Prime Minister Mark Carney said Tuesday that Stellantis’ agreement to sell its Brampton auto assembly plant is a “betrayal” to Canadians.
Stellantis, the parent company of Jeep and other automotive brands, announced on Monday a deal to sell its Brampton vehicle assembly plant to Canadian defence and armoured vehicle manufacturer Roshel.
The financial terms of that agreement have not been made public, and although there have been questions about whether some Stellantis workers may be grandfathered into Roshel’s operations, no specifics have been provided.
That deal came as contract talks between Stellantis and the union representing more than 9,000 of its workers in Canada remain at an impasse.
“But to be more fundamental, it’s a betrayal of the workers, as it is a betrayal of the obligations to Canada and, by extension, to all Canadians. We will fully enforce our rights in protection of those workers and protection of Canadian funds.”
Get daily National news
Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre said earlier on Tuesday that Prime Minister Mark Carney should “fire” his industry minister, Mélanie Joly, after a Stellantis agreement to sell its Brampton plant threatened thousands of job losses.
“This Liberal industry minister, just like Champagne before her and the entire Liberal government, is costing Canadians money and jobs and driving our economy into the ditch,” said Poilievre Tuesday in Brampton.
“She’s been threatening lawsuits for years. She’s done nothing. That is why today the official opposition is calling for the Liberal prime minister to fire his failed, costly job-killing Liberal industry minister.”
Carney was asked about Poilievre’s earlier comments regarding Joly.
“The issue is not the work, the exceptional work of the minister of industry, Madame Joly and her colleagues, it is the behaviour of the company versus of those workers,” Carney said in response.
“There’ll be a meeting of all stakeholders on Thursday on ways to move forward. But make no mistake, we will enforce our rights, absolutely, in protection of those workers.“
- Canada to review where Chinese EVs are allowed to drive: transport minister
- Talks with Meta ‘confidential’ following reports of possible deal, Miller says
- Ex-Alberta premier Jason Kenney says Quebec Conservatives could take power
- Alaska Democrat Mary Peltola wins U.S Senate race, defeating Dan Sullivan
Stellantis confirmed to Global News, in a response to a request for comment, that they will be attending the meeting on Thursday Carney referenced.
“We recognize that Canadians expect accountability for public funding and that is why Stellantis has offered to voluntarily return the government support received for Brampton Assembly’s original retooling plan,” a spokesperson for Stellantis said in a statement.
“Confidentiality provisions in our agreements prevent us from disclosing further details.”
In 2023, Stellantis received a $15 billion joint commitment between the federal and Ontario provincial government over 10 years as a performance incentive to revive an electric vehicle battery facility in Windsor and prevent it from being moved to the U.S. That agreement also required Stellantis to maintain its footprint in the province through 2035, which includes the Brampton plant.
Unifor has previously written to Joly urging the government to block the potential sale and clarify whether Stellantis’ intentions to offload the plant breached its commitments to Ottawa.
The Brampton facility had been slated to be retooled for Jeep production, a process that began early in 2024, before the company paused the plan in early 2025. It later announced it was moving production of the Jeep Compass to Illinois, leaving the plant idled indefinitely.
“They are the hub of activity that is unmatchable by any single investment by any defence contractor. It’s a plant that is at the center of an ecosystem that has dozens of other parts suppliers and raw material suppliers, tooling suppliers,” says Flavio Volpe, president of the Automotive Parts Manufacturers’ Association.
“If this plant leaves, if it crumbles, that business ecosystem around it crumbles.”
In October 2025, Joly launched a dispute process and claimed Stellantis breached the terms of its agreement by moving the plant’s production out of the province and to the U.S.
– with files from Global’s Sergio Vargas, Alessia Simona Maratta & Karen Bartko
Voting for Carney and the liberals in general is a betrayal to Canada as a nation.
The idea that Roshel is going to grandfather in employees from a previous company is a fantasy, much like “Build Canada Strong” while partnering with countries like China.
I do have to wonder why the terms of the contract between the federal government and Stellantis have not been made public. Surely the wise and competent Melanie Joly did her job and ensured Canadian tax payer money was well invested……
So why did Carney “approve” the agreement. Total idiot.
Yet Clowney knew and approved the deal with Roshel months ago. Performative politics by Clowney and nothing more.
@Anonymous. Carney ran in one of the safest seats for Liberals in Ontario.
Carney has shown he can’t deliver positive outcomes to Canadians. Then Elbows Up Canadians criticize Trump, PP, Opposition, Harper for lack of results because of their total incompetence.
Nobody cares what PP has to say. He lost his own seat in the last election and had to go running to a safe seat elsewhere. He is such a joke.
I’m not a fanboy of Carney by any means, but many other world leaders are exasperated by Trumps erratic trade policies…
The main problem Carney has dealing with Trump is that the American president is in end stage frontal lobe dementia…some qualified doctors believe the president may only have 2 to 4 months left…
Check out that video of Trump holding a meeting with a hundred oil executives at the White House, where he just wanders off to the window and starts talking about the ballroom and totally loses focus on why all these people are gathered there…
JD Vance is supposed to be even more hard line than Trump but he is younger and mentally fit and would probably be easier for our Prime Minister to make deals with…
Hilarious. He knew about it months ago. Another lie
@Rich. You have a short memory. PP talked about eliminating the consumer carbon tax 3 years before the Liberals finally did it. It is also up the Carney to work with the other parties collaboratively, which he doesn’t.
We know Rich will support Carney blindly on anything, even a misstep. Then will denounce the Opposition for bringing it to Canadians attention. I have never heard Rich once criticize the Liberals on anything.
Regarding the comments about the government meeting with all three parties.
Firstly, engagement was not approval. Government was trying to negotiate a deal.
Secondly, being at the table was essential to try to protect Canada’s interests. The government was at the table to enforce Canada’s rights and to re-iterate the obligations of Stellantis.
Finally, why aren’t the commenters holding Stellantis accountable? They are the ones who haven’t met THEIR obligations. Holding the wronged party (Canada) accountable is strange.
Our collective voices should speak up for Canada and not infight using right wing media gossip which just strengthens the hand of Stellantis.
Carney has betrayed Canadians by not keeping his promises during the 2025 election.
I make poop on plate.Form into Liberal Party “L”.Put candle in ,wish myself happy birthday then eat
CBC what is your take on this story.
OTTAWA – The federal government was actively and intensively part of discussions that ended in the agreement to sell a Stellantis car assembly plant to Canadian armoured vehicle manufacturer Roshel, according to three sources with direct knowledge of the talks.
The sources said the federal government also did not stand in the way of the deal in those private discussions.
All of my views and opinions are formed by absorbing years of Liberal Government Propaganda and messaging. I am literally a walking sponge for the stuff. A lot of the comments here criticizing Carney’s failures are accurate, but by the act of agreeing with them, I would have to admit to the fact that I am an absolute brainwashed stooge,so instead I will just keep my head in the sands of disillusion.
Just like YouTube is filled with AI slop so are comments. So easy to have AI agents read comments and interact with them.
I have small appendage, like Gherkin.I have fun.
Put in Jagmeets bum then Trudeau mouth.Trudeau say yum yum
Carney knew all about this. He is such a liar!
“This Liberal industry minister, just like Champagne before her and the entire Liberal government, is costing Canadians money and jobs and driving our economy into the ditch,” said Poilievre Tuesday in Brampton.”
Truer words have never been spoken about this dysfunctional Liberal Government.
Thanks Pierre, you are a true Canadian!!!!
So yet again we werelied to because a number of credible sources now say that the Carney government knew of and was part of the negotiations for the sale. When are elbozo Canadians going to wake up and see that Carney is just a con man who is gaslighting them over and over and over again.
Joly has to go. She no longer has any credibility left as a minister. She is nothing more than a paper tiger.
Of PM Elbozo had a legal leg to stand on he would sue instead of spouting powerless admonitions
But he doesn’t
Because the LPC cannot do anything right
Next is Stelco
More moaning and woe is me and powerless cries of “ unfair “
If only the LPC did their homework and their job but hubris and entitlement is all they got
Frank. The Opposition isn’t just there to mindlessly oppose everything. They should be suggesting alternatives. Working with government where appropriate. All of which is part of the overall job of holding government to account.
That’s not what we’ve got with the CPC. Poilievre spends all his time complaining without proposing. Not surprising since that was his role when he was Harper’s attack job and he’s carried it on. Also not surprising. Poilievre can’t control his own caucus, which makes it hard to run an effective opposition. You may believe that Poilievre has advanced proposals for policy alternatives, but I don’t see it.
OTTAWA – The federal government was actively and intensively part of discussions that ended in the agreement to sell a Stellantis car assembly plant to Canadian armoured vehicle manufacturer Roshel, according to three sources with direct knowledge of the talks.
The sources said the federal government also did not stand in the way of the deal in those private discussions.
@Rich. What is an effective “opposition” to you. Their job is to hold the Govt to account, which they are doing. It seems you don’t want the opposition to in any way criticize the Carney regime, regardless of what they may or may not be doing. In this case, Carney clearly didn’t deliver for Canadians. Outcomes need to be judged, not just empty words.
Even if this was unavoidable, it will be seen as a major loss for Carney when he needs to start bringing in some wins.
Anonymous. Yesterday you told me to be sceptical about Government and the MPs because that approach would change my views on Carney. You also said that this approach extends to Conservatives as well. You then said that we shouldn’t scape goat a PM from 12 years ago, which leaves Harper off the hook for his bad decisions by placing all the blame on Trudeau. You aren’t walking the walk.
You can’t ignore history. Harper took a multi-year surplus and turned it into deficit by reducing the GST and corporate income tax. He did this hoping for trickle down growth, which never happened. By the end of his term he successfully squandered government revenue without generating greater productivity while leaving us with less room to incentivize productivity advances by using tax credit programs, for example. You can’t just give Harper a pass on this because that would be scapegoating a PM from 12 years ago, particularly as the results of Harper’s decisions affected the incoming government.
As to being sceptical, there is a difference between looking at government with a critical eye and being critical for the sake of being critical. You called for a measured approach, but you and the other Cons here aren’t delivering.
The Con comments here can be summed up as unsupported opinions with no connection to reality. If you want to be taken seriously to a little research, recognize the facts on the ground, and show how they support your opinion that Carney is wrong, corrupt, incompetent, whatever. None of the Cons do that. Instead, at best they make things up.
Best example is the ongoing lie that Carney promised that he would get a deal with Trump. Carney said he was in the best position to deal with Trump, which is probably true given the other Party leaders. He also said that he had agreed to fast track negotiations with the U.S. starting July 2025. Neither statement are a promise that he would get a deal; that would depend on the nature of the proposed deal. In August, Carney walked away from the negotiations because the U.S. introduced terms that were unacceptable. Harper agreed with this decision. So, the Cons here are upset that Carney walked away from the bad deal on the table because they believed he promised to get a deal. I’m happy that Carney took no deal rather than a bad deal because a bad deal sets the base line for any further negotiations making a good deal in future less likely. I’ve asked the Cons to explain why they wanted the bad deal, but so far none have come forward. Says a lot about the quality of the Con comments here. They make claims with no evidence and when asked to support the obvious consequence of their position they can’t do it.
This is sad because our Parliamentary system needs an opposition to function properly. We don’t have an effective opposition now, and if the Cons here are any indication, the CPC won’t be a viable opposition.
If Brookfield owned it things would be all peaches and cream.
Some innovative Canadian should design and build vehicles that people actually want. North american market is flooded with overpriced unreliable vehicles.
Stop corporate welfare already. We are losing millions of tax dollars. What a waste. Allow the free market to reign
@7:57 “if an auto manufacturer wants to pull out of Canada, tell them to close all their dealerships too.”
I don’t understand how the concept of punishing 10’s of thousands dealership employees makes sense.
Why can’t we all be pleased that someone is taking over the plant and creating jobs?
Everyone knew Rochel was negotiating to purchase this plant months ago. Including Melanie Joly. It seems a bit sanctimonious to cry betrayal now. But that seems to be the Liberal government’s MO
So is negotiating trade deals with nobodies because you are too afraid of Trump.
Can we please stop the corporate welfare to auto manufacturers? The Canadian market is still very healthy; if an auto manufacturer wants to pull out of Canada, tell them to close all their dealerships too. You would end the welfare and attract a lot more manufacturers to Canada. But that was never the goal of Carney gov now was it, he just wants to liquidate Canada to the lowest bidder.
Total hypocrisy by Carney as he moved Brookfields office from Canada to the USA in which Canadians lost jobs. He is also heavily invested in the USA and his kids go to school there and his wife lives in the USA mainly. Carney needs to practice what he preaches.
Just recover all the money given to Stellantis and put it into health care and move on, stellantis just lost the sale of its vehicles in Canada as it is.
Capitalism baby!
Despite the public dismay conveyed by Carney and Joly on Tuesday, sources said the federal government had been engaging directly with both companies, knew the terms of the proposed sale and did not stand in the way of it.
corporate welfare and big industry lies canadian government is the patsy once again
I’ll be back!
Stellantis appears to fear Trump and the Republic wrath far more than it fears, Carney and his capable ministers who are being civilized, respecting the rules based order. It does appear time for the IRON FIST of nationalization.
All this could have been avoided had the big man Carney reached a trade deal with the US which was one of his election promises. But oh no we have to widen the rift with that virtue signaling Davos speech that left all the loony lefties salivating.
I’m disappointed in Carney who’s more worried about Union workers that are paid well, while most of Canada struggles. Carney is all for his own big investments along with the little finance minister who runs beside him like a puppet.
Sue ’em barefooted.
Carney writing off the $4.5 billion in CERB over payments and the $5.6 billion from CEBA is a “betrayal “ on tax payers
Carney just does not care about this country. Incredibly disappointing!
“I am the only one who can deal with Trump” and “I will get a deal by July 2025.” Now tell me what it is that Carney has actually achieved since being elected to government ……….. Crickets !!!!
Carney and his predecessor Trudeau have destroyed incentive for business investment in Canada and now that it is coming home to roost Carney is playing the “I care about workers” card when he really doesn’t give a hoot about Canadian workers or their families. If he did he would be using the billions of dollars his government is squandering on controlling the media narrative, and would give that as relief to struggling Canadians, along with his bogus carbon taxes. Carney is only about Carney and his business friends and associates profiting off our tax dollars.
I swim for a long long time but get very tired. So I let water out of bath tub.
I play kazoo with eyes wide open. But my ears hurt so much I go have bath.
I have friend and he leave me. I have no friend any more. So i go paint room.
@942pm, not Johnny, this guys mom should have swallowed instead
Your commenters brain is a one man band playing a kazoo in an empty subway station , genuinely believing it is performing at Carnegie Hall
I run very fast but stop. My head hurt to much.
I like legs. I lift them up to put food in mouth. Yum.
@928pm, not Johnny, the best part of this guy run down his mom’s leg
I go for long fly around, but my arms get tired. I try new things but I get lost getting there.
Your commenters argument just snapped shut on your own fingers like a giant wooden mousetrap baited with a single stale Cheeto
I hear farting noise still. I get scared. I sit on balloon and still hear more farting sounds. Then I see tv is on.
You commenters common sense is an overinflated balloon flying wildly around the room making farting noises until it hits the ceiling
My lights are out so I open my eyes wide. Really wide.
My head hurts so I put rubber bands in my rectum. Helps blood flow.
You commenters are lights out nobody home, house floating down the river in a raging storm
Rich a.k.a Ben
Just do one
Carney destroyed the market as he won’t make a deal. Now he expects companies to keep employees when they don’t have production and take a loss. Same guy who moved Brookfields office from Canada to the USA. Total hypocrisy
The liberals are a betrayal to Canadians, sounds like true bedfellows.
More lost jobs and another strikeout by Carney. Dude is total garbage. No positive results since he became PM. Just platitudes and virtue signalling.
Carney has totally been a disappointment. After 19 months he has not got one tariff line item reduced or eliminated. His Elbows Up approach has brought nothing of value and the Stellantis lost jobs out on his shoulders.
That is kind of what im saying Rich.
I’m not sure that “enemy of the people” and “seeing everything through that lens” is the idea, but there is merit in being critical of the gov. Many a societal change has come about through protest and opposition to the ruling power. Some good. Some surely bad. It depending on which end of the spectrum it falls and ones perception of the good bad spectrum.
I think being a federal politician, especially elected ones, makes you somewhat inherently not regular Canadians. Getting elected makes you about 1 in 100,000 with a salary in the top 4%, to start.
Like, flat Earth and all that? irrelevant.
Yes, of course this approach extends to conservatives. A colour, or a banner, or whatever, doesn’t make somebody immune to bad governance. Just to round things out a bit. Harper. Realistically Harper wasn’t my buddy, buddy. Its like we are scapegoating the prime minister from 12 years ago. Martin 20 years Chretien 25 years. Yeah Frig the 90s and early 2000 really were some glory days. For me, that was the best Canada ever was. Things have changed alot.
Yawn
I need more plunger action to clear out my empty head of bad thougts. Bad, bad thoughts.
Your commenters brain is just three circus clowns riding a tiny unicycle off a cliff while playing slide whistles
You commenters are confidently explaining politics like a blindfolded ostrich trying to parallel park a school bus
I heard a joke once…but it was about me. Im the joke. That’s all.
@752pm, not Johnny, this guys brain is a watermelon seed
I heard a car honk and I realize I am mentally challenged.
I fart and Anonymous the village idjit sez bless you
I have verbal diarriha, but I wipe my face with used toilet paper.
Everytime you commenters type a sentence a rubber chicken squeaks somewhere in the distance
its your government that fucked this up
Every word you commenters type sound like someone getting hit over the head with a comically oversized mallet
There’s a small bird flying around your head right now, waiting to fly in your ear and build a nest
“I am the only one who can deal with Trump” and “I will get a deal by July 2025.” Now tell me what it is that Carney has actually achieved since being elected to government ……….. Crickets !!!!
Carney and his predecessor Trudeau have destroyed incentive for business investment in Canada and now that it is coming home to roost Carney is playing the “I care about workers” card when he really doesn’t give a hoot about Canadian workers or their families. If he did he would be using the billions of dollars his government is squandering on controlling the media narrative, and would give that as relief to struggling Canadians, along with his bogus carbon taxes. No Ben Carney is only about Carney and his business friends and associates profiting off our tax dollars.
Somewhere a clown just honked his nose in respect for this absolute nonsense
Endless failure by Carney on so many files……
• Economic Contraction and Job Losses.
• Cost of Living and Food Insecurity. Food bank dependance is at record levels.
• Government spending and deficits continuing to grow and grow, rather than delivering promised fiscal discipline.
• Housing and Infrastructure Delays
• Declining Homebuilding.
• Pushback on supposed “Fast-Tracked” Projects with immediate resistance from Indigenous and environmental groups over consultation and climate concerns.
• Collapsed U.S. Trade Talks resulting in higher tariffs and ongoing uncertainty for key Canadian sectors like steel, forestry, and automobiles.
• Getting cosy with China given broader geopolitical tensions.
• Bypassing Parliament. The guy misses a large majority of Question Period sessions and announces major policies such as tax deductions and privatization plans outside of traditional parliamentary and budgetary frameworks.
• Strained Provincial Relations. With his top-down “competitive federalism,” unilateral federal deals on energy and trade have blindsided provincial premiers and weakened intergovernmental cooperation.
Everytime you commenters type, a tiny circus monkey drops its cymbals in sheer confusion
Your commenters brain’s sound like three circus clowns playing kazoos aggressively inside a tiny car
You commenters did not just miss the point, you fell through a wormhole into an alternate dimension where crayons are a major food group
Carneys plan backfired HARD in his own face. Looks good on him. Sad that his political games have already hit with such harsh consequences for Canadians.
You commenters are the exact reason aliens lock their doors when they fly past earth
Did you commenters get your geopolitical analysis from a Victorian doll, or did a raccoon whisper it to you behind a Denny’s
You commenters speak with the unearned confidence of a medieval peasant explaining where the sun goes at night
Anonymous. I forgot to add. Who was showing up at Trudeau’s house in their 10s of thousands daily? I don’t recall seeing crowds in front of Rideau Cottage. When did the country almost fall apart? That didn’t happen. Who are you talking about.
“Betrayal” Carney says. Well, I guess he knows all about that.
This has been on the radar a long time. Yet another waste of tax dollars given to a company with no strings attached, keep voting same old.
Anonymous. Why would I be suspect of the Government? It’s made up of and run by regular Canadians and I know a lot of them. Are you saying that we should begin from the point that the Government is the enemy of the people and see everything through that lens? If so, your position must be to distrust until proven otherwise. Do you also believe in conspiracy theories?
BTW. Does your approach extend to Conservative Governments? The Cons commenting here like to say that Trudeau was PM for a decade of decline. They never say that Harper was PM before Trudeau and that he took over from Chretien/Martin and their multi-year surpluses. Harper eliminated the surplus by reducing the GST and then doubled down by cutting the corporate tax by about 10% across the board. Harper was hoping that trickle down would create economic growth, but since its never worked anywhere it didn’t work in Canada. Because of those failed economic policies, Harper left Trudeau deficit and debt. Trudeau didn’t do a good job managing the economy but you can’t overlook Harper’s role, especially if you start from the position that you shouldn’t trust government.
Funny how all the loony lefties come out in sequence to defend their hero Carney.
The facts are people Canada under the Liberals is a failure !!! Ever increasing unemployment , Millions without a family doctor, record food bank claims, affordability crisis has created more homelessness and yet Carney opens the door to more third world immigration and I ask those loony lefties once and for all What positive achievements has Carney delivered in the 19 months since you naive people voted him in ?
Anonymous The Village Idiot and Johnny are the same person….maybe they have two idiotic personalities inside trying to out due each other?
Our country is in trouble. Is their a recession coming? Or is it here now?
Not a liberal fan: Joly I thought played hardball right out the gate. Not sure why the disdain for her here?
Multi billion $ private..public companies should never be subsidized with taxpayer dollars.
…Rich, you should start by being suspect of the government and work it backwards. Prove yourself wrong.
Trudeau did a “good job” through covid? The whole friggin country just about fell apart. The 10s of thousands of people showing up on his doorstep on the dialy? He essentially declared war on the citizens of Canada. Your short sightedness makes the future look bleak.
Rich is living in a fantasy bubble.
Just keep meddling in business there Carney and the Canadian economy will continue to circle around the drain.
The funnest thing about any liberals, is that they believe they can run a profitable business. To funny.
Rich’s Dad. CBC Radio, September 15, 2026, Stephen Harper said that Carney had no choice but to walk away from the U.S. deal. Look it up. Harper fully supported Carney. Sounds like a good idea to agree with the Press as it set out how the U.S. negotiated in bad faith and why Carney walked away. Unless you now disagree with Harper, but that’d be sacrilege.
You’re probably Anonymous. He says the same stupid thing about releasing the text of the Agreement so that he can decide for himself, as though he has the ability to understand the proposals being considered in a trade negotiation.
You’re just deflecting from the real issue. The Con cultists constantly say that Carney failed by not accepting the U.S. deal last August. The facts point to the U.S. proposal being a bad deal for Canada. Why are the Con Cultists upset that Carney refused to accept a bad deal for Canada? Why do they think we should have accepted that bad deal?
I don’t see why this is so difficult to grasp. I don’t expect any of the Con cultists to be able to explain why they want a bad deal for Canada without admitting that they actually hate Canada and want us to fail. The last thing they want is the truth to come out that they want Canada to fail.
So Anonymous. I ask you again. Explain why you think a bad deal is in Canada’s best interests? Try not to hide this time.
Your logic is currently doing the hokey pokey in the middle of a busy highway
Ben, mom and I are disappointed in you. You have a trans wife and are insufferable.
Your logic is currently wearing a clown suit at a very serious business meeting
You commenters speak with the absolute authority of someone who just accidentally glued their own hand to their forehead
You commenters have the unearned swagger of a pigeon that just found half a hotdog
Mark Carney’s been a real failure in my opinion. He sounds like he’s batting for us Canadians, but I like to see actions go with all those words and fance speeches. I was one of the ones that was duped by him saying it wasn’t a good time to change the government, but turns out he hasn’t been good at handling the situation with Trump.
Carnage claims it was a bad deal but Carnage and Domenic never released the complete text of the deal, so Canadians are forced to accept the “trust me bro.” No deals, no progress, Carnage sucks.
My stupid son Rich just takes politicians for their word, without seeing the proof.
Standing up for Canadian workers and Canadian industry should come before partisan politics.
But Poilievre has sided with Stellantis to try to score cheap political points.
Anonymous. I see you’re back and making no sense, as usual. Can you explain why taking the bad deal the U.S. was offering in August was the best thing for Canada? Bet you won’t even try.
Smart Guy. Not living up to your name at all. The VW battery plant isn’t dead, the opening has been delayed. What pipeline has been blocked? Trudeau built one, Carney just declared one to be a project of national importance that will be fast tracked through the approval process, Harper couldn’t get one built, and so gave up. Carney advised Trudeau on how to get through COVID. Trudeau did a good job, so I don’t see the problem with Carney’s advice. I think the problem is that, like all hyper partisans, you’ve decided that Carney is corrupt and everything he does is wrong. Taking that approach has never led anyone to a reasonable understanding of anything.
Did you commenters pull your comments out of a cereal box or a fever dream
In 19 months Carney has delivered absolutely nothing to Canadians. All hat and no cattle. Dude is a loser.
Your commenters logic is floating away on a helium balloon of pure delusion
You commenters have the reasoning skills of a GPS that keeps telling you to drive into a lake
Your commenters brain is essentially a hamster wheel, but the hamster died long ago
You commenters have the critical thinking skills of a potato battery trying to power a spaceship
Carney whines like a little schoolboy who lost his lunch playing marbles
No fair!!!!!!
LOL
If he had an ironclad contract instead of giving away the farm the situation would be different
But he’s such a brilliant financier , right elbozos? Can’t read a contract
Neither him nor Trudeau who he was advising since 2020
Rich and Ben are the same person. Can’t possibly be two people so delusional.
So the Libs blew another deal to go along with the other half dozen, battery plants,stopping pipelines,they had climate Barbie and Gibeau(convicted criminal) as ministers.Now they have Industry minister Barbie Joly,no wonder this country has turned into a Monty Python parody.Carney pisses off the USA with his speech and this is part of the result.He should keep his mouth shut.
Bob. As to your examples, they are all subject to Trump tariffs. Carney didn’t impose tariffs on Canadian exports. Trump thought he could force us to join the US through harsh economic measures, which are his tariffs. Carney didn’t do this. Carney has taken steps to diversify away from the US and that is working and giving us leverage in the trade war with the US. Does Carney get credit for that?
Bob. Of course they want a bad deal. Carney walked away from a bad deal. Harper said Carney was right to walk away. But the Cons criticize Carney for not accepting the deal on the table. So, they wanted Carney to take a bad deal. Why do they want a bad deal.
Rich
I don’t think that Cons want bad deal with US
Liberals are in power now and seems that we already have bad deal.
Steel aluminum lumber car parts ext ext
If you want to blame someone it’s your man Carney!
Ahkenaten tried to change which God was almighty and where the capital would be and by extension, trade partners and trade routes.
No one one can find him or his wife. We only know everything they attempted was reversed.
Meanwhile, Canada is sidelined by a government that refuses to accept its responsibility in maintaining the portfolio of trade customers that he inherited and thinks like Ahkenaten.
Right. Be anything else and keep your job.
“Awe hey boss (see: voters), I lost the $35 trillion dollar customer, but, hey…the Phillipines $500 billion market looks like a possible thing…
About that time off. I figured, while in Antigua on vacation, I put in some overtime on behalf of Canada and go for the over-saturated Caribbean market like no one ever thought of it before, huh?
I feel like, I feel like the big profits come after slavery, dependence on tourism, and corruption by foreign governments – the time is right.
I can feel it.”
So none of the Con cultists here can explain why they want a bad deal with the US. Figures. All the Con culhtists can do is complain. They can’t explain anything. They certainly can’t come up with a good idea or rely on fact. Just like their dear leader.
Sounds like we should be blocking all of their imports until the 222 million is paid back.
Never trust Carney, he’ll sell his mother for a quick buck!
Huge /Corporations/making mockery of CANADA again….
And the pot calls the kettle black!
Mr. CARNEY, THAT AS A CANADIAN BORN IN 1946 IS HOW I FEEL ABOUT YOUR DECISION TO INCORPORATE CANADIANS WITH THE EUROPEAN UNION AND DECREASE OUR IMPORTANCE AND FAVOUR WITH THE USA. AMERICA IS OUR NEIGHBOUR IN THE WESTERN WORLD WHICH IS FROM NWT TO THE TIP OF ARGENTIA IN SOUTH AMERICA. CANADA IS NOT ISOLATED! With this decision you are contradictory in your thinking. They are doing exactly what you are doing with this friendship “comcee/comsat” with EU’s Accepting Canada.
Never trust Americans. They’d sell their mothers for a quick buck.
The actions of Liberals are also a betrayal.
Elections have consequences.
Elbows up!
I hope that will teach them a lesson but I am afraid they will blame Trump for their misfortune anyway.
He moved his company HQ to thr US to avoid Canadian taxes.
Libturds saying nothing as usual, like anyone cares what those turnips have to say
Maybe time to put a lien on the monies from the sale to recoup what was agreed to years ago but Stellantis reneged and failed to deliver on the promises it made.
Maple Maga cons pushing PPs irrelevant nonsense like anyone gives a flying F what they say, lol!
Carney’s deliberate sabotage of trade relations with the US for the benefit of his foreign owners is the only betrayal here.
This PM is so incompetent, like the last one. All talk, no action. No deals. He even wanted us to basically join the EU, and thankfully the the EU didn’t want to issue us “Associate Membership” whatever that meant. I think the only thing this guy cares about are his U.S. investments and Brookfield.
@Rich The only comments I see on here that are untruthful lies are the ones you post !!!
Joly launched a dispute process October 25, just hearing now that it crashed and burned. Unfortunately our PM is full of spite…at whose cost? Why is he so spiteful on most decisions?… because he can be. Whereas most hard working Canadians just try to keep moving forward because they have bills to pay.
I am in a wreath of skunky smoke and its giving me visions of utopia. Look at all those deceased cons. Now all we have to do is siphon their bank accounts and we’ll all live happily ever after never having to work again.
Braindead Contards posting lies & garbage that is about as intelligent as Trumpkin MAGA cult, lol!
Better sue them too, better sue everyone
Aww shucks mr dictator. You mean companies can’t be coerced to lose money to save face for you? You suck at your job Carney.
Mark C,
Yours was the only one that made sense. Business is business and always has been. Sure they should give back the money they received(why they got it in the first place??) and after that they are free and clear. No company can be told how dare you close your doors. When your favorite department store or fast food outlet closes do you see the feds throwing money at them. Closures and layoffs are a fact of life. Move on people.
Does Poilievre not get its his conservatives here waisting money on spa deals and bribes thats ruining the economy
The hyper partisan Cons are out in force spreading lies and disinformation like always. Has anyone else noticed the smug self satisfaction that goes with being in the CPC cult. They’re so far gone that facts and consistency don’t matter. For examplr, they say that Carney hasn’t delivered the agreement with the US that he promised. He didn’t make that promise because that would be foolish, but the Con cultists are upset that Carney broke his promise and walked away from the deal the US was offering. It was a bad deal, even Harper said Carney was right to walk away, but the Con cult wanted it anyway. So, can any of you Cons explain why it would’ve been better to take the bad deal Trump was offering? I doubt antone will even try to answer. Easier to rely on the lies and disinformation
Does Carney ever know when to Zip It ?
Little man syndrome kicking in again.
Canada screwed again. Carney you suck!
No more of a betrayal than the Carney regime to use Chink steal in major projects.
F*ck you Carney! You and your damned regime ned to be stopped and held accountable for what you have done to this country! Maybe if you shut up and actually ‘NEGOTIATE’ with them instead of sending your attack shrew Joly to slam em all the time! Man what a bunch f*ckin screw ups! And no I dont need Ben or any other Liberal yap to sound off!
the company followed trumps rule and left, and like Steelco they need to pay back the money the province and feds gave them. But you know trump will stand with the American companies. And what can we do? Stop buying those cars and trucks from that company, and there is the rub most of the right wing faction drive Jeeps, and the bid Dodge trucks
Bye bye canada, thanks for the money SUCKERS!
Under Carney the Canadian government reaches new and unprecedented levels of sheer incompetence
Yet they just ditched the faithful Commissionaires for an American company. Please make sense
Yeah right a “ betrayal”
If you had an iron clad contract signed you wouldn’t be whining like a little kid
Mom they got my lunch and won’t give it back!
The much advertised banker is sooooo helpless
Hey, this is Stelantis fault not living up to their side of the contract! Let them all go to magaland where the traitors belong!! Bye bye!
Move to Illinois if you want. That’s business. But you will give me my $15 billion back first, thank you very much. That’s business.
The liberals have repeatedly lied, failed and lied some more. Please people of Canada open your eyes.
@Ben. Your programmed support for Carney makes me sick. Drink some more Kool aide.
@Ben. You are a misinforming evil Gen Zzzzzz lazy pompous ass who misuses his intelligence to support the corrupt Liebranos. What a waste of a pea brain.
@Ben. PP is the hero of mini-MAGA. Attack PP, they attack you.
@Ben Oh you are SO naive. Carney and his predecessor Trudeau have destroyed incentive for business investment in Canada and now that it is coming home to roost Carney is playing the “I care about workers” card when he really doesn’t give a hoot about Canadian workers or their families. If he did he would be using the billions of dollars his government is squandering on controlling the media narrative, and would give that as relief to struggling Canadians, along with his bogus carbon taxes. No Ben Carney is only about Carney and his business friends and associates profiting off our tax dollars.
What about the $50 billion to Volkswagon for battery plant.
What is the Librard definition of investment ?
Wow, Ben. Is that your opinion or an AI-generated disinformation piece?
“I am the only one who can deal with Trump” and “I will get a deal by July 2025.” Now tell me what it is that Carney has actually achieved since being elected to government ……….. Crickets !!!!
Canada has been destroyed and the live of Canadians have been ruined by the Liberal government since 2015…
Make sure that any money from Roshel goes through the govt so that Stellantis can’t walk off with taxpayers bailout money still owing..
Carney is standing up for Canada. But I digress.
Poilievre’s plan to hold Stellantis accountable is to fire everyone. That’s not a plan, and that’s not leadership.
Canadians need real solutions to protect jobs and hold corporations accountable, not empty slogans and political posturing.
One can question whose side Poilievre is on-Stellantis or the workers who are affected?
Like stellantis cares what Carney thinks! So funny 😂
Canadian should boycott Stellantis regardless if you like the brand or not
Classic Poilievre, demonstrating exactly why no one (even in his own party) thinks he can lead the country.
The Liberal government’s immigration policy is a massive betrayal; it is deeply disappointing…Enough is enough.. Carney, the ministers, and all Liberal politicians should resign and leave Canada.
Canada needs to seriously consider exiting NATO as this ‘trade war’ with Trump and his administration in terms of cost is worse than a real war. it costing Canada 1 billion/month and a company shut down any plant in canada. nobody will ever invest billions in starting a new plant like stelco again and no bank will lend to build if no access to the USA market. ok over 100,000 jobs loss from trump in less than 2 years and if this continue uover 300,000 job losss. it economic sabotage by an NATO ally by trump..Canada is being very nice for allowing this to happen. it’s econmic sabotage by foreign gov’t or Trump and Canada doesn’t beech to NATO about it?
Go back to sleep , PP. you have been redundant for quite some time now. Only a few trumpsters are listening to you now.
they are here to make money, not lose money or to create jobs etc and pay taxes. why would they lose money for ? they can no longer sell to the USA why have any auto plant in canada? the federgal gov’t is not subsidizing any company. they don’t have to be in Canada. it’s the Trump who betrayed Canada.
Joly and Carney can’t seem to get anything done or show positive results or outcomes.
Listen to these hypnotized elbozos in this comment section. You clowns could be pushed off a cliff by Carney himself you would still yell elbows up we love Carney on the way down right before you hit the ground you would say it was Trump or Poilievre’s fault for pushing you off the cliff. Just a bunch of helpless losers
@Anonymous. pp is dividing anything. Carney failed and now people lost their jobs. Carney owns this, not pp.
it’s more like failure of the federal gov’t to negotiate a ‘free trade’ deal with the americans, blame business and industry for job losses but never blame themsevlves. foreign trade is the federal gov’t responsibility. not the provincial or city.
Canada needs to fire the the entire liberal party. Bunch of clowns. Same as the clowns that vote for them. See below 👇🏻🤡
NOT AN ELECTED MAJORITY ELBOZO
Like I said earlier. When you have the population = market, companies will bend over backwards to cater to you. But population requires immigration, which MAGA traitors are against. “But, but but they drain our resource.” Sure, it requires resource, but history shows immigrants siblings bring in more to Canadian economy many times over the initial costs of bringing them in. The US would be a brain dead country and small economy had Trump ruled the US since the beginning. All the top US CEOs are recent immigrants: Google, MS, Nvidia, AMD, Micron, Uber, Zoom, Adobe and even Tesla’s Elon must is an illegal immigrant.
Most people commenting on here have kown idea what they are talking about and have their head up their ass
PP is at it again. Divide Canada as much as possible instead of uniting it at a time when we really need to unite against a much bigger force than our elected, majority party! Too bad PP has nothing positive to offer Canada. He needs to be smart instead of loud!
No company can ever change what they do in Canada, no matter how difficult I make it to be profitable. No deal is better than a bad deal. Tighten your belts auto workers. We’re all in this together you know.
When I read many of these comments it makes me wonder what some of these people actually do to contribute to our country or is their main purpose in life to just be negative. We are lucky to live in Canada, try living in the usa under Trump then you will truly have something to complain about. Better yet, put your name forward and run for office if you have all the answers.
Canada must STOP subsidizing corporations like Stellantis who merely pull out of Canada willy-nilly. SUE!!!
Maple MAGAt cons out in full force today with their typical insignificant blather, lol!
I think we should build automobiles in Western Canada.
Such a Maple Maga comment from pp…this headline is attracting all kinds of MINORITY opinion absent anything remotely nearing a better solution…typical 🙄
Great now turn that plant into a production line for the Grippen E and C.
Mark Carney is a betrayal to all the honest people in Canada. More garbage to be allowed into Canada, plus their complete families. We have no doctors as it is. The LPC is a complete failure in everything they do.
The only ones betraying us is you and your inept, corrupt government. How many billion(s) in subsidized money is now gone on her watch.
Elbows up.
If there is a dumber minister in cabinet, i’m not sure who it is. Despite the very weak bench strength of that caucus, she marks herself special in cognitive weakness.
Given the negative business climate that Carney’s left wing ideologies has created, his “Investment fund” will, just like the one he crated in the UK, fail miserably and take billions of our tax dollars with it.
Incompetence in Carney’s government is sending signals to business that Canada is not the place to continue investments. So business is starting to flee Canada for countries that are more business friendly, unlike Canada under Carney that is turning to left wing and communist ideologies.
Carney says the “work” isn’t the problem. People get paid for results and positive outcomes not just going thru the motions and pretending to be busy. Carney has delivered zero results now in over 19 months. His Elbows Up approach was a foolish choice.
Ya lets force Stellantis to keep building the jeeps which no one wants. In North America these Jeeps are over priced and their sales has dropped 33%. If they cannot build a car that people want then OK lets keep it open. But since is has been closed since 2023 and Stellantis does not have any vehicle to put their. then it should be sold. Automotive news papers told us twenty years ago that if Canada was not watching what the auto industry was doing, Ontario vehicle makers would be gone in twenty years. Problem here is our Politicians cannot think that far ahead.
“I’ll get us a deal by July 2025”
Thr government sitting on their hands, elbow deep, is the betrayal
Pierre’s right! That f *ucking cu nt has done nothing!
Just more hot air from PP, lol!! How the Cons still believe in this guy is beyond stupid…..but then, can’t fix stupid!
For being a successful man of business he sure plays the fool. Carney knows companies are there to sell their products and make money not to pay employees for doing nothing. The only betrayal here is Carney not getting a deal over the tariffs like he promised Canadians.
@Michel. How is Joly doing a “good” job. She has zero results to speak of.
Carney said the same thing with Stelco. How he forgets he moved Brookfields office from Toronto to USA. Total hypocrite.
To all the Cat ladies, come up with a coherent rebuttal of PP, s post. Feelings are not reality.
Hope the feds take legal action against Stellantis!! In the meantime, boycott every f’n Stellantis product!!!
Hey Clowney, you betrayed the Canadian public when you said you were going to get a deal done with Trump.
Of course he doesn’t blame the incompetent Minister
She will likely get a promotion
I love how liberals are putting down PP. When carney has used most of his ideas in some way or another. Look at what he campaigned on and look what carney has done hmmm. And lets be honest here. How many of you feel that you are better off now or before Carney became PM?
Any one remember when John Turner grab the the ass of Comenella. I think I have the name wrong but she was a Minister of Sports and he was running for the Libera leadership to be come interm PM
Don’t worry people they will transfer to Gov. Jobs. See problem gone?
Joly has always been useless. Remember how she tried to be tough to Putin? Such a lightweight.
Melanie Joly is doing a great job. PP not so much. Why don’t Conservative get rid of this guy and install someone with a brain.
Swing and a miss?
Try again Pierre.
Dong work for Youda.
Is anybody listening to PP? Cons, get rid of this lightweight loser.
Get the hook. He acts like the Conservatives could have stopped it. Ridiculous. What a con artist.
This is the consequences of Elbows up. I hope the laid off employees feel satisfied with the result. Carney doesn’t care about them.
PP is funny.
Never going to happen
The LPC doesn’t punish incompetence
They reward it
Agree. Joly has totally dropped the ball and needs to be held accountable for her incompetence and poor results.