City considers changing snow-clearing policy

WINNIPEG – Winnipeggers should pay more for some city services and get less, according to recommendations in a report prepared for city hall.

An operational review of Winnipeg’s public works department by KPMG LLP found potential savings of up to $5.5-million annually.

It holds 25 recommendations, including narrowing the path a plow makes on residential streets and no longer scraping to the bare pavement — changes that could save up to $3 million.

While some people question how that would affect streets with no sidewalks or parking, others think it is a good idea.

“Crews are hitting the curbs all the time and they are all broken and they have to come back and repair them,” said Raymond Raiche, who lives in St. Boniface.

The review also suggests a surcharge be tacked onto residents’ tax bills if the city goes over its yearly snow-clearing budget.

“That is not something anyone I have spoken to is in favour of,” said St. Boniface Coun. Dan Vandal, who chairs the public works committee. “That is an idea thrown out there by KPMG that is going to be deep-sixed by council.”

The review also recommends planting fewer flowers and not completely paying the cost to clean up graffiti on homes and businesses.

“Not every (recommendation) will get approved,” said Vandal. “I can tell you now the graffiti one is probably not going to get approved, although I am speaking about myself.”

The external review cost $287,500. Some councillors question if it was the best use of taxpayer dollars.

“There is not a lot of substances there and not a lot of realistic recommendations that can be implemented,” said Charleswood Coun. Paula Havixbeck. “Quite frankly, it is a waste of taxpayers’ money.”

That’s only the cost of the first phase. The second one is set to start soon and the city is asking for help from the same company responsible for this review.