Advertisement

Burger King faces new ‘test’ in quest for Tim Hortons

New rules on takeover deals like the one Burger King is attempting at Tim Hortons face fresh scrutiny from U.S. officials. Getty Images

The U.S federal government said Tuesday it’s cracking down on companies like Burger King who attempt to relocate to Canada or overseas to avoid paying U.S. taxes.

In a so-called “tax inversion,” a U.S. business merges with a foreign company in a country with a lower tax rate – in Burger King’s case, it plans to combine with Tim Hortons.

But new rules announced Tuesday in the United States will “test” the controversial takeover, experts said.

The merits “of the Burger King [takeover] of Tim Hortons will be tested by the enactment of tightened U.S. Treasury tax rules on U.S. companies looking to [relocate] their headquarters in countries with more favourable tax systems,” Fitch, a global credit rating agency, said.
Story continues below advertisement

Analysts suggest it could be Burger King’s high-profile takeover of Oakville, Ont.-based Tim Hortons that spurred the crackdown.

The U.S. Treasury Department says it’s putting forward regulations that will make inversions less lucrative by barring some techniques companies use to defer their taxes.

Financial news and insights delivered to your email every Saturday.

It’s also making it harder for companies to pursue an inversion by tightening the requirement that the company’s former owners own less than 80 per cent of the new company.

U.S. Treasury Secretary Jacob Lew says the steps will ensure that it’s no longer financially beneficial for companies to use that tactic.

The new measures will take effect immediately.

Burger King and Tim Hortons have already filed their takeover plans to regulators, but the new rules will still apply to the pending deal, which is expected to become official before the end of the year.

MORE: Should Tim Hortons brace for job cuts?

Tims officials indicated in a media report that Burger King is proceeding with its takeover plans.

Experts meanwhile suggest the deal will skirt around the new framework.

“We believe new rules won’t likely deter the Burger King/Tim Hortons transaction,” Fitch said.

Story continues below advertisement

Tax benefits ‘nonetheless’

Burger King has said the tax inversion structure wasn’t the main rationale for approaching Tim Hortons about a merger – growth is. The merger will create the third biggest “quick serve” or fast food company in the world.

MORE: With Burger King’s help, Tim Hortons poised to go global

But experts suggest the new firm will benefit from more favourable tax rates in Canada, where the federal corporate rate is 15 per cent compared to 35 per cent in the United States.

Burger King says its blended tax rates is in the mid- to high-20 per cent range, a rate comparable to what companies based in Ontario pay, and where the new Burger King/Tim Hortons parent will be based.

“Nonetheless, future potential tax benefits provided by the proposed [deal] should not be overlooked,” Fitch said.

Critics, including President Barack Obama, have blasted the growing number of U.S. companies seeking inversions as “corporate deserters”, shifting their burden onto individual American taxpayers to boost shareholder returns.

WATCH: Canadian coffee giant Tim Hortons has been acquired by Burger King and Canadians are worried. McGill University’s Prof. Karl Moore explains what can change about your coffee experience.

With files from Associated Press

Advertisement

Sponsored content

AdChoices