Quebec authorities concerned about possible child neglect in Lev Tahor community

Ultra-Orthodox Jewish children walk past slogans of the Neturei Karta movement during a rally held by the small anti-Zionist Jewish faction, that opposes Israel's existence, in Jerusalems Mea Sharim district on March 20, 2013. Ahmad Gharabli/AFP/Getty Images

MONTREAL – Child-welfare authorities and local police in Ontario say they found nothing unusual when they checked in on an ultra-Orthodox Jewish sect that fled to that province last week amid allegations of child neglect.

Members of the Lev Tahor community of about 200 people – about half of them children- were under investigation by social services in Quebec for a host of issues including hygiene, children’s health and allegations that the children weren’t learning according the Quebec curriculum.

The community denies any mistreatment of the children, but left Quebec a little more than a week ago and ended up settling in southwestern Ontario.

Quebec child-welfare officials said on Monday they briefed their counterparts in Ontario on the case and would wait to see how authorities in Chatham-Kent and Windsor, Ont., decide to proceed.

Authorities in Ontario have only said they are aware of the group’s presence in the region. The local police said on Tuesday that it checked in on the community and are monitoring the situation.

Story continues below advertisement

“An initial assessment of the children’s well-being has been conducted with the assistance of the Chatham-Kent Integrated Children’s Services and at this time there are no concerns,” Const. Renee Cowell of the Chatham-Kent police said in a statement.

The investigation began last winter and Quebec welfare authorities have described the situation for some children as “serious.”

The head of youth protection for Quebec’s Laurentians region said there were concerns about the health and level of education of the children.

There were claims the homes where the children lived were dirty and littered with garbage and that the children, who are home-schooled, were not capable of doing basic math. Many also spoke neither French nor English.

Quebec officials alleged the situation “establishes a presumption of neglect against children.” The Quebec authorities had been working with the group until Nov. 18, when some 40 families left their homes in Ste-Agathe-des-Monts in the middle of the night.

“With the Lev Tahor community moving to Ontario, exchanges have continuously been made by the Quebec welfare office and aid workers in Ontario as well as police in that province,” the Quebec organization said in a statement.

The Lev Tahor has denied through spokespeople that the children being neglected.

Nachman Helbrans, a spokesman for the sect, has said they want to educate their children according to their own religious beliefs and fled to Ontario to avoid Quebec’s education system, which “doesn’t give freedom of religion as most people understand it.”

Story continues below advertisement

Helbrans said the move had been in the works for some time.

In a radio interview with Radio-Canada on Tuesday, Quebec Education Minister Marie Malavoy called the situation “sensitive” and one that must be taken seriously.

The Education Department had negotiated with the community over the children’s schooling, which is largely religious teaching in an environment without proper permits.

Malavoy said the government offered compromises over the months but the families chose to leave.

“Our biggest preoccupation is the plight of these children, the well-being of these kids who are caught up in a situation for which they are not responsible.”

One expert on sects called the situation complex.

“Part of it is a need to understand how to deal with these kinds of closed groups,” said Mike Kropveld, executive director of Montreal-based Info-Cult.

“Dealing with them and then deciding what to do is far more complex than people want to believe or understand.”

Kropveld says it is important to act without exacerbating the situation. For example, he said if the leader is perceived as the sole representative of God, that person’s power can be enhanced if the intervention of authorities is unsuccessful.

Story continues below advertisement

“You can make the group more closed and more extreme,” Kropveld warned.

The Lev Tahor, which means “pure heart,” came to Canada in 2005 after their spiritual leader, Rabbi Shlomo Elbarnes, was granted refugee status here.

Members of the anti-Zionist group, which opposes Israel and advocates Arab domination in the region, settled in a popular tourist destination in the Laurentian mountains north of Montreal.

Elbarnes, who also goes by the last name Helbrans and is Nachman Helbrans’ father, made headlines in the United States in 1994 when he was convicted of kidnapping a teenaged boy. The boy was studying under him in Brooklyn.

After serving his sentence, Elbarnes was deported to Israel. He then entered Canada on a temporary visa.

A Federal Court ruling in 2005 upholding Elbarnes’ refugee status in Canada found he could not be considered safe in Israel, in part because his “religious belief and opinion are against the mere existence of Israel as an independent country.”

One Jewish rights organization called the group extreme andsaid that no one in the Jewish community – be they traditional or ultra-orthodox – would view the organization in a positive light.

“This group exhibits cult-like behaviour and is nothing more than a perversion of Judaism,” Frank Dimant of B’nai Brith Canada said in a statement.

Story continues below advertisement

“We are very much worried about the well-being of the children and have advised the social service and police authorities to ensure that they are properly cared for.”

Sponsored content