TORONTO – Colon cancer screening tests for almost 6,500 Ontario patients have been lost in the mail and the provincial health agency who sent them to doctors’ offices says several thousand more could also be missing.
Cancer Care Ontario said Tuesday that 15 reports containing colon cancer screening details for 6,490 patients mailed to doctors in February and March were never delivered.
“We apologize for this loss. We regret this loss,” said Pamela Spencer, the agency’s chief privacy officer.
Cancer Care Ontario is also trying to figure out if 11 more report packages, with results for another 5,440 people, were delivered as intended.
The agency, tasked with improving cancer services, used Canada Post’s Xpresspost courier service to mail the screening activity reports, which included patients’ names, health card numbers and test results.
If a doctor had made a colorectal cancer diagnosis then that, too, would be in the report, the agency said.
The packages were part of its ColonCancerCheck program which aims to boost the number of Ontario residents aged 50 to 74 who are checked for colorectal cancer.
Cancer Care Ontario began looking into the delivery status of a handful of report packages after it was notified by a doctors’ office in late April that three reports had failed to arrive.
Get breaking National news
Xpresspost was supposed to get a signature confirmation for every package or return them undelivered, Spencer said. In mid-June a Canada Post investigation determined the three reports were handed over without signature confirmation and couldn’t be tracked down.
That touched off an internal agency review of all 6,951 report packages sent by courier earlier this year to make sure they were delivered.
The agency then asked Canada Post to track down additional reports it suspected were missing. Earlier this month the postal service concluded 15 packages were unaccounted for.
“We just don’t know what happened to them,” Canada Post spokesman John Caines said. He added the service “isn’t giving up” efforts to find where the deliveries went.
Spencer said Cancer Care Ontario held off announcing that reports had been lost so it could narrow down the number of packages that could be missing. Agency staff and other health officials have made visits to medical clinics across the province to check if the records arrived, she added.
“We have been consumed with our investigation to try to reduce (the) numbers so that we were not unnecessarily notifying people when in fact those screening activity reports had been received by the physicians’ offices,” she said.
The agency should know by next month if the 11 other reports can’t be tracked down, Spencer said. Canada Post says it’s looking for the packages.
Ann Cavoukian, Ontario’s information and privacy commissioner, says Cancer Care Ontario should have sent the records out electronically, and not in a format anyone can pick up and read.
“You can send either a USB key, or just a CD,” she said. “You can encrypt that, meaning you can send it in code.
“So if that falls into unauthorized hands – doesn’t matter, they get gibberish, they can’t access the data.”
Her office is investigating the incident for a possible privacy breach under the Personal Health Information Protection Act. Cavoukian said a document with someone’s name, date of birth and health card number could be a “gold mine” for identity fraud.
The commissioner’s office checks Cancer Care Ontario’s privacy practices every three years. But the last review was in 2008 – before the agency decided to send the colon cancer results out on paper.
That year the agency did a trial run, sending the colon cancer results to 105 physicians, said Dr. Linda Rabeneck, the agency’s vice-president of prevention and cancer control.
“We had no issues. So there was every reason to think that this approach would be successful,” she said, even though it had never been tried with so many recipients.
Spencer said the next batch of cancer activity reports will be sent out electronically, though the agency hasn’t decided to physically send them or put the information in an online portal for doctors.
She said letters will start being sent out Wednesday by courier to roughly half of the nearly 6,500 patients whose information is missing. The remainder of the letters will be mailed once the agency gets physicians’ permission to send them direct mail.
Comments
Want to discuss? Please read our Commenting Policy first.