Advertisement

Defence may seek mistrial in alleged nurses’ assault case in Moncton

Click to play video: 'Trial of man accused of assaulting two nurses in Moncton came to a halt'
Trial of man accused of assaulting two nurses in Moncton came to a halt
WATCH: The trial of a man accused of assault came to an abrupt half on Thursday morning when the defence suggested they’ll likely seek a mistrial. Callum Smith has more – Feb 27, 2020

Just as the trial of a New Brunswick man accused of assaulting two nurses at a hospital in Moncton was expected to continue Thursday, it came to an abrupt halt after the defence lawyer suggested he could be seeking a mistrial.

Bruce Randolph (Randy) Van Horlick, 70, of Acadieville, has entered not guilty pleas to two counts of assault causing bodily harm, both of which are alleged to have occurred on March 11, 2019 at the Dr. Georges-L.-Dumont University Hospital Centre.

More than three weeks after the trial started, the case was expected to continue in Moncton provincial court Thursday.

READ MORE: N.B. Medical Society says hospital violence ‘getting worse’

Crown prosecutor Marie-Andrée Mallet started the hearing by calling the family doctor for Natasha Poirier, one of the two complainants, to the witness stand.

Story continues below advertisement

But before Dr. Manon LeRoux’s testimony, Mallet put on the record that the presiding judge, Yvette Finn, had previously represented LeRoux about 25 years ago during her time as a lawyer pertaining to a “marriage contract.”

After the court took a break for Mallet and Nathan Gorham, Van Horlick’s lawyer, to discuss the issue, Gorham came back to court and said “I think what I’m going to ask for is a mistrial.”

Get the day's top news, political, economic, and current affairs headlines, delivered to your inbox once a day.

Get daily National news

Get the day's top news, political, economic, and current affairs headlines, delivered to your inbox once a day.
By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy.

Gorham explained that after just learning of that relationship, he had concerns over a potential judgment or ruling on the credibility and reliability of the witness (LeRoux).

“Crown counsel is going to attempt to prove through this witness that the alleged victim actually suffered a concussion,” Gorham told the court. “Then she’s going to say the concussion establishes bodily harm.”

Van Horlick’s defence lawyer, Nathan Gorham (right), leaves the Moncton courthouse Thursday morning after suggesting he may seek a mistrial in the case. Callum Smith / Global News

He said solicitor-client privileged prevented him from further inquiring about the relationship between the judge and the witness, but based on what he knew, he raised concerns.

Story continues below advertisement

“I’m not impugning your honour’s integrity or impartiality,” Gorham said. “But the problem here is… This witness is your former client and you have duties that survive the end of the lawyer-client relationship that continues in perpetuity.”

READ MORE: No jail time for man who attacked Abbotsford ER nurse in 2015

After lengthy discussion between the Crown, defence lawyer, and the judge, the case was eventually set over to March 13 for a status hearing, which will give time for Gorham to clearly present his argument.

“I want to make sure that the issues are very clear,” Finn told the court. “We will reconvene; you both [lawyers] will have had a chance to review the discussion that we’ve just had on tape and think about it.”
Dr. Manon LeRoux (right) was expected to take the witness stand until the defence lawyer in the case raised concerns that the judge had previously represented LeRoux about 25 years ago as a lawyer. Callum Smith / Global News

Gorham declined to comment on the case outside of court.

Story continues below advertisement

Although the defence has yet to formally present its case, Gorham suggested Van Horlick blacked out during the alleged attack during day one of the trial, which took place Feb. 3.

Sponsored content

AdChoices