Advertisement

Supreme Court defends anonymity of informant in B.C. case

OTTAWA – Two former high-ranking Liberal aides, who face a corruption trial in British Columbia stemming from a 2003 police raid on the provincial legislature, have lost a court fight to attend a special closed-door hearing in their case.

The Supreme Court of Canada on Thursday unanimously overturned an earlier decision in the B.C. Court of Appeal that had granted defence lawyers for David Basi and Bobby Virk permission to attend a court proceeding to decide whether the legal tenet of police informant privilege should apply to a Crown mystery witness.

Crown lawyers won their quest to bar the defence team from the hearing, arguing that allowing them in could reveal the informant’s identity.

"While everyone charged with a criminal offence in Canada is constitutionally entitled to full and timely disclosure of all relevant material under the control of the Crown, the entitlement to disclosure is neither absolute nor unlimited.," Justice Morris Fish wrote in the 7-0 ruling.

"It is only where innocence is at stake that the privilege yields and information tending to reveal the identity of the informant can be disclosed."

Lawyers for Basi and Virk, two former civil servants, failed in their argument that an accused or a lawyer has a right to be present at all aspects of a trial.

Basi and Virk are charged with accepting a benefit, breach of trust and fraud, stemming from the $1-billion sale of B.C. Rail in 2003.

In pre-trial proceedings, they sought disclosure of certain documents and portions of documents.

The Crown requested a hearing behind closed doors, with only Crown lawyers present, to determine whether the documents are protected by informant’s privilege.

Also known as the "secrecy rule," informant’s privilege prevents disclosure of information in legal proceedings that could reveal the identity of the person, with a goal of encouraging citizens to report crime.

Basi and Virk’s trial was initially scheduled to begin in 2005, but it has been delayed by pre-trial wrangling.

Advertisement

Sponsored content

AdChoices