rafay to be freed for many of the same reasons.
“We also believe that they are innnocent or else we would not represent them,” Carter wrote online.
Hampikian said the court is expected to return a decision in six to eight weeks.
Comments
Want to discuss? Please read our Commenting Policy first.