Advertisement

Alward shrugs off criticisms over early patronage appointment

Alward shrugs off criticisms over early patronage appointment - image

FREDERICTON, NB – New Brunswick’s new Conservative premier shrugged off criticisms Friday that he’s started his term with an inappropriate patronage appointment.

David Alward said his decision to appoint Tory campaign organizer Daniel Allain as chief executive of NB Liquor was based on Allain’s qualifications.

Alward says Allain brings valuable experience from both the public and private sectors to the position.

The premier also said he has given Allain "a specific mandate and he will report back to cabinet…by the end of 2011," on a new business model for NB Liquor.

However, a member the Coalition of New Brunswickers – a citizen’s group that is lobbying for increased political accountability – says the appointment appears to contradict Conservative election promises to decrease political hiring.

Auguste Gallant said the six-figure salary, estimated to be about $150,000, shouldn’t be filled without a competition.

Gallant said the appointment wasn’t in keeping with the statements the Conservatives made leading up to the Sept. 27 election.

In a July 14 submission to the coalition, the Progressive Conservatives said they planned to expand the online requests for nominations to provincial agencies, boards and commissions to include more organizations.

The initiative was mentioned three times in the submission made by Greg Lutes, who was appointed secretary to the policy and priorities committee of cabinet at the same time Allain got his job.

Gallant says while the appointment is disappointing for citizens, it must be doubly so for employees at NB Liquor who hope hard work and commitment will help them climb the ladder to the top job.

"If you’re making a career at NB Liquor and you spend years and years in the ranks of the agency and you know you have no chance of rising to the top of the ranks, it must be pretty damned frustrating," Gallant said.

Allain is the third political appointment to the position in the last decade.

Don Desserud, a professor of political science at the University of New Brunswick in Saint John, said Alward missed a great opportunity to signal that he was breaking from politics as usual.

"This is depressingly predictable, that once again you would have a high-profile patronage appointment right off the bat," he said.

Desserud said it has never been a question of the qualifications of the candidate.

Allain, who has a master’s of business administration and spent the last four years as the head of Downtown Moncton, "seems perfectly qualified and will probably do a great job," Desserud said.

"But why you can’t do this through an open process is beyond me," he said.

The tendency to reward party stalwarts is typical among political parties, he said.

"It’s seen as the way that you do things in New Brunswick. It’s a way of rewarding people who have worked very hard for you and have things to offer."

"That’s not the way the public reads this. The public reads this as patronage."

Advertisement

Sponsored content

AdChoices