Retired Quebec judge Jacques Delisle convicted of murder to remain in prison pending case review

Former judge Jacques Delisle, centre, walks out of a courtroom at his murder trial Tuesday, May 8, 2012 in Quebec City.
Former judge Jacques Delisle, centre, walks out of a courtroom at his murder trial Tuesday, May 8, 2012 in Quebec City. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Jacques Boissinot

A retired Quebec judge serving a life sentence after being convicted of murdering his wife will not be released from prison pending a federal review of his case, the Superior Court has ruled.

Jacques Delisle claims he was wrongly convicted due to a judicial error and wanted to be freed on bail during the review by the Justice Department.

READ MORE: Quebec judge Jacques Delisle found guilty of murdering wife

Delisle was found guilty in 2012 of first-degree murder in the 2009 slaying of his wife, Nicole Rainville.

In his ruling Wednesday, Justice Benoit Moulin wrote that releasing the 81-year-old Delisle risked undermining the public’s confidence in the justice system.

“The public’s confidence in the administration of justice demands that Mr. Delisle continue to serve his sentence,” the ruling read.

Story continues below advertisement

“A public, composed of reasonable people, well-informed about the law and of the circumstances of the case and who appreciate the foundations of our criminal justice system…wouldn’t accept his release at this stage of the procedures.”

READ MORE: Jacques Delisle: Canada’s Justice Minister to review murder conviction of Quebec judge

Delisle’s conviction was upheld on appeal and the Supreme Court of Canada refused to hear his case.

The Justice Department, however, decided in September to review his case due to new evidence.

WATCH BELOW: Jacques Delisle found guilty

Delisle’s lawyers argue new ballistics tests reveal the jury convicted their client on faulty evidence and they are requesting a second trial.

Story continues below advertisement

READ MORE: Former Quebec judge convicted of killing his wife says he helped her commit suicide

Moulin said the evidence he’s seen isn’t sufficient to authorize Delisle’s release.

“The analysis of expert opinions leads to the conclusion that at the very least, the pathological and ballistic evidence remains litigious,” he wrote.

Delisle denied in a 2015 televised jailhouse interview that he killed Rainville and said he helped her take her own life by leaving a loaded gun for her to use.

READ MORE: Investigation launched into former judge Jacques Delisle’s first-degree murder conviction

He is the only Canadian judge ever convicted of first-degree murder.

Sponsored content