Advertisement

‘Please don’t paint my riding as racist,’ Nova Scotia MP says amid Mi’kmaq lobster debate

Click to play video '‘Please don’t paint my riding as racist’: West Nova MP makes powerful plea amid fisheries dispute' ‘Please don’t paint my riding as racist’: West Nova MP makes powerful plea amid fisheries dispute
The Member of Parliament (MP) for West Nova Chris D’Entremont made a powerful plea during an emergency debate of the House of Commons Monday evening, telling Canadians “please don’t paint my riding as racist.” D’Entremont said the majority of people in the riding, where tensions have escalated over Mi'kmaq “moderate livelihood” lobster fisheries, are “scared” and “worried about what’s happening in their communities.” – Oct 19, 2020

The Member of Parliament for a Nova Scotia riding where tensions over Indigenous lobster fishing have turned violent insisted Monday evening that the majority of his constituents are not racist.

During an hours-long debate in the House of Commons that sought to find solutions to the conflict between Mi’kmaq lobster fishers and non-Indigenous commercial fishers, West Nova MP Chris D’Entremont said he was frustrated it took escalating violence to get his colleagues to pay attention to the issue.

“This has been happening for weeks. This has been happening for months,” he said.

“Finally, people seem interested in what’s happening in West Nova. Where the heck — excuse me — where were you? Where were the other MPs?”

Read more: ‘We need a clear plan’: MPs clash during emergency debate on Mi’kmaw lobster fisheries

Story continues below advertisement

The emergency debate was requested by Fisheries Minister Bernadette Jordan and NDP MP Gord Johns, after a massive fire burned down a lobster pound used by the Mi’kmaq early Saturday morning.

Earlier on Monday, members of the Liberal cabinet condemned the violence as “disgusting” and “racist,” warning the Mi’kmaq have a constitutionally protected treaty right to fish for what the Supreme Court in its 1999 Marshall decision described as a “moderate livelihood.”

During the evening debate, D’Entremont pushed back on widespread assertions of racism, saying the actions of a few do not represent all of his constituents.

“Please don’t paint my area as racist,” he said. “There’s probably a few, as in many of our ridings. Systemic racism is true in Canada, but my area is not by default racist.”

Click to play video 'Trudeau says Ottawa ‘strongly condemns’ violence toward Mi’kmaq amid Nova Scotia fisheries dispute' Trudeau says Ottawa ‘strongly condemns’ violence toward Mi’kmaq amid Nova Scotia fisheries dispute
Trudeau says Ottawa ‘strongly condemns’ violence toward Mi’kmaq amid Nova Scotia fisheries dispute – Oct 19, 2020

NDP Leader Jagmeet Singh said during the debate that there is “no question” that the Mi’kmaq fishing operation poses no threat to lobster conservation.

Story continues below advertisement

“Any suggestion that this is about conservation is wrong (and) is clearly an example of systemic racism,” he said.

At issue in the recent conflict is how the Mi’kmaq treaty right is applied outside the commercial lobster fishing season.

Read more: Mobs are attacking Indigenous fisheries in Nova Scotia. Here’s what’s going on

Non-Indigenous lobster fishers have destroyed traps and catch, and threatened Mi’kmaq lobster fishers with violent mobs in recent weeks, culminating in Saturday’s fire.

Mi’kmaq lobster fishers have said they are exercising their right to fish for themselves and also to sell their catch, even though the commercial lobster season is currently closed.

Liberal MP for Cape Breton Jaime Battiste, the only Mi’kmaq politician sitting in Parliament, expressed optimism during the debate that lawmakers could reach a solution.

Click to play video 'First Mi’kmaw MP elected to House of Commons says community has shown ‘commitment’ to Canada' First Mi’kmaw MP elected to House of Commons says community has shown ‘commitment’ to Canada
First Mi’kmaw MP elected to House of Commons says community has shown ‘commitment’ to Canada – Oct 19, 2020

But he reminded his colleagues that the treaty right established by the Marshall decision was retroactive, and that Canada has an obligation to honour it.

Story continues below advertisement

“The fact is today, the Mi’kmaq are asking for a right that they’ve always had,” he said. “It wasn’t created in 1999. In ’99, the court said that the right existed the whole time.

“The fact that the Mi’kmaq aren’t looking for reparations or revenge — rather, they’re looking for reconciliation — shows our commitment to this country and our allies.”

Read more: As Ottawa commits to protect treaty rights, Sipekne’katik chief says ‘actions speak louder than words’

Chief Michael Sack of the Sipekne’katik First Nation, which launched the Mi’kmaq lobster fishery in September, said on Monday that he welcomed the words from federal ministers but that more was necessary to ensure their treaty rights are being protected.

“Actions speak louder than words,” he said.

“You can’t say sorry for something that already went down, you know what I mean? We could’ve lost people in that situation and ‘sorry’ doesn’t save lives,” Sack said.

Click to play video '‘Actions speak louder than words’: Sipekne’katik chief urges further action by Ottawa, RCMP in fisheries dispute' ‘Actions speak louder than words’: Sipekne’katik chief urges further action by Ottawa, RCMP in fisheries dispute
‘Actions speak louder than words’: Sipekne’katik chief urges further action by Ottawa, RCMP in fisheries dispute – Oct 19, 2020

Sack also said he believes the concern raised by commercial fishermen over conservation is over.

Story continues below advertisement

“(Jordan) said that the lobster stocks are strong. So, you know, that puts the conservation issue to rest,” he said.

Trudeau issued a statement on Monday saying he had spoken about the violence with Nova Scotia Premier Stephen McNeil.

One man described as a person of interest in the blaze at the lobster compound is in hospital with life-threatening injuries.

The Mounties have made two arrests in relation to other incidents linked to the dispute, charging one man with assault against a local Indigenous chief and charging another with arson in connection with a burned vehicle.

—With files from Global News’ Amanda Connolly, Hannah Jackson and Alexander Quon