KANDAHAR, Afghanistan – The guns-for-hire prowl the Afghanistan highways, heavily armed, sometimes wearing ski-masks and looking like something out of a Road Warrior movie.
Some of them are supplied by local warlords, others work for large U.S. and British corporations – and they are critical to western military operations in the war-torn country.
They protect supply convoys bringing in equipment and other material for the war effort. They stand guard at coalition bases, including those operated by the Canadian military. They provide protection for embassies and they are responsible for training the Afghan National Police.
As the U.S. focuses its attention on Afghanistan, the number of private security personnel is soaring. Afghanistan, which had been a moderate source of employment for security contractors, has become the hot market for guns for hire.
"In politics, they say follow the money," said Peter Singer, a Brookings Institution defence analyst and author of Corporate Warriors, a book about privatized warfare. "Well, this is what is happening in Afghanistan, but with private security."
In January, a U.S. Congressional study noted the number of armed security contractors working for the Pentagon in Afghanistan jumped from a little more than 3,180 to just over 10,700 in the period from December 2008 to September 2009.
It’s estimated there are 25,000 registered security contractors in Afghanistan. Most of the contractor army is made up of Afghan nationals employed by international companies or are working for Afghan firms or power brokers.
The increase in private security contractors is part of a surge in the total number of contractors, including those who do construction, cook meals, or perform other jobs for the military, with more than 100,000 in Afghanistan.
As if that wasn’t enough, the U.S. government is planning a civilian surge in Afghanistan, and will soon flood the country with specialists for significant projects in an attempt to turn around the Afghan reconstruction effort. There is talk about 50,000 contractors being involved. These people and their projects will all need security, say aid workers in Afghanistan.
But the reliance on armed private security contractors is already causing problems.
In February, U.S. military commanders warned that trigger-happy Afghan contractors guarding coalition convoys were indiscriminately shooting and killing civilians in western Kandahar province. Such abuses hurt U.S. efforts to win over the local population since the contractors were being viewed by Afghans as being part of coalition forces, officers said.
In January, it was revealed that an Australian security contractor had been sentenced to death in Kabul for murdering an Afghan colleague and then claiming the man had been killed by insurgents.
Xe Services, the security company formerly known as Blackwater, which was infamous for a number of incidents in which civilians were gunned down in Iraq, is now under investigation for its activities in Afghanistan.
In February, Congress heard about claims that Xe Services employees stole weapons and then, while intoxicated, killed two Afghans and injured two others. One of the guards had a criminal record for assault in the U.S. while the other had been kicked out of the U.S. military after testing positive for cocaine.
Last month, U.S. Defence Secretary Robert Gates announced an inquiry into who authorized private contractors in Afghanistan to run what some critics are claiming is a rogue spy ring. The spy network helped gather intelligence needed for U.S. forces to hunt down and kill insurgent leaders, according to reports.
In addition, there are questions about the effectiveness of the contractor-operated $1.7 billion training program for the Afghan National Police. That training is provided by the U.S. company DynCorp.
U.S. government auditors found that more than $300 million in invoices associated with the program were "approved even though they were not allowable or reasonable."
Iraq had been the lucrative market for private security. But even back in 2007 some firms were already getting ready for what they believed would be an increase in business in Afghanistan.
ArmorGroup Ltd., which constructed a state-of-the-art secure facility on the outskirts of Kabul, talked about further expanding its capabilities in Afghanistan. At that point, the British-based company was in the first year of a 10-year business plan for Afghanistan with its sights set on the lucrative training contract for Afghan police.
Much of the growth was also being fuelled by ArmorGroup’s win of two major contracts in Afghanistan. In 2007, the firm announced that its subsidiary had been awarded a deal to provide security services to the U.S. Embassy in Kabul.
But in September, some ArmorGroup employees made headlines after they complained their colleagues guarding the U.S. embassy participated in sex parties and were pressured to perform sex acts for promotions. Eight guards were fired and two resigned.
But none of the problems now emerging should come as a surprise since similar issues about a lack of accountability and criminal activities have already been seen among security contractors in Iraq, Singer said.
One of the main problems, he said, is that the U.S. government has still not built up the capacity on its own to do the various military and state-building roles needed for overseas operations. Instead, it contracts out such work to private industry, with mixed results.
The actions of such security firms have also affected Canadian troops in Kandahar. In the summer of 2008, freelance gunmen were blamed for the death of Canadian soldier Master Cpl. Josh Roberts, who was killed in a firefight just west of Kandahar City. The Canadians were being attacked by insurgents at the time but also in the area returning fire were Afghan private security guards accompanying a supply convoy.
A Canadian officer originally said it was believed that the contractors from Compass Security, a firm used by Canada, were responsible for Roberts’ death but an investigation by the military’s National Investigation Service exonerated those gunmen. NIS officials concluded that insurgents killed Roberts.
But Roberts’ mother, Beth Figley, and her family have questioned the validity of the NIS investigation, noting a number of discrepancies, conflicting testimony from witnesses and the destruction of video evidence of the incident.
Afghanistan’s government has been attempting to crack down on private security contractors and private militias but with limited success.
Last year, Kandahar province’s criminal investigation director as well as its police chief, who had worked closely with the Canadian military, were gunned down during a dispute with Afghan security contractors working for the U.S. That prompted the country’s interior minister, Mohammad Hanif Atmar, to call for the disbandment of all private security forces in Afghanistan.
That wasn’t done but some of those working in Kandahar in support of coalition forces said Afghan authorities now seem to be going after foreign workers.
"The government seems to want to go after the contractors, whether you work for a security company or work like us," said Vince Scopa, a former U.S. navy officer who has worked in Afghanistan since 2003 building bases and other installations for coalition forces. "They’re looking for weapons. They’re looking for big bribes."
Scopa, who used to go into downtown Kandahar City, now no longer makes such trips. He also no longer carries a weapon because of new rules brought in by the Afghan government.
Since Scopa can’t afford the expensive fees being charged by guards provided by U.S., British or Afghan private security companies, he has limited his travel and his work in Afghanistan. He does, however, live in a Kandahar compound owned by a local warlord who uses his own guards to provide security there.
Increased insurgent activity and the high cost of hiring private security limits his company from bidding on reconstruction contracts that might benefit the average Afghan, Scopa added.
Back in the U.S., more questions are now being asked about the use of private security contractors in Afghanistan.
Allegations that such companies have paid off warlords and insurgents not to attack their convoys are under investigation by a U.S. congressional subcommittee.
Last month, U.S. federal government auditors stopped army plans to award Xe Services the billion-dollar contract to train the Afghan police. The auditors uncovered irregularities in the bidding process and determined that other firms, such as DynCorp., had been unfairly excluded from bidding.
But Singer said the U.S. taxpayer will be the loser in this contract. "It’s like a toss-up between Tweedledee and Tweedledum," he said. "There are concerns about both companies."
Still, it may be difficult for the U.S. government to entirely limit the use of such contractors, since the Pentagon has come to rely on them so much. "They have a willingness to work in places that very few companies are willing to work," Pentagon spokesman Geoff Morrell recently said of Xe. "So they provide a much-needed service and the ability to do it well."
Comments
Want to discuss? Please read our Commenting Policy first.