FAIRFAX, Va. – Inside the aptly named Patriot Center, U.S. President Barack Obama was riling up supporters with animated talk about making health care history in America.
"Yes, we can," the enthusiastic crowd of about 8,500 roared in response, repeating the old campaign refrain.
Outside, however, Judy Kirk was stalking the security line on the George Mason University campus, practically seething with anger.
The 68-year-old northern Virginia woman lost six of her Irish brothers to colon cancer in a public health care system that told them they were suffering from hemorrhoids.
A native of Tipperary who moved from Ireland to the United States in her 20s, Kirk made a half-dozen mournful journeys home in the late 1980s and early 1990s to bury her kin.
Now Kirk, a colon cancer survivor herself, fears America is about to be forced to accept the same kind of "socialized health care" that she says was responsible for the deaths in her family.
"They were postponed, postponed, postponed for treatment until they died," Kirk says of her brothers, none of whom lived to see their 63rd birthday.
"When I had cancer 11 years ago in the United States, my doctor saw me that day and I was operated on within 24 hours."
Like the 200 other demonstrators who came to protest Obama as he made a final public pitch for a $940-billion health care bill, Kirk is a passionate defender of the very system of private insurance the president blames for preventing millions of Americans from getting coverage.
It may be true that the legislation headed for a final vote as early as Sunday in the House of Representatives doesn’t actually create a new U.S. government-run insurance plan, like ones in Canada. And it may be true that the older protesters in the crowd – including Kirk – currently get at least some of their health coverage through Medicare, the existing government insurance system for American seniors.
No matter.
For the folks corralled behind yellow police tape as the president spoke, "Obama-care" still amounts to a government takeover of the $2.5-trillion-a-year American system – and a step on a slippery slope to an America they no longer recognize.
"I think the bill is an abomination," said Larry King, a member of the Northern Virginia Tea Party who carried a handmade sign that said "Obama Socialism Failure" on one side and "Obama you lie" on the other.
"He is a socialist and the country is awakening to the dangers of socialism."
The raw emotions on display among health care reform opponents served as a potent reminder Friday of the risks Obama is taking on a bill that could define his presidency and redefine the way health care is delivered.
A Gallup poll earlier this month reflected an America deeply split over the bill, with 48 per cent against and 45 per cent in favour.
The final version of the legislation would regulate private insurers, offer federal subsidies to make premiums more affordable to the middle class and provide more money for Medicaid to low-income Americans. It will add a Medicare tax on unearned income and will eventually tax existing high-cost "Cadillac" plans. If passed, it will eventually provide coverage to 32 million Americans currently without health insurance, according to the non-partisan Congressional Budget Office.
The House of Representatives is no less divided than Americans; less than 48 hours before a likely vote, Democratic leaders are reportedly still a handful of votes short of the 216 needed to secure passage.
Enter Obama, in full campaign mode, hoping to change some minds.
Don’t believe the "nonsense" that’s being circulated about a government takeover or alleged death panels that Sarah Palin claimed were "going to kill granny," Obama told the crowd in Fairfax.
Without legislation that bars private insurers from denying coverage to people with pre-existing conditions, or prevents them from dumping customers when they get sick, "the insurance industry will continue to run amok," Obama said.
"They will continue to jack up premiums 40 or 50 or 60 per cent as they have in the last few weeks without any accountability whatsoever."
The upcoming vote, he said, was nothing short than a test of America’s mettle as a nation.
"It’s a debate about the character of our country, about whether we can still meet the challenges of our time – whether we still have the guts and the courage to give every citizen, not just some, the chance to reach their dreams," he said.
"Teddy Roosevelt, Republican, was the first to advocate that everybody get health care in this country. Every decade since, we’ve had presidents, Republicans and Democrats, from Harry Truman to Richard Nixon to JFK to Lyndon Johnson – every single president has said we need to fix this system."
Obama’s power of persuasion failed to work on two protesters who had made their way inside the Patriot Center, only to be escorted out by security after heckling the president.
The rancour continued outside the event, where supporters of the legislation exchanged taunts with opponents.
"Don’t kill babies, kill the bill," yelled a young boy, who was among a group of pro-life protesters who contend the legislation will fund abortion – a charge denied by Democrats.
"You want insurance, pay for it," shouted one man, clutching a corner of a giant American flag.
The upcoming votes in Congress may close the legislative debate on health care, but they won’t end the broader argument waging across America.
SIDEBAR: What’s next?
The House of Representatives will likely vote Sunday. Lawmakers will essentially be voting on two pieces of legislation – an $875-billion health care bill passed before Christmas by the Senate, and the new $940-billion version incorporating a set of "fixes" proposed by Obama to make the legislation more palatable to some Democrats.
The U.S. president could then conceivably sign the original $875-billion version into law.
The revised $940-billion version would then go to the Senate, where Democrats plan to use a tactic known as ‘reconciliation’ to trump a Republican filibuster and pass the legislation with a simple 51-vote majority. Obama hopes to sign that final version into law before Congress’s Easter break.
Comments
Want to discuss? Please read our Commenting Policy first.