Advertisement

Toronto executives: Your severance package could be worth far more than you think

A businesswoman looks out over the city from a corporate boardroom. Shannon Fagan/Getty Images.

Imagine being a Toronto vice-president who has just lost their job. Your employer offers 12 months of salary and describes the package as generous.

At first glance, it looks that way.

But what about your annual bonus? The restricted share units scheduled to vest next year? Your pension contributions, benefits and long-term incentives?

Those missing pieces can be worth tens or even hundreds of thousands of dollars. And once you sign a severance agreement, you may have given up the right to recover them.

My advice to senior executives is simple: do not judge a severance offer by the number of months of salary alone.

Your salary is only part of the calculation

Executive compensation is rarely straightforward. A senior employee might receive a base salary, annual performance bonus, commissions, stock-based awards, retirement contributions and other benefits.

Story continues below advertisement

When that person is fired without cause, the question is not simply how many months of salary the company has offered. It is what they would have earned over the notice period they are legally owed, taking their contracts into account.

An offer of 12 months of base salary can sound impressive while overlooking compensation that makes up a substantial part of an executive’s earnings.

That is why I want to see the entire compensation picture, not just the termination letter.

A bonus does not automatically disappear when you are fired

Employers sometimes tell executives that their bonus is unavailable because they were not actively employed on the payout date.

That is not necessarily the end of the matter.

The Supreme Court of Canada has confirmed that incentive compensation that would have been earned during the applicable notice period can form part of a wrongful dismissal claim, unless the governing terms validly take that right away.

The exact wording matters. So does the history of how the bonus was paid, when it would have been earned and what the employment agreement actually says.

Get breaking Canada news delivered to your inbox as it happens so you won't miss a trending story.

Get breaking National news

Get breaking Canada news delivered to your inbox as it happens so you won't miss a trending story.
By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy.

If your employer tells you that years of performance incentives simply vanish when your employment ends, have the documents reviewed before accepting that answer.

Story continues below advertisement

READ MORE: Boss took away your bonus in Ontario? 3 things you must do

Unvested shares can be worth real money

For executives in technology, finance and other industries, stock options, restricted share units (RSUs) and long-term incentive plans can be among the most valuable parts of a compensation package.

I have seen employees assume those awards are lost because a plan says they must be actively employed to vest. But the legal answer depends on the wording of the plan, the employment contract and the notice period.

An Ontario Court of Appeal decision involving millions of dollars in unvested RSUs is a useful reminder: a company’s forfeiture wording does not always have the effect the employer claims.

Do not treat an HR summary as a substitute for reading the underlying equity agreements.

READ MORE: Fired with unvested RSUs? Recent Ontario win could mean you’re owed more

Your employment contract may not settle the issue

Executives are often handed lengthy employment contracts when they join a company or accept a promotion. Years later, the employer points to one termination clause and says that is all they are owed.

Story continues below advertisement

Not so fast.

Some termination clauses are unenforceable under Ontario law. Others may affect which payments and benefits are included. Bonus plans and equity documents can also contain terms that interact with the employment agreement.

Signing a contract does not mean every provision in it will hold up. The documents need to be examined together before anyone can say what a severance package should contain.

The number of months matters, too

A senior job title does not automatically mean two years of severance. But executives can have substantial common-law severance rights because comparable senior positions may be difficult to find.

Age, length of service, the nature of the position, the availability of comparable work and enforceable contract  terms all matter.  In many circumstances, an executive severance package in Ontario can reach 24 months’ compensation.

An executive who has spent years building a career should not assume that Ontario’s minimum employment standards—or an employer’s first offer—represent the full amount they can claim.

Your departure is about more than the cheque

Money is often the biggest concern after an unexpected termination. For an executive, though, the terms of the departure can also affect what comes next.

Story continues below advertisement

Think about how the company will announce your exit, whether it will provide a reference, what you can say publicly and any restrictions on joining a competitor or contacting former clients.

These issues deserve attention alongside salary, bonus and equity. A poorly negotiated exit can complicate the search for your next senior role.

READ MORE: Tech exec’s severance victory: Turning termination into triumph

What I tell executives before they sign

First, do not let a short deadline rush you into signing a release. A deadline set by the company does not, by itself, erase your legal severance rights, even if a particular offer may expire.

Second, collect your employment agreement, termination letter, bonus plans, equity documents, vesting schedules and recent compensation statements. Each can change the value of the package.

Third, avoid negotiating only the number of weeks or months offered. You need to know which pieces of your total compensation are missing before you can evaluate a proposal.

If you have been let go from a senior role, speak with a Toronto executive severance lawyer before responding. My team at Samfiru Tumarkin LLP reviews the full package, not just the base salary, to determine what you are owed.

Story continues below advertisement

I tell executives this all the time: the company has already decided what it wants to pay you. That does not mean it has calculated what the law says you must receive.

Before you sign, always check first.

Contact Samfiru Tumarkin LLP or call 1-855-821-5900 for a consultation with an employment lawyer. Get the advice you need and the compensation you deserve.

Lior Samfiru is an employment lawyer and co-founding partner at Samfiru Tumarkin LLP, Canada’s most positively reviewed law firm specializing in employment law and long-term disability claims. He provides legal insight on Canada’s only Employment Law Show on TV and radio.

Sponsored content

AdChoices