Reality Check: No, Canadians aren’t ‘smuggling’ shoes across the border due to ‘massive’ tariffs

U.S. President Donald Trump commented on Tuesday that Canadians were “smuggling” shoes from the U.S. into Canada due to “massive tariffs,” but experts are calling this statement “incredibly misleading.”

People living in Canada are coming to the United States and smuggling things back into Canada because the tariffs are so massive,” Trump said Tuesday. “The tariffs to get common items back into Canada are so high, that they have to smuggle them in.

1:24 Freeland vows ‘equally clear and firm’ repose to Trump auto tariffs

• Freeland vows ‘equally clear and firm’ repose to Trump auto tariffs
• Freeland confident 160,000 auto sector jobs will be protected from U.S. tariffs
• China warns of swift retaliation after U.S. imposes new tariffs
• U.S. Tariffs getting people to buy Canadian
• Freeland ‘strong, measured’ retaliatory tariffs to be imposed on U.S.
• Pompeo ‘convinced’ tariffs won’t effect relationship with Canada
• Retaliatory tariffs will cost American jobs: Goodale
• Doug Ford on tariffs: ‘the fight shouldn’t be with Canada’
• Peterborough companies feeling effects of U.S. steel tariffs

Previous Video

Next Video

“They buy shoes and then they wear them. They scuff them up. They make them sound old or look old,” the president said.

However, while many Canadians are guilty of bringing products across the border without paying the appropriate fees attached, the reasons for this have little to do with tariffs, explained Walid Hejazi, an associate professor at the University of Toronto’s Rotman School of Management.

“It’s incredibly misleading. It is true that many Canadians go into the U.S. to do shopping, and they do not declare these things returning to Canada for a multitude of reasons,” Hejazi explained.

He emphasizes that any products made in North America, with the exception of a few, are not subject to any tariffs at all when being brought over the border. In the case where the item purchased was not manufactured in North America, not declaring the purchase stems more frequently from uncertainty about what needs to be declared and a reluctance to go through the hassle of doing so at the border.

In addition to the tariffs on products not made in North America, Canadians would also have to pay Canadian taxes on these products, should they declare them. Hejazi explained that each set of fees would likely amount to approximately CDN$40 each.

“The vast vast majority of goods and services across the Canada-U.S. border are not subject to tariffs. If they’re made in North America, there’s no tariffs. They would just cross the border freely, but if they’re made outside, there is a tariff, but they vary by product,” he said.

1:49 ‘Confident common sense will prevail’: Freeland on U.S. tariffs

• ‘Confident common sense will prevail’: Freeland on U.S. tariffs
• Canada to retaliate U.S. tariffs with its own dollar-for-dollar tariffs response
• Corker calls Trump’s tariffs an ‘abuse of presidential authority’
• Bob Corker says U.S. tariffs on Canada have yet to be approved
• Marco Rubio says U.S. should have confronted China with its allies instead of applying tariffs
• Marco Rubio says U.S. should have confronted China with its allies instead of applying tariffs
• Freeland says U.S. tariffs are illegal, unjustifiable and ‘insulting’
• Theresa May welcomes G7 agreeing to maintain Russia sanctions, condemns U.S. tariffs

Previous Video

Next Video

The bottom line, said Hejazi, is that Trump’s claim that Canadians are smuggling shoes and other items across the border to avoid “massive tariffs,” is simply false.

“It’s not true. The statement is not true that Canadians are wearing shoes and scuffing them up and bringing them back into Canada because of the massive tariffs,” he said, and went on to call the argument “completely disingenuous,” he concluded.

Greg Anderson, an associate professor in the political science department at the University of Alberta, added that he suspected Trump was referring to the personal duty exemption limits imposed by the Canada Border Services Agency (CBSA) when Canadians return from trips abroad. Depending on how long they’ve been out of the country, they are able to claim a certain amount on tax and duty-free basis.

1:22 Trudeau says Canadians ‘will not be pushed around’ over U.S. tariffs

• Trudeau says Canadians ‘will not be pushed around’ over U.S. tariffs
• Freeland: Canada rejects ‘illegal, unjustified’ U.S. trade tariffs
• Trudeau and tariffs: What will he say to President Trump?
• Putin calls U.S. tariffs on Canada ‘sanctions’
• White House denies report of extending exemption to Canada on tariffs
• Justin Trudeau on pipeline, trade and tariffs in 1-on-1 interview
• Trudeau on tariffs: ‘In what universe is Canada…somehow become a national security threat’ to U.S.
• Manufacturers in North Dakota worry about impact of tariffs, trade war
• ‘Tariffs protect the steel and aluminum industries’: White House

Previous Video

Next Video

Anderson adds that this is something that’s been on the “U.S. hit-list of Canadian barriers to trade for many years.”

He suggests, however, that the reason these policies irk the U.S. president is that the limits are “rather low.”

“These limits are rather low and are designed mainly to disincentivize Canadian cross-border shopping, or to protect merchants and firms on the Canadian side. In other words, if you have a low tax/duty limit and live in Southern Ontario, you are unlikely to slip across the border and grab a pair of running shoes in Buffalo and scuff them up (as Trump says) so you can “smuggle” them through Canada Customs,” Anderson said in an emailed statement.

1:52 Justin Trudeau, Chrystia Freeland talk tariffs on U.S. political shows

• Justin Trudeau, Chrystia Freeland talk tariffs on U.S. political shows
• China warns U.S. trade deal is off if Trump’s tariffs continue
• Trudeau calls Trump tariffs ‘insulting and unacceptable’
• Latest tariffs against Canada may be strengthening China’s hand: Yerxa
• White House economic adviser says Trudeau is ‘overreacting’ to Trump tariffs
• G7 allies call out U.S. over new tariffs
• Chrystia Freeland encouraged by some angry responses out of U.S. after Trump imposed new tariffs on Canada
• EU warns Trump tariffs could trigger ‘severe turbulence’ on global markets
• NDP question timeline of new Canada tariffs on U.S., Liberals want to consult first

Previous Video

Next Video

Trump made these comments while addressing the National Federation of Business in Washington. This comment marks the latest in a long line of insults aimed at Prime minister Justin Trudeau and at Canada in general since the G7 Summit concluded earlier this month. The summit took place shortly after the president announced new tariffs on Canadian steel and aluminum imports, which Trudeau followed up with CDN$16.5 billion in retaliatory tariffs, to come into effect on July 1 of this year.