Experts say don’t treat home equity credit lines as a personal bank machine

TORONTO – Home equity loans have become a fast-growing source of cheap borrowing for Canadians – so alluring that some have treated their homes as a personal bank machine and put off thinking about the debt that must be repaid.

Many Canadians have turned to their homes as a source of cash for everything from renovations or vacation to debt consolidation or RRSP investments, which they can achieve at a much lower interest rate than credit cards or unsecured loans because their home is used as collateral.

But with mortgage rates expected to rise and home prices to fall, now is the time for those who have piled on debt while decreasing their home ownership stakes to start building up equity.

Home equity lines of credit, known in the industry as HELOCs, are the fastest growing source of credit in Canada. The Bank of Canada estimates that the dollar amount of HELOCs has risen by as much as 170 per cent in the past decade or almost twice as fast as mortgage debt.

Story continues below advertisement

However, many Canadians are unaware of the implications of this cheap borrowing. Nearly 60 per cent of respondents in a recent poll for TitlePlus insurance did not know that taking out a HELOC amounts to a mortgage or a second mortgage (if they already have one).

The trend has left Canadians with an average 34 per cent of equity in their home, the lowest level in two decades and a 20 per cent drop in four years.

The Bank of Canada has recently pointed out that much of the increase in household debt to a record 153 per cent of income is not due to mortgages, but rather loans secured by home equity which Canadians in turn spent on consumer items and renovating their homes.

“We’ve seen it as a growing problem, first with debt consolidation and now more often with renovations and things like that,” said Patricia White, executive director of Credit Counselling Canada.

White said she’s talked to clients who have taken on a HELOC to consolidate debt, then find themselves in debt again and no longer have any room to manoeuvre because they can’t use their small remaining stake in their homes as leverage.

Home equity lines of credit allow you to access up to 80 per cent of the appraised or purchase price of your home (whichever is lower) less any outstanding mortgage or other charges. The more equity you have in your home, the more credit becomes available – but the more you use, the less equity you have in your home.

Story continues below advertisement

They’re usually calculated based on the prime rate and you can get a secured line of credit for as little as half a point above that rate. Your interest rates will change if the prime rate does – and sometimes even if it doesn’t as lenders can raise the interest rates they charge on top of prime arbitrarily.

The plans are extremely flexible and allow you to pay as little each month as interest only, or as much as you want. The problem is some homeowners choose to pay just the minimum, which only covers interest – leaving a huge mortgage on their homes.

Cheap borrowing rates introduced since the recent recession have helped Canadians to get deeper into debt, said Lior Hershkovitch, a mortgage agent in the Toronto area.

The most recent downturn marked the first time Canadians came out of a recession with more debt than they had going in, he noted.

“But it would be very wise for them to take advantage of (low interest rates) and pay it down as much as they can while rates are low.”

Those who find themselves in debt with declining equity in their homes need to put the brakes on drawing from their HELOC, even if there is still room on it.

Don’t borrow over half your limit unless for an emergency. And if you use your HELOC for discretionary spending, don’t fall into the trap of interest only payments, said Rob McLister, editor of the Canadian Mortgage Trends blog.

Story continues below advertisement

“If your balance is large, pay at least four to five per cent of your balance each month. If you can’t afford four per cent payments, don’t borrow further until you can,” he advises.

Start by calculating how much you can realistically increase the amount you pay every month. If that extra amount would be difficult to reach while still making ends meet, it’s a sign you’re overextended and may need to seek a professional to help create a plan.

It’s important to take such steps now because the share of household income going toward paying off debt will increase when borrowing costs return to more normal levels as economic conditions improve.

One option is to ask your financial institution abut a fixed rate option that would protect you from interest rate increases and establish regular fixed payments to help plan your budget.

The point is to start reducing the principal payment and not just make the minimum interest payment because that will catch up to you and it’s not ideal to be carrying a big debt burden into retirement.

Finally, a HELOC can keep you trapped in your home because if you’re looking to sell, your HELOC must be paid off.