Advertisement

Magnotta’s actions prove planning of deliberate murder, Crown tells jury in closing arguments

Time is of the essence, the jury was told.

What did Luka Magnotta do after killing Jun Lin? Where did he go? Focusing on those details, surely, will confirm the killer was organized and in touch with reality, Crown prosecutor Louis Bouthillier told the jury during his closing arguments Thursday.

“We see during those [first] 48-odd hours, Mr. Magnotta is very busy,” he said, asking the jury to find the defendant guilty of first-degree murder. “He’s very purposeful … and there doesn’t seem to be any indication of him not being in contact with the outside world at this point.”

READ MORE: ‘Insanity is insanity,’ defence argues in closing arguments

And so the lawyer recounted, in the same precise detail the Quebec Superior Court heard throughout the 10-week trial, every movement Magnotta took from the moment he entered his apartment building with Jun Lin on May 24, 2012 until he left for Paris two days later.

Story continues below advertisement

Magnotta made multiple trips — 16 in total — to the garbage room, throwing out much of what Montreal police would later recover as evidence. He changed his outfit a number of times, checked out his reflection in the building’s lobby mirrors, ordered pizza, and made several trips in and out of the building.

READ MORE: Tracing Luka Magnotta’s footsteps, Part 1 of 3 The night Jun Lin is last seen alive

“And finally, at 5:14 p.m., it’s the last time the video cameras at 5720 Décarie Blvd. will catch a glimpse of Mr. Magnotta,” Bouthillier said.

That is when Magnotta hopped in a cab to Pierre Elliott Trudeau airport in Montreal to catch an Air Transat flight to Paris. He stayed there less than a week, losing out on several nights he’d pre-paid for a hotel room, to head to Berlin.

READ MORE: Tracing Luka Magnotta’s footsteps, Part 2 of 3 The making of a killer

Whereas Bouthillier recalled evidence already finely detailed throughout the trial, defence lawyer Luc Leclair on Wednesday told the jurors to disregard much of what they’d heard throughout the 40 days of testimony.

That, despite the fact his central witnesses — three psychiatrists who treated and assessed the defendant — all testified Magnotta was in a frenzied state of psychosis when he killed Lin, the consequence of schizophrenia.

Story continues below advertisement

GALLERY: Photos of Jun Lin, who was killed between May 24 and May 25, 2012.

19
Photos from the family of Jun Lin, the victim of Luka Magnotta were given to media Tuesday, April 2, 2013 in Montreal. CANADIAN PRESS/HO-Lin Family
29
Photos from the family of Jun Lin, the victim of Luka Magnotta were given to media Tuesday, April 2, 2013 in Montreal. CANADIAN PRESS/HO-Lin Family
39
Photos from the family of Jun Lin, the victim of Luka Magnotta were given to media Tuesday, April 2, 2013 in Montreal. CANADIAN PRESS/HO-Lin Family
49
Photos from the family of Jun Lin, the victim of Luka Magnotta were given to media Tuesday, April 2, 2013 in Montreal. CANADIAN PRESS/HO-Lin Family
59
Jun Lin poses in this undated family handout photo. Handout from the Lin Family
69
Photos from the family of Jun Lin, the victim of Luka Magnotta were given to media Tuesday, April 2, 2013 in Montreal. CANADIAN PRESS/HO-Lin Family
Story continues below advertisement
79
Luka Magnotta (right) is seen entering his Montreal apartment building the night of May 24, 2012 accompanied by Chinese student Jun Lin in a framegrab from a video released at the Magnotta trial. Luka Magnotta (right) is seen entering his Montreal apartment building the night of May 24, 2012 accompanied by Chinese student Jun Lin in a framegrab from a video released at the Magnotta trial.
89
Diran Lin, father of victim Jun Lin, seen at the murder trial for Luka Rocco Magnotta Oct. 7, 2014 in Montreal. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Ryan Remiorz
99
Dong Dong Xu, a friend of victim Jun Lin, arrives to testify at the murder trial for Luka Rocco Magnotta Tuesday, Oct. 7, 2014. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Ryan Remiorz

Despite what forensic psychiatrists concluded, Bouthillier said, the jury should take into consideration other witnesses descriptions of Magnotta’s demeanor following the killing: knowledgeable, calm, cultured and well-groomed.

One German officer even said Magnotta was sitting with a grin on his face after being arrested, the Crown recalled.

Story continues below advertisement

Magnotta is charged with first-degree murder, committing an indignity to a human body, publishing obscene material, criminally harassing Prime Minister Stephen Harper and other members of Parliament and mailing obscene and indecent material.

READ MORE: Tracing Luka Magnotta’s footsteps, Part 3 or 3 The making of a killer

Although he admitted to the “physical acts” behind each charge, he is maintaining a plea of not guilty by reason of mental disorder.

Central to the jury’s decision is whether Magnotta was of sound enough mind to distinguish between right and wrong when he killed Lin.

In pleading its case, the defence focused on behaviours they’ve suggested are “out of touch with reality.” The Crown, meanwhile, zeroed in many of the same behaviours, telling the jury the actions prove awareness and pre-meditation.

READ MORE: Not criminally responsible myths, debunked

Standing at a lectern in front of the jury, Bouthillier was at the part of Magnotta’s timeline when the defendant left Paris for Berlin. This was on May 31 — seven days after he’d brought Lin home and two days after the victim’s torso was discovered in a suitcase.

“When he was identified by media as being wanted, as being in Paris, he fled quickly to Berlin to hide,” Bouthillier suggested to the 14-person jury. German police eventually arrested Magnotta on June 4.

Story continues below advertisement

Bouthillier then took a step back in time, to December 2011.

Five months before Magnotta killed Lin, he was in London. There, local reporter Alex West interviewed him about videos online purportedly showing Magnotta killing kittens.

Two days later, West’s newsroom received a menacing and vulgar email — long suspected, though only later confirmed, to have been penned by Magnotta.

READ MORE: Journalist describes meeting with ‘defensive and cocky’ Luka Magnotta in England

In it, Magnotta wrote he was behind the kitten-killing videos and had plans to move from little animals to humans. Moreover, he wrote of his intention to film the killing.

The grisly, repugnant video depicting Lin’s dismemberment and the indignities performed upon his corpse was played several times during his killer’s trial. For close to one minute of the video that quickly made the rounds online in the days following Lin’s death, there is footage of a man lying prone on Magnotta’s bed, bound to the metal mattress frame. That man, filmed between the night of May 18 and morning of May 19, isn’t Lin. Nor did police ever identify him.

READ MORE: Why is the court seeing Luka Magnotta’s gore video?

“I think this is important in showing the crime was planned,” Bouthillier said of the email to West. “In this email he said he was going to make a movie with a human. He started that movie on the 18, 19 of May, 2012. The first actor, unknown. And he ended the shooting of that movie on the 24, 25 of May, featuring Mr. Lin.”

Story continues below advertisement

Bouthillier recalled other actions Magnotta took, such as attempting to delete evidence of an email sent from his computer to a gore site containing a link to the snuff film, or apparently sullying the suitcase in which he stuffed Lin’s limbless torso.

“Why would someone do this?” Bouthillier asked the jury.

After a few breaths, he provided an answer to his own question: “Because they know right from wrong.”

GALLERY: The faces and places of Magnotta’s first degree murder trial.

18
Luc Leclair, lawyer for Luka Magnotta, speaks to reporters at the courthouse in Montreal, Monday, September 8, 2014. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Graham Hughes
28
Crown prosecutor Louis Bouthillier, left, leaves the courtroom as the Crown wraps up its case at the murder trial for Luka Rocco Magnotta Tuesday, Oct. 28, 2014 in Montreal. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Ryan Remiorz
38
Dr. Joel Paris, center, a psychiatrist who examined Luka Magnotta, leaves the courtroom after testifying at Magnotta's murder trial Tuesday, Nov. 25, 2014 in Montreal. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Ryan Remiorz
48
Witness Frank Rubert housed Luka Magnotta in Berlin for several days. Here, he's leaving the courtroom after testifying at the murder trial. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Ryan Remiorz
58
Exhibit D32: A note found in the package sent to Conservative Party offices in Ottawa and presented as evidence in the Luka Magnotta murder trial on October 20, 2014. HO
68
Police escort Luka Magnotta off the flight from Berlin after German officials released him to Canada. Montreal Police/HO
Story continues below advertisement
78
Members of the media stand outside the Internet cafe where Luka Magnottahe was recognized in Berlin on June 4, 2012. THE CANADIAN PRESS/AP, Markus Schreiber
88
Building manager Eric Schorer looks over Luka Magnotta's apartment in Montreal on Wednesday, May 30, 2012. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Ryan Remiorz

Everything Magnotta did, from cleaning his drab bachelor apartment to switching hotels in Paris, from deciding to travel under an assumed name after arriving in Europe to deleting online accounts, from wrapping body parts in three layers of plastic to putting other peoples’ names on the parcels, all indicate the defendant was aware of what he was doing and prove he was trying to hide, Bouthillier said.

Story continues below advertisement

“Is this the action of someone who is delusional, who doesn’t know right from wrong?” he asked.

Then, as if to beat the jurors to an obvious question, Bouthillier noted Magnotta left tracks.

“He was sure to be found. Who in their right mind would do that?”

It’s not too difficult to imagine a world in which Magnotta would have gotten away, Bouthillier said.

READ MORE: Magnotta trial hears of discovery of victim’s severed head

Had one man not become curious about the suitcase lying in the sun for three and a half days, it would have soon been picked up and brought to the city dump. Same goes for the rest of the evidence collected from the garbage on the curb.

Had the drug store post office not had video cameras, Magnotta may not have been identified since he didn’t put his name on any of the parcels he mailed.

Equally important, Bouthillier said, was that a Toronto lawyer sent a fax to police leading to the discovery of Lin’s head more than two months after the killing.

“If not for those three events, there may have been no case against Mr. Magnotta,” Bouthillier said. “Police got lucky, Nadeau was curious and Mr. Magnotta made some mistakes.”

Story continues below advertisement

“People who commit first-degree murders or other crimes get caught when and if they make mistakes or if the police get lucky, or a combination of both,” Bouthillier said. “This is what happened here.”

The judge will issue his final instructions to the jury Monday, after which 12 or the 14 jurors will be sequestered until they reach a verdict.

Sponsored content