Ontario government lifts ‘net zero’ bargaining condition for public-sector contracts

ontario politics wage freeze metrolinx
A file photo of Queens Park. File Photo

TORONTO – Ontario may be loosening the purse strings for the next round of public-sector bargaining as it has a balanced budget in its sights.

The Liberals have run deficits for about a decade, at one point going more than $20 billion into the red, and for the past several years have implemented wage restraint bargaining terms, including public-sector wage freezes. For the last round of contract talks, the government dictated that any wage increases negotiated in public-sector deals must be offset by savings elsewhere.

But now, as the Liberals say they are on track to reach balance with the 2017-18 budget, “net zero” has been dropped as a restriction of public bargaining.

READ MORE: ‘Net zero’ labour deal with Ontario teachers actually cost province extra $300M

Premier Kathleen Wynne released new mandate letters to ministers last week, with less than two years to the next election, and the letter to Treasury Board President Liz Sandals contained no mention of such terms.

Story continues below advertisement

“That was in a period in time and we’ve been through that period and it’s been a challenging time in those conversations with public-sector employees,” Wynne said Monday.

“We’ll go into a new round of negotiations recognizing that we need to continue to find ways to make decisions on compensation, on service delivery, that recognize the needs of the system and the needs of the individuals who work in the system.”

Sandals said a lack of “net zero” terms in her mandate letter doesn’t necessarily mean massive raises for public employees.

“Oh, I didn’t say we were going to make it rain,” she quipped.

“When you’re dealing with very large unions and very large contracts there’s always some challenges, so I would never anticipate that life will magically become easy when we’re talking about collective bargaining.”

Since about 2012, when a public-sector wage freeze was implemented, Ontario’s public collective agreements saw an average of 0.6 per cent increases, Sandals said, lower than the federal government and the private sector.

Progressive Conservative Leader Patrick Brown said the government never really abided by their own net zero terms anyway, so dropping it “seems pretty meaningless.”

READ MORE: Ontario teachers could be in ‘perpetual state of bargaining’

“It was a Wynne stretch goal in the first place,” he said.

Story continues below advertisement

A strike by correctional workers was narrowly averted in January after the government reached a deal with them that included a 1.4-per-cent lump sum payment for 2016 and a raise of 1.4 per cent in 2017.

But an arbitrator then awarded additional “special wage adjustments,” giving correctional officers 4.4-per-cent raises next year and 3.4 per cent for probation officers.

READ MORE: Ontario corrections staff avoid strike, reach tentative deal

The government had said the original deal with 1.4-per-cent raises was “net zero,” but it said even with the additional increases the deal as a whole was still cost neutral.

Teacher and education worker contracts came with a total $402 million in salary increases – a one-per-cent lump sum payment earlier this year and a one-per-cent raise on Sept. 1 with a further 0.5 per cent around January. The government said the deal was net zero, but it also came with an extra $300 million in costs to set up new benefit trusts.

Sandals, who was then the education minister, said “net zero” applied to offsetting wage increases, and the $300-million cost was not compensation.