Canadian Pacific Railway refuses to pay for Lac-Megantic cleanup

Raw video of cleanup at Lac-Megantic (July 16)

MONTREAL – Canadian Pacific says it holds no financial responsibility for the Lac-Megantic rail disaster and has rejected a legal demand by the Quebec government that it help pay for the cleanup in the devastated town.

The railway announced Thursday that it will appeal the province’s legal order.

The news came one day after the provincial government added CPR to a list of defendants that it says are responsible for picking up the tab for the massive mop-up in Lac-Megantic, where a train derailed on July 6 and dumped millions of litres of crude oil into the environment.

“Canadian Pacific has reviewed the notice. As a matter of fact, and law, CP is not responsible for this cleanup,” railway spokesman Ed Greenberg said Thursday.

Story continues below advertisement

“CP will be appealing.”

That legal notice demands that the companies follow a provincial law that holds businesses accountable for the financial impact of an environmental disaster.

Read more: Quebec government targets CP Railway for money to cleanup

That legal notice demands that the companies named follow a provincial law that holds businesses accountable for the financial impact of an environmental disaster.

The Quebec government argues that taxpayers should not be forced to pay for the cleanup. However, attempts so far to ascibe financial liability have produced a flurry of finger-pointing between various public and private interests.

Environment Minister Yves-Francois Blanchet, who signed the order, responded quickly Thursday to CPR’s position.

“I will leave it up to lawyers, but let’s be clear: under the law on environmental quality, the minister does not ask for, or suggest, compensation … he orders it,” Blanchet said in a statement.

“It’s not optional.”

Read more: Study shows high pollution at Lac-Megantic

The disaster killed 47 people and led to a mass evacuation in the community of 6,000. The derailment has since prompted a criminal investigation, several lawsuits, and concerns that locals may have to abandon Lac-Megantic’s oil-soaked downtown core.

Story continues below advertisement

In the legal notice, the province said CPR was the main contractor responsible for the fateful shipment that was supposed to transport crude from North Dakota oil fields to New Brunswick’s Irving refinery.

It handed off the train in Montreal to the smaller Montreal, Maine & Atlantic Railway Ltd., which then operated the tanker train that derailed in the heart of Lac-Megantic and set off a series of explosions.

MMA is already among the other companies on the legal notice, but the U.S.-based railway has said it can’t afford to pay and has requested bankruptcy protection.

In one court filing, MMA said its insurance coverage was $25 million and estimated the total cleanup cost would exceed $200 million.

Earlier this week, the federal railway regulator announced it would suspend MMA’s Canadian operating licence because it said the company did not have sufficent insurance coverage.

On Wednesday, the Quebec government also added World Fuel Services Inc. to the legal notice. It’s a subsidiary of the petroleum-logistics firm World Fuel Services Corp., which was listed along with another of its branches, Western Petroleum Company, in the initial demand from the government.

World Fuel Services, which stated last month that it had “serious objections to the legality of the order,” had bought the crude that was to be shipped to the refinery in St. John, N.B.

Story continues below advertisement

The Miami-based company declined to comment Thursday about the updated notice, but in an interview last month with The Canadian Press, its spokesman shifted some of the responsibility to CPR.

“World Fuel Services has absolutely no contractual relationship with MMA,” Brian Kennedy said.

“(The company) did business with Canadian Pacific for the transport of the merchandise from North Dakota to New Brunswick … (CPR) were the ones who then offered to subcontract it to MMA.”

For our ongoing coverage of the explosion in Lac-Megantic, click here

Sponsored content